Gerry Dulac: OK kids...good morning from Indy. We'll be starting out chat in just a few minutes so get ready.....
Gerry Dulac: OK kids, here we go...fire away!!
Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: it has been reported in the PG that the Steelers might decide to keep Ogunjobi and pay him an additional $10 million this year because they want to avoid releasing him and absorbing a $7 million "dead" cap hit. In reality, the Steelers choices are to either vastly overpay Ogunjobi (again) this year and book $17m total at some point to the cap for him or to release him and book $7m. The release should be a very easy decision. After all these years, does the team still not really understand that "dead money" for released players is no different than the charges for players still on the team for previous money paid, but not accounted for? Most sophomore level economics majors understand "the sunk cost fallacy".
Gerry Dulac: I think they understand it better than you and me.
Tom: Generally speaking , the Steelers philosophy for years was to ignore the "high profile" positions like CB and LT in draft and FA. They found solid guys for those spots and put money and picks into "less profile" positions like S and RB. Seems the new GM brought a change to that with last years draft class, picking LT, CB, then DE. I feel there was a distinct difference in their impact, even as rookies. With a deep class would you want them to go LT and CB again and domiate at impact positions? Or go back with a C in Rd 1, improving but not quite getting the impact edge?
Gerry Dulac: Personally, I like the idea of a big-time center and an off-the-ball LB
Read More
Tom: Always feel that projections/rankings are most accurate now before combine media hype begins. One or two fly up rankings every year (QB's are mind boggling but understandable). Steelers got suckered with Devin Bush. The C from Oregon is clearly the top guy, with next two a few rounds behind. Seems like the C Frazier will be the guy hyped this year and Steelers will take him in Rd 2. Do you feel this is accurate? Why do teams predictably fall for media hype EVERY year?
Gerry Dulac: I don't think the teams fall for the hype. The media and the fans fall for the hype.
SPQR: I often disagree with your opinions but respect your reporting. I thought your piece on why trading for Justin Fields is not a great idea really hit the mark. What would seem to make sense to me would be to draft a QB in the middle of the draft. Not necessarily to challenge to start this season, but perhaps in 2025 or develop as a long-term backup.
Gerry Dulac: You're not the only one who thinks that would make sense.
Tom: 100% honest question...Why do teams have scouting departments, nowadays? You could get medical from combine, coaches can meet players predraft, then just Google Daniel Jeremiah's or any BigBoard the morning of the draft. It basically falls exactly how the players are ranked. Some variations to the type/size of a player a team likes. There are almost never any crazy suprises, and the few that are (think Seattle or Oakland) have been busts. Scouting departments fail with busts more than they uncover gems not in a magazine. True?
Gerry Dulac: Where do you think guys like Daniel Jeremiah get their info???
Bill in LA: Based on Cam Heyward's age and salary and poor production last year, why not just cut him? Why would nostalgia even come into play?
Gerry Dulac: Oh, ok
Bill in LA: For Mike Tomlin, wasn't Presley Harvin's release similar to Matt Canada in that Tomkin knew after two years both were below average but gave them a third year to be rhe sane anyway?
Gerry Dulac: And look who is entering his third year....
Bill in LA: Pat Freirmuth wasn't very productive last year even when not injured. If next year is similar what kind of new contract do the Steelers offer him?
Gerry Dulac: Well, I think he will be offered a new contract before next season. Plus, Arthur Smith loves to involve tight ends.
Mar: Who do you think Steelers take with 20 th pick? Also do you see the team signing Russell Wilson we can’t go into season thinking Kenny Pickett is the answer we need a reliable back up just in case he struggles in camp people and the Steelers organization has to realizes the guy is about to be 26 years old 13 TD and 13 interceptions in 2 years is bad. Also he only had 2 TD in one game in 2 seasons that’s not good also everyone wants to say he’s clutch I can make a argument our defense kept us in all them games to give us a chance to win it wasn’t qb play if u look at the whole game the guy struggle the entire game the Steelers just have a good roster and shouldn’t waste it on him for another year and Ryan tannehill u can just kiss the season goodbye if u go in with Pickett and tannehill not good options thought Mason Rudolph was good
Gerry Dulac: I don't see Russell Wilson signing with the Steelers because I don't think he wants to go somewhere to be a backup
Mike: I read your article on why a Justin Fields trade doesn’t make sense and I agree completely. Not sure why everyone thinks this is going to happen. I don’t feel like Justin Fields ceiling is much higher than what they already have nor do I think he will make them a SB contender. It feels like a move that will keep them in similar territory as they currently are. If they are going to make a trade I would rather see them move up in the draft if they like one of the QBs coming out of college. They need a franchise QB to take them to the next level. At the end of the day, I think they are going to roll with Pickett and sign a vet such as Tannelhill.
