The Steelers are switching things up on defense to free T.J. Watt so he can be even more of a game wrecker.

Their defense ranks second in the NFL in points allowed heading into their bye week at 6-2 in first place in the AFC North having allowed 14.9 points per game. In recent years, the Steelers’ defensive success has primarily come from its ability to sack the quarterback at a high rate. But in 2024, the Steelers only have 19 sacks through eight games, which ranks 17th in the NFL.

Watt’s 6.5 sacks rank seventh in the NFL and are impressive. But it’s below the standard he set when, in three of the last four seasons, he led the NFL in sacks.

Part of the reason for that has been the concerted effort of opposing offenses to stop Watt from being a difference maker. Pro Football Focus (PFF) added a new statistic to follow this season that tracks how often an edge rusher gets chipped — when an extra blocker helps momentarily — on a pass-rush play.

Advertise with us

Through Week 8, Watt leads all NFL players in being chipped — and it’s not even close. Out of his 269 snaps rushing the passer, Watt is charted by PFF as having been chipped 85 times, or 31.6% of his pass-rush snaps. The next-closest pass rusher in the NFL is the Raiders’ Maxx Crosby, who’s been chipped 47 times at 19.7%.

To do this, offenses will often line up their tight ends on Watt’s side along with a running back in the backfield to ensure the 2021 NFL Defensive Player of the Year has a harder time getting to the quarterback. Watt has lined up exclusively on the left side of the defense — over the right tackle of the offense — all season, and rarely has he switched to the opposite side of the defense over the past several years.

But Monday night, the Steelers flipped Watt and Alex Highsmith’s alignment for just a few plays, and it resulted in Watt and Highsmith each recording two sacks for the first time this season.

How offenses chip Watt

Here’s an example of what that looks like on a 3rd-and-3 in the second quarter, when the Giants had Daniel Jones in the shotgun. Watt is lined up in his traditional role on the left edge, and the Giants made sure to line up a tight end and a running back both toward Watt’s side on this play.

Knowing this, the Steelers tried to counter by having Watt twist inside on his pass rush behind Larry Ogunjobi’s stunt to try to get him a clearer path up the middle of the offensive line rather than around an offensive tackle, a tight end and a running back. But Giants center John Michael Schmitz Jr. was waiting for him and picked Watt up. The play resulted in an incomplete pass thanks to a key breakup by Minkah Fitzpatrick.

Advertise with us

To counter this, the Steelers moved Watt occasionally to the opposite side of the defense for the first time this season. PFF only charts it to have happened on four specific plays, but the impact of those few plays went into some of the biggest moments of the game.

“We’re trying it out to get some [attention] off T.J.,” Highsmith said after the game. “We just both [have] got to work our rushers from the other side. I think it was effective because we threw them off a little bit. It’s something we’ve just got to keep working on.”

Impact of the flip

The first time the Steelers tried to flip Highsmith and Watt’s sides came on the first play of the second quarter. But that play never began, as Giants guard Greg Van Roten jumped for a false start penalty.

When asked, the Steelers coaches said it was a collective decision to start making the flip happen, even if it was only for four official plays Monday night.

Those four snaps were the first time Watt lined up on the right side of the defense all season. That total in one game was the total combined that Watt had lined up there for his previous three seasons.

Advertise with us

“It was a little of both,” Steelers outside linebackers coach Denzel Martin said Wednesday of whose idea it was for the switch. “It’s about what we’re seeing on tape and how we’re attacking it. If they’re chipping heavily on one side and you can literally just go over to the other, sometimes that’s cool for us. But it’s week by week.”

Not all of the four plays when Watt lined up on the right side of the defense resulted in positive plays for the Steelers, but that wasn’t Watt’s fault. One such play came on a 26-yard run by Giants running back Tyrone Tracy Jr. in the third quarter. Though Watt was in the different spot, he did his job alongside Cam Heyward to maintain the edge of the defense and turn the run inside.

The hole opened up for Tracy toward the interior of the Steelers defense, where linebackers Patrick Queen and Payton Wilson both struggled to push through the Giants offensive line and close down the A-gap.

Part of the reason Watt and Highsmith have not flipped as much has been the dominance they’ve both displayed playing on their respective sides over the years. Since Highsmith became a starter for the Steelers in 2021, Watt’s registered 53.5 sacks, the most in the NFL. Highsmith has registered 30.5 sacks during that time, placing him 15th among NFL players during that span.

The natural chemistry the two have built from being on the same sides has played a role in their success. Several times, one player will pressure the quarterback while the other lies in wait to finish the play as the quarterback tries to escape.

Advertise with us

That was what happened on Watt’s first sack of the night, when both were lined up on their natural sides and Highsmith’s spin move chased Jones right into Watt.

Highsmith acknowledged that to get that kind of consistent success while the two are lined up on the opposite of their normal sides of the defense, it will take more reps in practice and in games.

“The moves we work is something we need to work on more,” Highsmith said Wednesday. “Doing it from the other side is something we need to practice more. When you’re moving from left to right, it’s a whole different body mechanic. It’s a different torque of your body to a different side. So we just need to get more reps at it from the [opposite] side.”

“It’s something we work every day during individual [drills],” Martin said. “It’s something we’re always trying to get better at. You need rushers on both sides and to put your moves on tape. Just need a plan to go with it.”

On one of the four plays Watt and Highsmith flipped, it was Watt who first got into the backfield before a Highsmith sack. Watt didn’t have a direct shot at Jones, but his rush forced Jones to move up in the pocket just enough so that when he tried to look for more space, Highsmith was right in position to finish the play with a sack.

Advertise with us

But the biggest impact of Watt and Highsmith flipping sides might be the plays when they line up in their natural positions after being on opposite sides. Steelers defensive line coach Karl Dunbar said simply moving the two around forces the offenses to communicate more about where each player is and can lead to plays when they forget to make calls at the line of scrimmage to send extra blockers to Watt’s side.

“It affects the offense and their protection more,” Dunbar said Wednesday. “That’s why we do it. The first games of the year, T.J. stayed on the left. But when you start moving him around and they don’t have their protections in — I think that’s what happened late in the game. They were seeing T.J. on the right and on the left, and when he was on the left, the quarterback didn’t check [the protection] to get him chipped, and he paid for it.”

The play on which Jones “paid for it” might’ve been the play of the game for the Steelers — Watt sacked Jones, forced a fumble and recovered it himself to spoil the Giants’ red-zone possession.

On that play, Giants right tackle Jermaine Eluemunor was without a tight end to help against Watt, and the only running back in the backfield didn’t help, either. That left Watt with one of the few opportunities he had in the game to be 1-on-1 with Eluemunor on a passing down. Watt capitalized, and it played a big role in the Steelers’ win.

While Watt and Highsmith flipping sides on the defense for only four plays doesn’t appear to be a big deal, you can see the impact it had late in a close game. As the Steelers head into their bye week, the two edge rushers will have more time to work on their chemistry, technique and timing to bring more of an impact on those plays.