The Steelers enter Week 12 with dimming playoff hopes. They likely need to win five of their final six games to make the postseason, maybe four of the final six if they’d rather sweat it out on the final weekend of the regular season and hope the tiebreakers fall their way.
In many ways, it’s amazing the Steelers are even in contention for a playoff berth after 10 games. They are among the worst offensive teams in the NFL, with unsightly rankings in total offense (28th), passing offense (27th) and rushing offense (27th). They are 24th in scoring but only because the defense has chipped in with three touchdowns.
Some of their offensive rankings are trending toward franchise lows. Since the 1970 merger, the Steelers’ 807 rushing yards are the second-fewest in franchise history after 10 games.
So how in the world can the Steelers make the playoffs with such a flawed offense?
They might want to reference the 1989 Steelers, who had the worst offense in the NFL and almost made it to the AFC championship.
The ’89 Steelers were dead-last in the league in total yards and passing yards. They averaged just 249.8 yards per game. How bad was that? It was 19 fewer yards per game than the second-worst offensive team in the league that season. They also averaged just 136.1 passing yards per game, or half as much as the top passing team in the league that season, the Washington Redskins.
Read More
Like the 2019 Steelers, the ’89 team had a young defense with budding stars that had to carry the team to many of their victories. Rod Woodson and Carnell Lake were young standouts, and the defense was the reason the Steelers finished 9-7 in a very competitive AFC Central Division that sent three teams to the playoffs.
“You’d hear things like, ‘Well, we have to win it,’ ” said Bubby Brister, the quarterback of the ’89 team. “Well, you might, but down the road, we’ll have to bail you out. That’s football. That’s how it works. Very rarely do you have teams that are great on offense, defense and special teams at the same time. I was on teams in Denver that were like that, and we won back-to-back Super Bowls. But it doesn’t happen a lot. You have to work through it. I know it was frustrating for our defense. They were like, ‘What do we have to do?’ You could feel the tension, but it’s a team effort.”
The ’89 team was outscored 92-10 in the first two games of the season. They were shut out three times, twice at home.
Yet somehow they persevered. They were 4-6 after getting blanked by the Bears, 20-0, at Three Rivers Stadium but won five of their final six to finish 9-7. The offense, bordering on inept for much of the season, finally got hot. They scored 28 points or more in three of those five victories, including 31 in the regular-season finale in Tampa Bay.
Many believed the ’89 turnaround was Hall of Fame coach Chuck Noll’s best coaching job.
“Chuck always said that if everyone just got a little bit better throughout the season, the end result could be staggering,” said Tunch Ilkin, the starting right tackle on the ’89 team who is now a member of the Steelers radio broadcast team. “That’s what happened that season.”
Ilkin was one of just a handful of veteran starters on the offense. Most were young players who were just getting their feet wet in the league.
“Louis Lipps was our only veteran receiver,” Brister said. “I was a young quarterback. We had drafted Tim Worley that year. John Jackson was our left tackle starting for the first time. Dermontti [Dawson] was still a young player. We were all learning, but we really started to play well at the end of the year.”
Even after their 31-22 win against the Buccaneers, the Steelers needed help to get into the playoffs. They needed three other results to go in their favor to claim the final playoff berth in the AFC. They got it when the Vikings beat the Bengals on Christmas night.
In the AFC wild-card game, the Steelers traveled to Houston, where they lost, 27-0, earlier in the season. The game, played on New Year’s Eve, was won a 50-yard field goal by Gary Anderson in overtime after Woodson stripped Lorenzo White and recovered a fumble near midfield.
In Denver, for an AFC divisional round game the following week, the Steelers nearly pulled off an upset of the top-seeded Broncos. They led until John Elway put together one of his signature fourth-quarter comebacks. Running back Melvin Bratton scored with 2:22 remaining to give the Broncos a 24-23 lead.
“We got Elway-ed,” Ilkin said.
The Steelers had one last shot to go ahead, but rookie receiver Mark Stock dropped a Brister pass at the Denver 40 on the Steelers’ final drive.
Brister threw for more yards than Elway (229-226), and the Steelers out-gained the Broncos, 404-364. The difference was two lost fumbles.
