Mike Tomlin said he may already have his mind made up which quarterback — Mason Rudolph or Devlin Hodges — will start the rematch against the Cleveland Browns on Sunday at Heinz Field. He may even publicly anoint the starter during his weekly televised news conference on Tuesday.

But, because he will continue to look for a spark for his offense, and because he has had to adjust the way he might typically coach in an attempt to keep his injured team afloat in the AFC playoff picture, Tomlin should — and probably will — buck conventional wisdom again and start Hodges.

It will be for the same reason he inserted him in the second half of Sunday’s 16-10 victory over the Cincinnati Bengals.

“I’ve always got a hardcore plan, but I’m light on my feet in case necessary adjustments are made in any element of play,” Tomlin said after the game.

Advertise with us

Tomlin made that comment when asked if Rudolph, who he said was coming off a “tough week for him on a lot of levels,” was on a short leash heading into the Bengals game. Tomlin said he wasn’t, but that doesn’t mean he wasn’t averse to a quarterback change if Rudolph started giving the ball away like he did a week earlier in Cleveland, when he threw four interceptions.

When Rudolph threw an interception on third-and-goal at the Bengals 9 in the first quarter, then failed to produce a touchdown for an offense that had produced just one in each of the previous three games, he made the move to Hodges. Three plays later, the player they call “Duck” produced a touchdown, doing what Chris Hatcher, his former coach at Samford, said he does best — throwing the ball where his receivers can make plays. And that’s what James Washington did with a perfect lead pass for a 79-yard, catch-and-run touchdown.

There is only one problem for Tomlin if he elects to start Hodges against the Browns: It would appear as though he is trying to protect Rudolph from any retribution or negative treatment from Myles Garrett’s teammates or even coaches, who have been accused of running an undisciplined ship. That has never been Tomlin’s style. He believes in confronting issues, not running from them.

But using a game as a means to administer a life lesson will not be the reason Rudolph will start against the Browns, if in fact he does. If Hodges gets the nod, it’s because Tomlin believes that, right now, he gives the Steelers the best chance to win — if not simply to just generate some offense. It’s the reason he made the switch to Hodges in the third quarter against the Bengals to begin with. And Hodges responded with a touchdown and two field goals.

If Tomlin is worried about protecting Rudolph, it should not be from the Browns but rather from a hometown crowd that is enamored with Hodges and his let-it-rip style. The fans at Heinz Field would be waiting to jump all over Rudolph at the first three-and-out or bad incompletion, further exposing him to even more abuse — if he hasn’t received enough already in the past 10 days.

Advertise with us

The move doesn’t have to be permanent. It doesn’t mean the Steelers prefer Hodges over Rudolph, or that they have given up on the player they are evaluating to see if he can be Ben Roethlisberger’s eventual replacement. Sitting Rudolph for a game and letting him regroup might be the best way for the Steelers to proceed, especially after the manner in which he has been shell-shocked from the events of the past two weeks.

Whatever Tomlin does, it will be with one purpose in mind: using the player who best gives the Steelers the chance to win against the Browns.

Spread the wealth

With the injury to James Conner (shoulder), who is expected to miss at least one more week, the Steelers turned to rookie Benny Snell to help out the running game against the Bengals.

Like he did in the second half against the Los Angeles Chargers, Snell had the majority of his game-high 98 yards after halftime at Paul Brown Stadium. He had 79 yards on 13 carries in the second half, including 35 yards on five carries on the final field-goal drive.

Advertise with us

But it wasn’t just Snell. The Steelers used all four running backs, including newcomer Kerrith Whyte, against the Bengals in an attempt to exploit the league’s worst rush defense. It was the first time this season the Steelers divided the snaps among four players as much as they did.

Snell played 36 snaps, Jaylen Samuels 22, Trey Edmunds 12 and Whyte 7. The Steelers inserted different backs depending on down-and-distance and the play selection, almost to the point the play became predictable depending on which back was in the game.

The result was the Steelers rushed for a season-high 160 yards against the Bengals and had runs of 16, 21 and 21 yards — the first time this season they had three runs of at least 15 yards in the same game.

“When you’re getting those, you’re probably playing pretty well,” guard David DeCastro said. “That’s what the stats say, at least.”