The Steelers have three players among the 25 semifinalists for induction into the Pro Football Hall of Fame, but only two should get the call to be inducted this year.
Troy Polamalu is one of the greatest Steelers ever and is in his first year of eligibility. He should be a no-brainer as a first-ballot Hall of Famer. Reading the tea leaves among voters and listening to the experts, it seems like he will comfortably be voted in as one of the five modern-era members in the 2020 class.
The other former Steeler who should get the call is guard Alan Faneca. He was close last year but he fell just short of getting in. Faneca is one of three offensive linemen nominated as semifinalists, but he seems to have by far the best resume of them.
Faneca is a nine-time Pro Bowl player and was named All-Pro six times. He was a big part of the offensive line that helped running back Jerome Bettis achieve Hall of Fame status, and he helped the Steelers win a Super Bowl. He was a member of the NFL’s all-decade team in the 2000s and a member of the Steelers’ all-time team.
He was a great player and an argument could be made that he was one of the top three or four offensive linemen in the NFL for most of his career. There is no question he is qualified to be in the Hall of Fame and his resume is better than that of the other two linemen who are semifinalists, Tony Boselli and Steve Hutchinson.
Boselli may get a little more consideration than Faneca simply because he played tackle, but he still doesn’t have the resume to match Faneca. Boselli was a Pro Bowl player five times and was named All-Pro three times and he was named to the NFL’s all-decade team in the 1990s. Hutchinson’s resume is a distant third to Faneca and Boselli’s, so it will be a while before he is going to have a chance to get in.
Read More
The third Steelers player among the semifinalists is Hines Ward. Many Steelers fans believe Ward should be in the Hall of Fame already. He was one of the most physical receivers in league history and was one of the core members of a lot of successful Steelers teams. His blocking was legendary and his toughness symbolized who the Steelers were during his time.
Ward won two Super Bowl rings with the Steelers and was a key part of the team winning both of them. There is no question he is a great player and if you are a Steelers fan, it is easy to understand why he is one of your favorites. He played with passion, he had the smile on his face all the time, and he had some legendary blocks thrown in the Ravens games.
All of that is true, but so is this — he isn’t a Hall of Famer, at least not at this point. He may never be a Hall of Famer, but this year he is not going to get close, nor should he.
There are only five spots so it is tough for more than one player from a given position to get in the same year. It isn’t impossible but it isn’t likely, either.
Ward sits with Isaac Bruce, Torry Holt and Reggie Wayne as the four wide receivers who are among the semifinalists. All three of the others are above Ward on the all-time receiving yards list. Ward is second on the list in touchdown receptions, but he also played in more games than any of the other three except Bruce.
Ward is also fourth on the list of semifinalists in yards per reception, and by a lot. He was always a good receiver, but many years he wasn’t even the best receiver on his own team much less one of the best in the league. He did win a Super Bowl MVP and is on the Steelers’ all-time team, but those don’t trump the areas in which he is behind the other three.
The other three receivers up for nomination have better cases than he does, but only one might get in. That means he will be behind other receivers for the next few years and then a new crop of receivers with much better resumes will come along.
The Steelers are well represented in the Hall of Fame and should be, given their history. They will add to that this year, but only two of their former players, not all three, will be a part of this new class.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.