Welcome to Brian Batko’s Steelers mailbag. You can submit your questions for occasional offseason mailbags to Brian directly @BrianBatko on X and bbatko@post-gazette.com.

James in Fresno: Is there a viable FA that they can sign at Center, or do you see them moving up to get JPJ? Releasing Cole shows they have a dire need for the position. Would have to be a heck of a player left on the board to not draft JPJ in the first round.

Brian: Jackson Powers-Johnson out of Oregon is widely regarded as the best center in this draft, and it does feel as if the time is right for the Steelers to get back to going younger there after pivoting from Kendrick Green to a veteran in Mason Cole.

But the Steelers do tend to shore up positions of need to some extent in free agency before hitting them in the draft. Looking at the centers likely to be unrestricted free agents, there are a few who strike me as definite starters: Cowboys starter Tyler Biadasz, Broncos starter Lloyd Cushenberry and Raiders starter Andre James. They’ll all command quite a bit in a new deal with a different team or else their current teams would re-sign them.

Advertise with us

The next tier includes Dolphins starter Connor Williams, who went down with a torn ACL in December; Rams starter-turned-backup Brian Allen; and Texans backup-turned-starter Michael Deiter. All three are under 30 with starter experience and likely in the same financial range as Cole, who signed for three years, $15.75 million in 2022.

If you go the bargain route, you’ll be settling for someone over 30 like Connor McGovern, Cody Whitehair or Graham Glasgow, relatively inexperienced as a starter like Nick Harris or Trystan Colon or a former starter such as Matt Hennessy, who did play for Arthur Smith with the Falcons. Those last three would be here to compete with a rookie rather than step right into the lineup.

Dan in Bremerton, WA: Know there were issues with Mason’s snaps this past year but didn’t realize the Steelers were that unhappy about it that they would release him this early. Is there more to this than it seems on the surface?

Brian: I highly doubt it. From everything I’ve observed the last two years, Mason Cole was well liked by teammates, coaches and Steelers staffers. He was often a spokesman for the line throughout the week and after games, so he represented the franchise well in that regard. But releasing him early staves off a roster bonus when the new league year begins.

Actually, it wouldn't shock me if Cole gets a chance to see what offers come in for him, and if nothing materializes, he could always return as a backup for less money. Only he knows if he’s willing to swallow his pride and do that, but I wouldn’t rule it out. It just doesn’t seem likely to me that James Daniels or Nate Herbig would move to center full time.

Advertise with us

Steve C: I know you’ve gotten a million QB related questions but see if you have any interest in responding: For context I’m a generally positive Steelers fan. I understand that we likely need to go through a few KPs until we find the next ‘guy’. I don’t call for MT to get fired after every loss and I am thankful we aren’t a loser franchise because losing is for losers. Going 8-8 in 2019 after Ben’s elbow fell off was something I took pride in; never say die. One consistent behavior of the franchise I take issue with is that we have a proclivity to commit the sunk cost fallacy. I LOVE(D) Ben, but it was over after 2020 and we held on. Anyone with eyes could see that Matt Canada just wasn’t good at his job and we allowed him to see year three. Mason Rudolph is better than Kenny Pickett, but we’ll probably start Kenny over Mason (I’m not a ‘Mason will be the franchise QB’ truther). Pressley Harvin, I rest my case. What is your opinion? Do we hold on to our lost causes for too long and does it hold the franchise back from recapturing success more quickly?

Brian: Perhaps, but I imagine the Steelers would argue that over the course of time, that philosophy has done more good than harm. It’s tough to overlook the six Lombardi Trophies in their facility that way.

But, certainly, times change, and processes sometimes need to change accordingly. I wouldn’t say the Steelers are a franchise I consider to be on the cutting edge of NFL decision making these days. The 49ers and their recent run of success might be the best example of a team quickly realizing its mistake, cutting ties with Trey Lance after just two seasons, eight games and four starts and appearing to be better for it.

That doesn't mean the Steelers should abandon everything they believe in just because it worked for the reigning NFC champs. But it is living proof that every tough situation needs a thorough evaluation rather than a steadfast commitment to how you've always done it. If the Steelers come down on committing to Kenny Pickett for the start of his third season, they’ll have to understand that questions like yours will only get louder and louder.

Tom in Dallas: There has been endless chat about QB options. But let’s assume the most obvious: KP is the designated starter going into camp. The Steelers don’t sign any of the names being floated for QB2, but they do convince Mason to come back as the QB2 going into camp with the potential to be the starter if KP gets hurt or under performs in the first half of the season. If I remember correctly, Mason signed for $1M last year. The question is, what would be the expected contract to get him to sign for 2024 under this scenario?

Advertise with us

Brian: One national writer, Bill Barnwell of ESPN, doesn't expect Mason Rudolph to earn much more than he did a year ago this time. He projected him to fall in the category of quarterbacks who will sign new deals for around $1.5 million per year.

Other players in that group are Josh Dobbs, Mitch Trubisky, Blaine Gabbert, Tyler Huntley and Nate Sudfeld. I'm not sure I agree with Barnwell entirely on that, but it does go to show how Rudolph may be viewed outside of our Western Pennsylvania bubble.

Alan in Alabama: Good morning! I get the “no playoff wins in 7-years” or the “mediocre” mantra from so many BUT reading and listening to outlets lately, you would think the Steelers have been 2-15 for 7-8 years in a row to hear others talk about it. To me, a 10-win playoff team is NOT a “disaster” but is a team that needs to keep finding ways to improve. Also, I like the move away from the “keeping up with the Joneses” model that Pittsburgh and a few others are trending towards. If you’re in an arms race to beat KC, unless another Mahomes comes along soon, or a bunch of them, you might as well try something else. Other teams w Herbert, Burrow, Allen, etc. haven’t broken the code all the way. Your thoughts, Brian?

Brian: Part of me gets the sense that, whether they’d ever admit it or not, the Steelers had that in mind with the Pickett pick. Basically, finding the next superhero quarterback is a crapshoot, so you have a better chance of trying to zig while everyone else is zagging and winning in a different way. Pickett, on paper, was the quarterback in that 2022 draft with the highest floor for that sort of formula.

But is that even true? I can make the case it is not. The two quarterbacks who have kept the Chiefs from a ring in the Mahomes era are Tom Brady and Joe Burrow. Yes, those left in their wake include Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson but also Brock Purdy, Jimmy Garoppolo and Ryan Tannehill. But hey, at least those last three had good rosters around them and their teams tried something other than running out a highly drafted quarterback (or the GOAT, in Brady’s case).

Advertise with us

Ed H: Barring any trades, how will the Steelers choose to spend their seven draft picks in April’s draft? Might there be a position where the Steelers select multiple players?

Brian: Wish I knew, Ed. And my answer surely will change between now and late April, given that free agency has to transpire, quarterback dominoes must fall, etc.

But my best guess on Feb. 29 — hey, happy birthday to my Uncle Mark, the only leap year baby I know — is one quarterback, one wide receiver, one tackle, one center, one inside linebacker, one corner, one safety. Best possibility to double up is at corner, with an inside and an outside guy, but defensive line is more likely to knock off one of those seven before they’d invest two picks in one.

Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and @BrianBatko on X.