Gerry Dulac: I think you're right, but the only way they are signing a vet QB to be No. 2 is if Rudolph signs elsewhere
Charmy: Who do you think is the most overrated prospect as of now?
Gerry Dulac: Can't answer that one, sorry.
Pistol33: Thanks for the chats Gerry!! Dorin says the Steelers love Nix. Not in the first but after that. What have you heard??
Gerry Dulac: I haven't, but someone like Nix would make sense in day 3 if he's still there.
Infinite: If the Steelers were to double dip on one position in the draft, which would it be?
Gerry Dulac: Good question....Maybe ILB.
Alan in Alabama: Morning! Looking to the future, is Danny Rooney a full-time employee of the Steelers and is he present day-to-day w the organization? Is he at the games, including road games? I’m just curious how involved he is at this point. Does he interact w players at all? Thanks!
Gerry Dulac: Yes he is. But he doesn't interact with the players other than to say hello if he sees them
Tiki Harp: Hi Gerry. Don't get all the "get rid of Pickett" talk. The guy had a horrible OC and Scheme with a poor OL and almost no receivers. Not to entail a questionable development record for the HC. Still managed to have a decent record and some great comebacks And not even 2 years of games in. These people would have dumped Bradshaw who took like what until year 4 to get good? Pickett showed he has the tools. He just needs to settle in AND get some good player help around him. What say you?
Gerry Dulac: Well, I kinda agree with you about all the "get rid of Pickett" talk. But not about the poor OL and no receivers part. And I'm still not sure he has shown he has all the tools
Guest: Hey Gerry. One position we have really struggled at finding is ILB. The last 10 starters for Tomlin are Roberts, Holcomb, Bush, Jack, Schoebert, Spillane, Williams, Barron, Bostic, and Shazier. The last 5 starters for Cowher were Farrior, Foote, Bell, Holmes, and Kirkland. The difference is huge. Is this a weak spot for Tomlin? Is it just the scheme? Or was LeBeau the difference maker and just that much better of a defensive coordinator than Tomlin? This needs to be improved and get back to the way it was in the Cowher days.
Gerry Dulac: Yes it does!!
Guest: Enough of this crazy quarterback talk. Sign Mason (ask him nicely MT) and pick up a promising arm later in the draft. Then give Pickett every opportunity to improve under a competent NFL level offensive coordinator (and have Tomlin let him do his job). Actually have a fair competition for the starting position in camp- Mason is owed that. Then move on to other matters. We don't need Wilson or Fields. If Picket turns out not to be the "anointed one" look for a franchise guy in next year's draft.
Gerry Dulac: Who let this smart guy in the chat??
KW: Gerry, Thanks for the chats. Any word on Holcomb and Alexander?
Gerry Dulac: None, other than they are rehabbing
Jeff M: DL is a big need for the Steelers. Do you think Byron Murphy would be an option at #20?
Gerry Dulac: Yes it is. And I wouldn't rule it out
islandborn: How much, if any, do the minority owners have a say in the team's operation - notably the draft picks? What about coach staffing (fire/hire) decisions? Thanks!
Gerry Dulac: None
Mar: why is it so hard for the Steelers to see they made a mistake? Why do they hold on to players to long? Mr Rooney he’s a good owner but at the same time I feel as a fan he is stuck in his old ways this is a passing league u need good qb play to win Pickett ain’t it tomlin also need to change his ways im tired of the never losing season as Steelers fan we are about championships.