“I think about it sometimes,” Brister said. “If we won that game, we would have played Cleveland again. We were playing well, and we had beaten them. We wanted to play them again and put it on them pretty good. And the Super Bowl was in New Orleans that year so that would have been great for me. I tell John all the time. When he got hit in the back on the sideline — you never wish anyone to get hurt — but if he had missed a series or two, it might have happened. I think he only missed one play. Then the next play he throws a 60-yard pass. But that was John. That’s why he was a great player.”
Here’s a look at some other offensively challenged teams that made the postseason:
2017 Bills
Record: 9-7
Total offense: 29th (302.6 ypg)
Passing offense: 31st (176.6 ypg)
Rushing offense: 6th (126.1 ypg)
Scoring offense: 22nd (18.9 ppg)
Playoffs: In Sean McDermott’s first season as a head coach, the Bills won four of their final six games to earn a wild-card spot. Against the No. 3 seed Jaguars, Tyrod Taylor and Nathan Peterman combined to go 18 for 40 for just 148 yards and threw two interceptions in a 10-3 loss. After Taylor was injured late in the game, Peterman marched the Bills to the Jaguars 38, but Jalen Ramsey picked him off with 32 seconds left to mercifully end the Bills’ season.
2011 Broncos
Record: 8-8
Total offense: 23rd (316.6 ypg)
Passing offense: 31st (152.1 ypg)
Rushing offense: 1st (164.5 ypg)
Scoring offense: 25th (19.3 ppg)
Playoffs: Ah yes, this list would not be complete without the Tim Tebow-led Broncos, whose upset of the 12-4 Steelers ranks among the NFL’s all-time playoff shockers. Tebow’s 80-yard touchdown pass to Demaryius Thomas on the first play of overtime gave the Broncos a 29-23 victory. Tebow-mania ended the next week in New England when the Patriots shellacked the Brocnos, 45-10, to end their Cinderella run.
2010 Seattle
Record: 7-9
Total offense: 28th (297.8 ypg)
Passing offense: 19th (208.8 ypg)
Rushing offense: 31st (97 ypg)
Scoring offense: 23rd (19.4 ppg)
Playoffs: The Seahawks became the first team in NFL history to make the playoffs with a losing record. And by virtue of winning the NFC West, they got to play host to the defending Super Bowl champion New Orleans Saints in an NFC wild-card game. They beat the Saints, 41-36, behind a dominating performance by Marshawn Lynch, but their season ended the following week in a divisional-round loss to Chicago.
2009 Jets
Record: 9-7
Total offense: 20th (321 ypg)
Passing offense: 31st (148.8 ypg)
Rushing offense: 1st (172.2 ypg)
Scoring offense: 17th (21.8 ppg)
Playoffs: With rookie quarterback Mark Sanchez under center, the Jets beat Cincinnati and San Diego in the first two rounds to make it to the AFC championship. The Jets led the Colts, 17-13, but the Colts scored 17 unanswered points in the second half to deny the Jets a berth in the Super Bowl.
*1990 Saints
Record: 8-8
Total offense: 23rd (279.8 ypg)
Passing offense: 26th (164.1 ypg)
Rushing offense: 16th (115.6 ypg)
Scoring offense: 22nd (17.1 ppg)
Playoffs: The Saints became the first .500 team to qualify for the playoffs as a wild card. In an NFC wild-card game in Chicago, Saints quarterback Steve Walsh completed just six passes before being knocked out of the game. John Fourcade replaced him, but the Saints offense managed only 193 total yards and two field goals in a 16-6 loss.
*1985 Browns
Record: 8-8
Total offense: 21st (307.6 ypg)
Passing offense: 25th (164.8 ypg)
Rushing offense: 8th (142.8 ypg)
Scoring offense: 23rd (17.9 ppg)
Playoffs: Behind rookie head coach Marty Schottenheimer and rookie quarterback Bernie Kosar, the Browns won four of their final six to finish at .500. They led the Dolphins, 21-3, in the third quarter of their playoff game, but the Dolphins scored 21 unanswered points for the comeback win. It was the start of a nice five-year run for the Browns, who would make the AFC title game three times in the next four years.
*Rankings when NFL had 28 teams



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.