One of my favorite Steelers stories to write, research and ponder each year is the best-case/worst-case first-round mock draft. Pre-draft content has become so prevalent that there are only so many ways you can slice it, and way back in 2020, I tried to come up with a different way of looking at it from a Steelers perspective.
If it’s your first time reading, it’s essentially a thought exercise that plays out the draft in two hypotheticals. First, if every team picking in front of the Steelers acted relatively within reason but in a way that just so happened to help the draft board look as promising as possible in Pittsburgh. And second, if every team picking in front of the Steelers made a fairly realistic choice that just so happened to hurt the depth at their projected positions of need.
In case you missed the ideal version already published, in that one, quarterback mania swept through the first 13 picks, edge rushers were popular, and most of the big fellas fell to the Steelers. But that was the good. Now, for the bad. In this alternate reality, Michael Penix and Bo Nix hype is overblown, with teams opting for foundational offensive linemen and trying to beat the open market by taking young, talented wide receivers. Let’s get to the pick-by-pick breakdown (for the sake of simplicity, no trades included, but it’s more about which names end up in which slots anyway):
1. Bears: Caleb Williams, USC quarterback
2. Commanders: Drake Maye, North Carolina quarterback
3. Patriots: Jayden Daniels, LSU quarterback
Read More
4. Cardinals: Marvin Harrison Jr., Ohio State wide receiver
The top three remain unchanged from the best-case mock draft, but the rush for receivers begins early with a prospect some view as the best overall player in the draft, regardless of position. Harrison going fourth likely only increases the stock of all the wideouts behind him, which could have a domino effect throughout the rest of the draft, and we know the Steelers need an upgrade at that position.
5. Chargers: Joe Alt, Notre Dame offensive tackle
6. Giants: Malik Nabers, LSU wide receiver
7. Titans: Olu Fashanu, Penn State offensive tackle
8. Falcons: Quinyon Mitchell, Toledo cornerback
9. Bears: Rome Odunze, Washington wide receiver
10. Jets: JC Latham, Alabama offensive tackle
This would be a bit of a gut-punch sequence for the Steelers. Not necessarily because they had any visions of those elite talents falling to them — other than Latham, perhaps — but for what it would do to the offensive tackle and wide receiver depth. And it’s not unrealistic for it to go this way. Blue chippers are particularly valuable at these spots, with teams trying to put their quarterbacks in good situations, not only to produce but to be evaluated. Even the Falcons, the most defense-likely team in the top 10, take from a position the Steelers could theoretically target early.
11. Vikings: JJ McCarthy, Michigan quarterback
12. Broncos: Brian Thomas Jr., LSU wide receiver
13. Raiders: Taliese Fuaga, Oregon State offensive tackle
14. Saints: Amarius Mims, Georgia offensive tackle
Not only are two more tackles gone, but they’re both right tackles, which would make more sense for the Steelers and their plan for 2023 first-rounder Broderick Jones. While Denver taking Thomas would be a bit of a surprise, they did trade Jerry Jeudy this offseason and could try to trade back up for a quarterback later. Or Sean Payton could stubbornly roll with Jarrett Stidham as the franchise looks ahead to 2025. Minnesota making McCarthy their guy isn’t bad for the Steelers, but seems like it’d be a given if he’s there at No. 11 and they stay at their spot.
15. Colts: Brock Bowers, Georgia tight end
16. Seahawks: Jackson Powers-Johnson, Oregon center
17. Jaguars: Nate Wiggins, Clemson cornerback
18. Bengals: Graham Barton, Duke offensive lineman
19. Rams: Troy Fautanu, Washington offensive lineman
Would Omar Khan start to think about trading up if it gets to this point? He probably would, but that would cost future draft capital and is exactly what makes this a nightmare scenario for the Steelers given their roster makeup. Fautanu is the last of the tackles that most draft analysts view as a top-20 pick but can also play guard. And as rare as it is to see a center go this high, the Seahawks don’t have many needs beyond an elite interior lineman. If that’s Powers-Johnson, then the near-consensus No. 1 center is plucked before the Steelers can even have a final decision on whether it’s worth using No. 20 on one. The most surprising aspect of this draft would be Alabama edge rusher Dallas Turner slipping to the back half of the first round.
Here’s who the Steelers would have to choose from in this universe — keep in mind that picking as high as 20th means some targets will still be available, starting with …
• Tyler Guyton, Oklahoma offensive tackle
• Jordan Morgan, Arizona offensive lineman
• Zach Frazier, West Virginia center
• Byron Murphy II, Texas defensive tackle
• Jer’Zhan Newton, Illinois defensive lineman
• Darius Robinson, Missouri defensive lineman
• Cooper DeJean, Iowa cornerback
• Terrion Arnold, Alabama cornerback
• Kool-Aid McKinstry, Alabama cornerback
• Adonai Mitchell, Texas wide receiver
• Keon Coleman, Florida State wide receiver
• Michael Penix Jr., Washington quarterback
• Bo Nix, Oregon quarterback
• Dallas Turner, Alabama edge rusher
• Jared Verse, Florida State edge rusher
• Laiatu Latu, UCLA edge rusher
• Chop Robinson, Penn State edge rusher
Frazier could be the solution the Steelers seek at center, but it’d be viewed as a reach by most. If they aren’t comfortable with Frazier that high and don’t trade down, then it’s settling for likely a lower-rated, one of the top three defensive linemen, a second-tier receiver or possibly DeJean, who did take a pre-draft visit. DeJean and Arnold both offer versatility, but teams tend to value the ceiling more than the floor in a top-20 pick. The “best player available” philosophy would be put to the test here, and there would be relatively few options at positions of need. Maybe they could go center-receiver-tackle in some combination with their first three picks, but it would be a lot tougher to get there this way.
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and @BrianBatko on X






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.