Gerry Dulac: I don't think the Steelers are holding on to Pickett "too long" after being a starter for just 1 1/2 seasons
Andrew in ATL: Hi Gerry, obviously this is a big year for Kenny. That being said, in your years of covering the sport has anything changed more than how quickly fans and the media expect a young QB to develop? Very few have looked like world beaters in year 1 or 2. Other than Mahomes, Marino, and now maybe Stroud all QBs take a few years to develop into what they will become. Imagine if Bradshaw's first few years happened in today's world. Fans and the media would've wanted him traded for bag of footballs don't you think?
Gerry Dulac: Agreed!!
JPinIndy: Good morning Gerry! Is there a position group that you're most interested to observe this week in Indy?
Gerry Dulac: DTs (Murphy), C (Powers-Johnson), ILBs (Cooper). Remember those names.
Kool Aid Yinzer Man: I think if the Steelers draft oline early and add another wr that Pickett can win mvp and the Steelers win the Super Bowl, this season. Good prediction?
Gerry Dulac: Yep. Not bad
Bill: masters winner?
Gerry Dulac: Ludvig Aberg
epiballo: Hi Gerry! Thanks for the chats! Assuming that Rudolph would be the smart choice for QB2 and next up should Pickett falter or yet another injury, should he sign elsewhere, which other of the rumored QBs do you think would be the best fit for QB2?
Gerry Dulac: I'm not really thrilled about what's out there to bring in. Tannehill and Mariota, each of whom played under Arthur Smith, would appear to be the most logical.
Andrew in ATL: Is art Rooney III more or less involved in football decisions than his father was?
Gerry Dulac: I'd say he has the same involvement, though their styles might be a little different
Linebacker Lounge: My Google is broke down, can you tell me who has won more games the past 3 years - Pickett or Fields?
Gerry Dulac: Pickett has 14, fields 10
Danny: Why haven't the steelers released Robinson or peterson yet
Gerry Dulac: Patience.
Sal: Hay Gerry! I hope you have a great time at the combine. What are your thoughts on free agency ? Any potential signing ?
Gerry Dulac: I don't think they will be as active as they have been the past two years
Linebacker Lounge: Holcomb is injury riddled.. Where do we get a off ball ILB?
Gerry Dulac: Draft
Danny: Do u do a mock draft if so when will u do it
Gerry Dulac: I do not, sorry.
Linebacker Lounge: Morning Gerry, is Patrick Queen an option or will the price be to steep?
Gerry Dulac: He'd be a great fit!!
epiballo: Which non-Steeler FA do you think has the inside track and is most likely to be signed to the team? I hear a lot about Queen from Baltimore; is that a real possibility?
Gerry Dulac: It's an intriguing possibility. I don't know how realistic it is. And don't know if the Ravens want to let him walk.
Danny: If the steelers resign rudolph would they still try to sign another qb or would they draft one
Gerry Dulac: I would think a day-3 draft pick
Anonymous: Hey Gerry hope all is well, Who would you want to be the starting QB for next season?
Gerry Dulac: Ben
Greentree Greg: Surely you've been to all, or most, nfl stadiums. What are your top 3? Where would you rank Acrisure?
Gerry Dulac: After being in Vegas this year, I've been to them all. Lucas Oil, where I am right now, is my favorite for several reasons. Raymond James in Tampa has always been at the top of my list for outdoor stadiums. Mercedez Benz dome in Atlanta is a bit extreme on the outside -- looks like something from Star Wars -- but it is really cool inside. SoFi is exceptional, but a logistics nightmare
Linebacker Lounge: Did Lions Reeves-Maybin signing raise the price of poker for Killebrew to return?
Gerry Dulac: Maybe. But not impossible. That might be the Steelers most important free-agent re-signing after Rudolph
Stan the Caddy: Gerry, If Rudolph comes back do you personally believe there will be a true, open competition? Will they actually split the first team reps during OTAs, training camp, and the pre-season or will it look more like 2022?
Gerry Dulac: Maybe somewhere in between.
Mar: Anyone going blame Colbert? For this mess why was he allow to draft when a new gm was coming in I think we all can agree he reached on Pickett he was horrible the last 5 years
Gerry Dulac: I'll take a poll.
