Devlin Hodges has been much better than Mason Rudolph at quarterback, James Washington is the Steelers’ best receiver and their playoffs odds have taken a hit even as five wins in six games have given given them control of the AFC’s sixth seed after a 1-4 start.

Those are the stories the team’s bleak advanced metrics on offense are telling as the home stretch of the season looms.

Let’s start with the all-consuming controversy behind center, because the differences are stark in two key metrics tracked by Football Outsiders. Defense-adjusted yards above average (DYAR) measures how much a player has been worth compared to an easily acquired fill-in, while defense-adjusted value over average (DVOA) “represents value, per play, over an average player in the same game situations.”

Rudolph is one of the worst among regular quarterbacks in both categories. His minus-102 DYAR puts him 28th among passers with at least 165 attempts. Only five quarterbacks with similar playing time are worse. The DVOA situation is even uglier. There, he’s tied for 29th with Chicago’s Mitchell Trubisky at minus-17.3%.

Advertise with us

Not only are Hodges’ numbers’ better, they’d put him among at mid-pack if extrapolated to a larger sample size. His 71 DYAR in 40 attempts is sixth among passers with between 10 and 164 attempts. That translates to 292 DYAR over 165 attempts, which would put him 17th, above names including Drew Brees and only slightly behind Jimmy Garoppolo (308 DYAR) of the NFC West-leading San Francisco 49ers.

DVOA offers and even sunnier outlook. Hodges’ mark of 24.9% is second among part-time quarterbacks and would put him eighth among regular passers, ahead of huge names including Green Bay’s Aaron Rodgers and New England’s Tom Brady.

Of course, because he has so few attempts, it’s important to keep in perspective that one bad performance could change the dynamic completely. To this point, though, the numbers suggest coach Mike Tomlin is making the right decision in backing Hodges this week against Cleveland.

That conclusion probably won’t surprise fans who’ve been clamoring for Hodges for weeks. What may surprise is who either QB’s best target has been this season.

It’s Washington. In a walk. Really.

Advertise with us

His 97 DYAR put him 25th in the NFL among 66 players with at least 44 targets, and his 15.3% DVOA is 14th in that same group. He’s the only Steelers receiver whose numbers are both above zero.

JuJu Smith-Schuster’s 34 DYAR put him way back in the pack, as does his DVOA of minus-5.8%. Diontae Johnson is close behind — 17 DYAR and minus-8.1% DVOA — despite positive reviews of his rookie season. No other Steeler even makes the list.

Washington stands out across the rest of the offense, too.

James Conner is 33rd in both DYAR (minus-48) and DVOA (minus-19.9%) among running backs with at least 88 attempts. Each of his three understudies — Benny Snell (minus-15 DYAR, minus-20.6% DVOA), Trey Edmunds (minus-30, minus-40.5%) and Jaylen Samuels (minus-38, minus-29.6%) — join him underwater, though in less playing time.

At tight end, Nick Vannett (minus-4, minus-12.3%) has been merely below average while Vance McDonald (minus-61, minus-30.9%) has really struggled.

Advertise with us

And the offensive line? It’s 26th in adjusted line yards, Football Outsiders’ top run blocking statistic, and third in adjusted sack rate, the site’s pass blocking figure.

So yes, put another way, Washington and Hodges are the only players tracked who don’t have any glaring holes in their stat profiles.

For that reason, it should be no surprise that the team’s playoff odds have dropped off despite its winning streak and a No. 3 rating in weighted defense, Football Outsiders’ unit efficiency rating.

The site gives the Steelers a 27.4% chance to make the field of six AFC teams. That figure is eighth best in the conference. Buffalo (81.0%) and Indianapolis (43.0%) are currently the favorites to win the wild card spots.

The forecast is right in line with those of other outlets. FiveThirtyEight.com has the Steelers at a 27.0% chance to make the playoffs, while ESPN’s Football Power Index puts the number at 26.9%. So all of the figures are within a half a percent of each other.

Advertise with us

All of those numbers are actually down from five weeks ago, when the Steelers were 2-4 and further outside the playoff picture than they are now at 6-5.

Taken together, the data paints a pretty grim picture, one of a team that’s done enough to get back into the race, but may not have enough gas to stay in it — regardless of whom the quarterback is.