Editor’s note: The commentary below contains opinion. The author’s name has been withheld at the writer’s request.

It is a Pittsburgh tradition that goes back more than four decades, back to the days when Tom Moore assisted Chuck Noll and helped him and the Steelers win four Super Bowls in the 1970s.

Everybody wants to fire the offensive coordinator.

Tell the truth.

Advertise with us

How often have you taken Randy Fichtner’s name in vain this season?

Fichtner is a terrible play-caller. He is too conservative. He has put handcuffs on Mason Rudolph and won’t give Rudolph a chance to succeed. He won’t allow Rudolph to throw the ball deep. He calls run plays when he should call pass plays and pass plays when he should call run plays. Bring back Todd Haley …

OK, maybe I haven’t heard that last part. But I’ve heard the rest.

I get it to a point. Everybody thinks they are smarter than the play-caller. It doesn’t matter if the coordinator spends countless hours every week studying tape to document a defense’s tendencies and weaknesses and come up with a game plan. Too many people think they can call the plays better. It’s been that way since there has been football.

What I don’t get is how people can judge Fichtner harshly this season.

Advertise with us

I thought Fichtner was pretty good last season in his first season as offensive coordinator when he had Ben Roethlisberger and Antonio Brown. Hard to believe those guys made a difference with the offense, right? Roethlisberger believes in Fichtner and pushed for him to get the promotion from quarterbacks coach when Haley was fired after the 2017 season. I’ve heard people say that’s a bad thing, but that’s nonsense. What’s wrong with the franchise quarterback feeling comfortable with his coordinator?

This season, Fichtner lost Roethlisberger for the year in the second game. He hasn’t had James Conner for two games and parts of three others. He won’t have Conner, injured JuJu Smith-Schuster or suspended Maurkice Pouncey Sunday in Cincinnati.

Let’s review:

The Steelers will play the Bengals without their Hall of Fame quarterback, their top rusher, their best wide receiver and the leader of their offensive line.

Good luck with that.

Advertise with us

Roethlisberger’s elbow injury was the killer. Fichtner’s offense was designed around him. Of course it was. It’s unfair to Fichtner and Rudolph to expect Rudolph to step in and run it as effectively. By the way, Fichtner has called plenty of deep pass plays for Rudolph, who too often has missed on them or been afraid to take his shot.

Conner’s injuries also have been crushing. The Steelers have no running game without him. Somehow, they beat the Colts with a 45-yard run by Trey Edmunds and a total of 45 rushing yards on their other 24 carries. They beat the Rams with 42 rushing yards. Those wins still seem surreal.

The inability to run the ball caught up with the Steelers in Cleveland Nov. 14 after Conner was injured late in the first quarter. They finished with 58 rushing yards. Much worse, they couldn’t pass the ball after Smith-Schuster and Diontae Johnson left with injuries. Rudolph was left to throw to Johnny Holton and Tevin Jones. They couldn’t have scored another touchdown in the 21-7 loss if they had played all night. Rudolph’s four interceptions didn’t help.

At least Johnson is expected to play against the Bengals. That’s something, right?

I still can’t believe the Steelers are 5-5 despite that brutal loss to the Browns. I know the defense has carried the team since Minkah Fitzpatrick arrived in a trade after the second game, but I can’t believe the offense has done enough to help win five games. It did it with Jaylen Samuels in the wildcat in the first game against the Bengals. It did it with Duck Hodges at quarterback in Los Angeles against the Chargers. It did it against the Rams with a late eight-minute drive. There could have been — maybe should have been — two more wins if Conner didn’t fumble late against the 49ers and Smith-Schuster in overtime against the Ravens.

Advertise with us

Although all of the injuries make for a sad story and a convenient excuse, they aren’t totally to blame for the offense’s ineptitude. The line has been mostly putrid, the team’s biggest disappointment because it includes three Pro Bowlers. They couldn’t protect Rudolph against the Browns. They haven’t been able to convert third-and-ones and fourth-and-ones all season. They too often get no push. That’s on the linemen, not on the injuries.

Bottom line?

Fichtner has done pretty well with what little he has.

There will be no calls for his firing here.