STEEL72: Hi, Gerry. At what position do you feel Omar may strike for a big ticket FA and pay the money to upgrade there over the draft? It seems as if getting the right veterans made a difference last year until injuries hit (and those players weren't big money signings). Roberts, Holcomb, Alexander, Rowe off the top of my head.
Gerry Dulac: ILB or S
X Yunzer: Gerry - thanks for the chats - I enjoy your viewpoint. I no longer live in Pgh so i wind up being exposed to alot of Steelers news - mostly national stories. To me the whole thought process about them getting Wilson is ridiculous - #1, Wilson will be able to choose where he goes after he gets fired; #2 Wilson needs to be a starter not a backup or else he'll be out of football after next year and the Steelers are not going to elevate Wilson over Pickett absent injury or poor play by Pickett; #3 Wilson is a weird selfish dude and has turned into a locker room cancer now that he can't single handedly win games in the 4th quarter. No chance he comes to the Steelers; no chance the Steelers want him. Thoughts?
Gerry Dulac: Correct. I think RW still wants to be a starter and there is no guarantee of that at all with the Steelers
Linebacker Lounge: People talking Jonnu Smith to Steelers. Seems TE room is already full. Thoughts ?
Gerry Dulac: Correct
Nick Danger: Much to the dismay of J Sinns, Sara J & the nattering nabobs of negativity in PGH talk radio, the Steelers will not be bringing in RW, JF or KC. The upside of any of the 3 is not that great once the cost is factored in. I say let's see KP w/ a new OC & then decide. Agree?
Gerry Dulac: Hey ND, IA
62 Stack Monster: Good morning, Sir! Down here in Miami, the locals are vying for Jackson (?) Center from Oregon and I believe the Doplphins pick after the Steelers. Will Mr Khan trade up for him?
Gerry Dulac: I think he'll still be there at No. 20. Only two centers have been drafted in the first round the past four years and the last one, Tyler Linderbaum, went at No. 25 to the Ravens.
Charlie: Gerry, could Starkey card better than an 86 if granted an invite to a PGA Tour qualifier?
Gerry Dulac: Did you say 186??
Marc from Germany: Hi Gerry! Has anybody at the combine already been able to catch your eye, who wasn't on your radar already?
Gerry Dulac: No because there haven't been any workouts to watch
Pat from Ellwood city: Hi Gerry do think they will go center in the draft or go in house with Daniel
Gerry Dulac: It won't be James Daniels.
steve: Hi Gerry - golf question here. It's hard to imagine just how many wins Scottie Scheffler could have if he could just make 10' putts. Tee to green he's incredible. Do you think he's got a major win or two in him this year?
Gerry Dulac: Yes I do. Maybe the first one
Tony: Good morning Gerry. I have only one simple question for you. It's possible that you've heard this question before. Who do you believe will be the Steelers starting quarterback this year beyond the first 3 games?
Gerry Dulac: I have not heard that one before. I'll stick with the safe bet -- Pickett
Guest: While Smith is certainly an upgrade over Canada, that is not difficult to do. We still kept the likes of Austin, Sullivan, Faulkner, etc. It seems like preparation and game planning have been a bigger problem than talent and players for a long time. Couldn't we have done much more to improve the coaching staff?
Gerry Dulac: I don't have a problem with the staff. I just would've liked to see one more move
Tom M.: The best way to a Super Bowl is with a franchise QB. There have been teams get there without one if they have an elite defense. I think that’s what the Steelers are trying to do. But, even though the Steelers have invested a lot of $$
Gerry Dulac: Not many. Most have won with the elite QB. Just go back and check the past 25 years.
Sal: Gerry: any progress on Mason Rudolph’s contract negotiations?
Gerry Dulac: None yet
Stash: Gerry, what's with all this love Harbaugh is sending Tomlin's direction? Of course he loves Tomlin - their recent playoff records are pathetically similar, no?
Gerry Dulac: What else you want him to say??
willie wood: Are you enjoying the underwear olympics?
Gerry Dulac: Not yet...
