When we debuted this exercise last year, it was harder in some ways, but easier in others. On one hand, the Steelers didn’t even have a first-round pick, and then there were 16 more players drafted in the second round before they were finally on the clock. So, the range of outcomes was wide, to say the least.

But there were also more clearly defined needs this time a year ago. It was painfully obvious after 2019 that the Steelers needed to add an offensive playmaker, and after the failed Donte Moncrief experiment, wide receiver seemed like the most logical avenue to do so. This draft, though? There are enough areas in need of new blood that Kevin Colbert and Mike Tomlin can seriously consider just taking the best prospect available — which is exactly what they claimed they will do Monday.

Still, for the sake of this concept, we’re going to work under the assumption that running back and offensive line are atop the to-find list, above a bevy of defensive positions from cornerback to inside linebacker to outside linebacker. In this mock draft, we unfurl the ideal Thursday evening for the Steelers — and we try to do so within reason. That means Trevor Lawrence won’t fall to them at No. 24, and teams ahead of them won’t be picking guys projected to go on Saturday afternoon.

However, we will take some liberties in order to set up an ideal draft board for the Steelers, one in which good players at their weak spots fall all the way to the final third of the first round. We also aren’t factoring in trade possibilities. Without further ado …

Advertise with us

1. Jaguars — QB Trevor Lawrence

2. Jets — QB Zach Wilson

3. 49ers — QB Mac Jones

4. Falcons — QB Justin Fields

Here’s the first real inflection point of any mock draft. In this one, four quarterbacks go in the first four picks for the first time ever. This is a good domino effect for the Steelers, who in a perfect world might love to have any of the above passers waiting in the wings behind Ben Roethlisberger, but none of whom would help them this year.

Advertise with us

5. Bengals — WR Ja’Marr Chase

6. Dolphins — WR DeVonta Smith

7. Lions — OT Penei Sewell

8. Panthers — TE Kyle Pitts

If Oregon’s Penei Sewell falls to No. 7, that will push down every other tackle behind the consensus top lineman, one that has been called a generational prospect by some analysts. Same goes for Pitts, who, like Sewell, probably shouldn’t fall out of the top five given how special he is at the tight end spot. It could happen, though, if the QB run plays out at the top, followed by the Bengals and Dolphins reuniting their second-year quarterbacks with their favorite targets from college.

Advertise with us

9. Broncos — QB Trey Lance

10. Cowboys — ILB Micah Parsons

11. Giants — OLB Kwity Paye

Cowboys fans might storm Lake Erie if they don’t beef up their secondary, but hey, keep in mind that in this world Jerry Jones is trying to help out the Steelers by dropping some can’t-miss cornerbacks into their lap. Penn State’s Parsons is no slouch, and arguably the best defensive prospect in the draft. Also, this could be a reach for Paye, but the Giants need pass-rushing firepower, so they opt for one of those athletic marvels and hope he pans out.

12. Eagles — WR Jaylen Waddle

Advertise with us

13. Chargers — OT Rashawn Slater

14. Vikings — CB Jaycee Horn

15. Patriots — CB Patrick Surtain II

We couldn't hold off any longer at offensive line and cornerback, where the Steelers need to replace a couple starters. But Slater lasting all the way until No. 13 would be a bad sign for the rest of the tackles who hoped to hear their names called in the top half, while Horn and Surtain go later than expected, but are too good to pass up and finally get things started at cornerback. (Side note: The Vikings have never had a player named Horn, and that’s a long time coming. Like, a thousand years, give or take.)

16. Cardinals — WR Elijah Moore

Advertise with us

17. Raiders — DL Christian Barmore

18. Dolphins — OLB Azeez Ojulari

Now we get into what would be classified as reaches, but they would be reaches that benefit the Steelers, who shouldn’t be in the Round 1 market for receivers, defensive linemen or edge-rushers. Moore would be the biggest shocker here, but the Cardinals addressed a lot of needs this offseason and could be salivating at the thought of Kyler Murray having a 4.35-speed demon to play with. Also, take note of the Dolphins opting for Ojulari over a running back …

19. Washington — ILB Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah

20. Bears — WR Rashod Bateman

Advertise with us

21. Colts — DE Jaelan Phillips

Three more teams that could draft an offensive lineman passing on offensive linemen. Virginia Tech left tackle Christian Darrisaw is dropping like a rock. Same goes for USC’s Alijah Vera-Tucker. There aren’t many flaws in their games, but if teams view this as a draft class deep with offensive line talent — specifically at tackle — they could be content to wait and go high-upside instead. That’s exactly what Bateman would be for the Bears, who have Allen Robinson on the franchise tag, and what Phillips would bring to the Colts, who must replace Justin Houston and Denico Autry.

22. Titans — WR Kadarius Toney

23. Jets — DE Gregory Rousseau

Wow, two more teams passing on the consensus third- and fourth-best offensive linemen in the whole draft. But the Titans and Jets also have other needs, namely, playmakers on either side of the ball. The Titans may shy away from guys with off-field incidents given how 2020 first-rounder Isaiah Wilson flamed out in one season, but Toney is a huge play waiting to happen. As for the Jets, the 6-foot-7 Rousseau could join their long list of draft busts — Vernon Gholston, anyone? — but in this universe, they swing for the fences.

Advertise with us

Which brings us to …

On the board for the Steelers

• RB: Najee Harris, Travis Etienne, Javonte Williams

• OT: Christian Darrisaw, Alijah Vera-Tucker, Samuel Cosmi, Teven Jenkins, Alex Leatherwood, Jalen Mayfield

• C: Creed Humphrey, Landon Dickerson

Advertise with us

• CB: Caleb Farley, Greg Newsome

• ILB: Zaven Collins, Jamin Davis

• OLB: Jayson Oweh, Carlos Basham, Joseph Ossai, Joe Tryon

There’s something here for everyone in Steeler Nation (unless you’re gung ho on finding Roethlisberger’s successor). Running backs? Not a single one went in the first 23 picks. Offensive line? Only two have been drafted to this point. Defense? You’ve got two inside linebackers, two cornerbacks and even four edge-rushers who will have first-round grades from a lot of teams.

It’s not likely that more than a fourth of the first 23 picks will be wide receivers, plus four edge-rushers, but if you’re the Steelers, dare to dream. This would also be an interesting trade-down discussion, given the plethora of impact players they didn’t expect to be there at No. 24. The only negative would be Kevin Colbert and Mike Tomlin fighting over which Week 1 starter to rush to the podium, and they’re so paralyzed by the wealth of options that their time runs out and they miss the pick like the Ravens in 2011.

Advertise with us

Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.