Welcome to Brian Batko’s weekly Steelers mailbag. You’re more than welcome to email him at bbatko@post-gazette.com, tweet him @BrianBatko or slide into his DMs to inquire about the Steelers, NFL or anything out of bounds.
Let’s get started, and don’t forget to join us on our weekly all-sports podcast, The North Shore Drive, whether you use Apple, Spotify or any of the other major platforms.
Alan S.: Hi Brian, I’ve been a big-time Mason fan since he was drafted and I’m pulling for him all the way BUT… I’m really starting to worry. I know he’s only had a few starts and he’s been OK at times but I’m not sure that he has “it”. QBs coming out of college these days are so pro ready that we usually have a decent idea pretty quickly. Even lower pedigree guys like Minshew have had some success. Lamar Jackson, Prescott and Carson Wentz showed up right away, along with others. Even with good protection he’s hanging on to the ball so long that several of his throws are coming out while he’s being hit. He’s under throwing go routes like crazy. Am I just judging him too harshly and too quickly?
Brian: Full disclosure, Alan’s email hit my inbox a day after the Colts game, so, before Mason Rudolph completed 22 of 38 passes against the Rams for 242 yards, his highest total against a real NFL team (looking at you, Dolphins). That seemed to be Rudolph’s best game to date. Offensive coordinator Randy Fichtner even said so, at least in terms of “consistently making decisions and putting the ball in proper spots,” as he put it Tuesday after practice.
There’s been some consternation from the Twitter-sphere (goes without saying) about Fichtner’s comments toward Rudolph, including what he said in the next breath after that quote above: “It’s baby steps.” But to me, that goes to show that Fichtner is not doing what a lot of other people — perhaps including you, Alan — are with Rudolph, and that’s jumping to conclusions about whether he’s great or awful.
Now, far be it from me to tell fans or media or whomever not to watch the games and make judgments based on what they see. That’s part of the fun of watching sports. But look at the other guys you mentioned: Gardner Minshew has been benched in Jacksonville, with Nick Foles getting his job back; Lamar Jackson was relying on sheer athleticism for the most part last season, rather than the all-around quarterbacking ability he’s shown this year; Dak Prescott had two 300-yard games in 16 starts as a rookie; and Carson Wentz’s 16-14 touchdown-to-interception ratio as a rookie contributed to a 7-9 season in Philadelphia.
Read More
Hey, if you’re convinced that the numbers and the film show that Rudolph doesn't have the “it” factor to be a longtime starter in the NFL, that’s your call. But it probably is too early to make that leap, especially on a third-round pick — not a first- or second-rounder, even if the Steelers have said they think he could've been — that wasn't supposed to be in this situation in his second year. Rudolph now has six career starts under his belt. Taking away his first one, on the road against a dominant San Francisco defense, he has just two turnovers, one of which was picked off as the result of a drop. He maybe hasn't done much to ease concerns about the future of the position post-Ben Roethlisberger, but he’s been effective enough be 4-1 in games he has started and finished, which should buy him ample time to keep being evaluated with an open mind.
As for Fichtner being not complimentary enough or something like that, I don’t buy it. Say what you want about his coaching and/or play-calling, but he doesn’t strike me as someone who’s going to throw his quarterback under the bus to save himself. We always want these guys to be honest about what they’re seeing, and all indications are he’s doing exactly that.
Tom in Dallas: There was a question in one of the chats this week if Mason had Franchise QB potential. The response was probably not, but he could be a very good QB. My questions: what is the accepted definition of a FQB? And if you look at the league today, who is on that list and who might be a border line FQB? On the list are Brady, Rogers, Ben, Brees, Mahomes, Cam, Rivers. Would Eli have been on that list? Russell Wilson?
Brian: There’s been plenty written on this subject, which is essentially a moving target anyway as the NFL changes with regard to the quarterback position and evolves in general. Most of the guys you mention are slam dunks, but all of a sudden, the Cam Newton experience looks to be ending in Carolina, and it hasn't even been a decade. Wilson has cemented himself as a franchise quarterback, no doubt. Eli Manning? Yeah, most likely the rare one to be put to pasture by his franchise.
The simplest way to think about it? It’s a quarterback you expect to have and build your team around for a long time — 10 years or more — who can also be your best player for much of that span. That might go without saying, given that if you have a quarterback who’s just so-so, there’s no reason to keep him around all that long. Except for Joe Flacco, I guess. Should we stop asking if Flacco was elite and start asking if Flacco was a franchise QB?
Bill in SF: When is the last time we've actually seen the Steelers offense, with ball in hand and needing just a couple first downs to close a game out, actually managed to execute a four-minute drill. And I'm talking about going back to games when all three of the Killer B's were healthy and playing? Thanks.
Brian: Certainly not this past game. They couldn't even execute a 15-second drill to close out the Rams.
The last time the Steelers offense salted away a victory with any kind of drill, be it two-minute or four-minute, was — well, it was just last season, with only two of the so-called B’s. Week 3, at Tampa Bay, with a 30-27 lead, Ryan Switzer fielded a Bryan Anger punt and returned it for 16 yards (yes, really). With 2:36 on the clock and the Steelers at their 32, James Conner got stuffed for no gain. Timeout, Buccaneers. On second down, Ben Roethlisberger found JuJu Smith-Schuster for 18 yards to midfield. Timeout, Buccaneers. The very next play, Conner ripped off a 17-yard run into the two-minute warning and three kneel-downs. Game over.
That does kind of feel like a long time ago, doesn't it?
Mike P.: All game long the announcers have been talking about how Sean McVay said he may fake a punt. Surely one of the Steelers coaches in the box has heard this and relayed it down to the field. Steelers were ready and get the turnover. So, is it on the announcers not to reveal info like that (off the record?), or a stupid thing for the coach to say before the game?
Brian: Stuff like that said by commentators on TV is never going to be significantly helpful to opposing coaches, players, staffers, etc. If it were, it would never get mentioned publicly, be it to the media or even in those pre-production meetings.
Now, if Sean McVay or anyone else feels compelled for some reason (they wouldn't) to tip their hand or give inside info to, say, Tony Romo — then, sure, there’s a journalistic responsibility for that to be kept off the record, if that was the understanding between both parties. But trust me, it wouldn't take watching the TV broadcast to know that McVay likes to bust out a fake from time to time; the Steelers were ready because they have a lot of smart football minds scouting and game-planning each week.
Do teams pay attention to what gets said in the media throughout the week? Yes, I imagine they do, if just to cover all their bases and be as 100% informed as they can possibly be. But by the time the game actually starts and it’s being broken down in real time by play-by-play folks and color analysts to an audience of millions? The hay is in the barn by then.

Be sure to compliment Joe Starkey. Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.