AZPGH: The steelers will never do this, but would you consider offering Watt and our next two 1st round picks to the Bears for the #1 overall pick? JJ started going downhill at age 29. TJ is now 29. His value is extremely high right now. We had some of the best defensive players in the league in the 90's but won nothing w/o a QB. Would it be wise to move off TJ now if it can get you the #1 pick?
Gerry Dulac: TJ and two No. 1s, eh????
Jim_Bow_Dean: How is it possible the Bengals have the 10th most cap space available and the Steelers have the 10th least available?
Gerry Dulac: I don't think it is possible with Joe Burrow's contract. But the Steelers have a lot of money invested in 39, 90 and 97
Rick Woods: If Mason Rudolph is interested in resigning, when would you expect that to happen in the next two weeks? I haven’t noticed any team signing any of their soon to be free agents at this point. Is there a reason for that? Do teams typically wait until after the combine to begin resigning their free agents? Thanks.
Gerry Dulac: Yes
Henry: Due to Colbert's dismal drafting the last five years the team has no depth. Should they consider trading down to get more picks?
Gerry Dulac: I don't think they have any intention of doing that
Linebacker Lounge: Gerry, it seems you have warmed up to a Center.. and out of no where an off ball LB. You have been adamant about DL for a year! What has changed? Thanks
Gerry Dulac: i am still adamant about a DL -- a big-time, Pro Bowl-type DL. This draft is a little thin on top DL prospects. So that's why I'm looking at possibilities elsewhere. But, if that gut is out there, I still think DL is way to go
Linebacker Lounge: Some of the Pickett has only thrown 2 TDs in one game has to fall on Canada and the offense?
Gerry Dulac: It didn't stop Rudolph
Guest: Hey Gerry do you believe in Kenny Pickett?
Gerry Dulac: It is not my job to believe in him. My original opinion of him has not changed.
Stash: Gerry, why do all the Pitt alumni insist that KP has all the tools when in fact his arm is very suspect, in terms of both accuracy and velo (Tiger's term for velocity, for the non-golfers out there).
Gerry Dulac: You've noticed that??
Stillers: Regardless of the opinions of Tomlin and Management, do you believe Kenny is the franchise guy?
Gerry Dulac: I never thought he was a "franchise" QB.
Alan F: So based on your comments in these Chats, Steelers will put all "their eggs in one basket" w/ Kenny regardless of the outcome (good or bad) and their backup QBs (should Kenny doesn't improve) will be Ryan Tannehill & a developmental QB coming out of the draft?
Gerry Dulac: No, I never said they will put all their eggs in his basket. What I've said is they will start camp with a couple eggs already in there.
Hogan: Gerry, any decent courses in Indy in case you get tired of hanging out with Ray and watching prospects run around orange cones?
Gerry Dulac: Not after the temperature just dropped 40 degrees in two days. Ugh
Brian in VA: No matter who the Steelers bring in to the quarterback room in 2024, do they really have to worry about Pickett’s feelings ? It would seem silly not to have some competition after the qb play we suffered through last season
Gerry Dulac: No they shouldn't. This is the NFL, not fourth grade
Guest: Steelers record prediction next year?
Gerry Dulac: 11-6
willie wood: If the Steelers are going to stay with the status quo at Qb, citing the San Francisco model as proof that if you build your skill positions and offensive line, you can be successful with a game manager type at QB,.... who is our Kyle Shanahan?
Gerry Dulac: I'm spending too much wondering what you mean by that reference...
Guest: My biggest concern with Pickett is his ability to stay on the field. injured alot in short career. Steelers should stay put with QB's. No clear answer in draft or free agency. Upgrade the roster via the draft and they will be competive with Rudolf as QB.
Gerry Dulac: I get your point, but their objective is to be more than competitive, even though we haven't seen a lot of that lately
Brian in VA: If Darnell, Washington’s knees are shot, won’t the Steelers need a second string pass catching tight end with the new coordinator?
Gerry Dulac: I'd like to see them involve him more
Stash: Gerry, why don't these Pitt aums acknowledge that Bradshaw could throw a tight spiral through a car wash without getting it wet, while KP's toss would collapse in a soggy pile of leather within the first 10 feet?
Gerry Dulac: Cause they don't remember
Tom in TN: Gerry, would like your thoughts or predictions on the QB situation heading into new season. I don’t believe the Justin Fields rumors are the answer.
Gerry Dulac: I would agree with that. https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2024/02/27/justin-fields-...
Stash: Gerry, is Starkey correct that TB would be welcomed back with open arms if there were a Bradshaw extravaganza? I'm thinking it would respectful, but slightly muted? And not nearly as funny as Jagr's.....
Gerry Dulac: I don't know what he said
Bob in Az: Will you be going to St. Elmo’s?
Gerry Dulac: Check
Guest: Gerry what's 9+10?
Gerry Dulac: OK, I give..??
Stillers: Gerry, if the Steelers just run it back with Kenny, Mason, and a rookie, all things considered, what do you think the ceiling of this team is? I personally feel like it’s no more than a wild card win.
Gerry Dulac: A playoff win? Really? They'd take that right now
Danny: If they steelers keep Robinson is there a chance they trade dj
Gerry Dulac: No
John: Hi Gerry, Did the Steelers even kick the tires on signing punter Matt Araiza before the Chiefs got him?
Gerry Dulac: Not that I'm aware, but don't know for sure. They kick the tires on a lot of guys. Just how hard I can't say for certain
Michael: Hi Gerry, when do the Steelers win the Superbowl? My prediction is 2027
Gerry Dulac: That's fair, if not optimistic
John: Which does Tomlin like better at the Combine? Evaluating the prospects or the seemingly hundreds of free dinners?
Gerry Dulac: Evaluation. The dinners come at the pro days
Gene: What round do you think they will draft a WR?
Gerry Dulac: Maybe 2. Or 3. Depends who's there
Michael: Do the Steelers draft McCarthy or do we get Wilson?
Gerry Dulac: It's not the latter. McCarthy makes some kind of sense
Pete in Macungie: Do you think a player like Fletcher Cox of the Eagles would be a nice depth fit for the defensive line?
Gerry Dulac: Best days are behind him. Not their style
Michael: Would you be willing to acquire Jalen Hurts or Patrick Mahomes for draft picks?
Gerry Dulac: Why don't you just ask if Ben can come back??
Steve in Canton: Who gets the biggest piece of "blame pie" for drafting and overvaluing Kenny? (Former GM Colbert, Coach T, the Khan artist) Please don't say "collaborative effort."
Gerry Dulac: It's not Omar. Wasn't his job then
Dave: Do you listen to JR Sports Brief? If so thoughts?
Gerry Dulac: No
Lefty: Ok. I'll bite. What is the "one more move" you would have liked seeing on the coaching staff?
Gerry Dulac: Ahhhh, very perceptive!!
Steve in Canton: Will you continue to do these chats when you retire? I'm sure they're the highlight of your week!
Gerry Dulac: Oh no. and Oh yeah
SteelGuys: Way too early record predictions for the 2024 season?
Gerry Dulac: 11-6
Steve in Canton: Trubisky being talked up as a possible Browns' backup QB. Good fit?
Gerry Dulac: Yep
chris: With multiple holes to fill and increase in cap space why do you think Steelers wont be as active in FA?
Gerry Dulac: It's just because they were uncharacteristically active the past two years
Anthony: When dolling out the blame, let's make sure we are pointing at the person who has the final say. Who is most responsible for who gets drafted...Tomlin or the GM?
Gerry Dulac: That is an age-old question
Teddy: Will Cam Heyward be back next year? Will they extend his contract soon?
Gerry Dulac: Yes
Ct Stan: Gerry, do think it would be better to get a first round C for eight or nine years than a CB for five maybe six years.
Gerry Dulac: Right now, yes
chris: You stated Steelers would'nt be interested in Fletcher Cox because its not their style then how do you explain Pat Peterson?
Gerry Dulac: Now that's a really good question...
Guest: I don't think he is the answer, but would the Steelers consider trading for Zach Wilson? He does have the pedigree.
Gerry Dulac: I wouldn't say with a trade...
Gerry Dulac: OK kids, that's all the time we have. Thanx for the questions






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.