Brian Batko: Good afternoon, friends. Short week, but we’re still chatting. And we’ll still have plenty of Steelers coverage, including a North Shore Drive podcast (https://newsinteractive.post-gazette.com/the-north-shore-drive-sports-...), my weekly mailbag and the Skinny Post newsletter, which you can sign up for below. It’s free, fun, exclusive Steelers content, from quotes to stats to insights from me. All you have to do is create a Post-Gazette account if you don't already have one, then sign up here: https://my.post-gazette.com/profile/#/preferences
Brian Batko: And with that, let's kick off
Dirty Dave the Love Slave: ¿Would you consider the trade for Minkah comparable to the trade for Jerome Bettis back in the day?
Brian Batko: Well, I was 4 when that trade happened, but it does seem like the Steelers have pulled off maybe their best deal since then. Although the compensation in return for Minkah Fitzpatrick was probably fair. It'll likely end up being a win for both sides, if the Dolphins can put another first-rounder to good use in their rebuild.
Alaska Steeler: Sure seems like we got lucky on the non PI call on Edmunds at end of game. It seems like he rarely turns his head to find the ball and his style just begs for that type of call. Agree or not?
Brian Batko: He plays physical, yeah, but I wouldn't say the Steelers got lucky on that one. You see those types of calls go either way a lot of the time. Sean McVay might've challenged it if it hadn't been under two minutes, though. I don't think Terrell has been great in coverage or anything -- certainly not the 100 percent A-plus grade his brother Trey has -- but that was a big play, and he made another big play that kinda flew under the radar last week on stopping the 2-point conversio.
Read More
Hood: Any word on how shaziers rehab is going? Is he able to run?
Brian Batko: Yes, and he can do a lot of other things in the weight room, but as far as I know, still a long way to go for him. Nice to see Shazier honored on the field pregame last night though. He's enjoying his time as a Pitt student, finishing up the degree he started at Ohio State.
John Strange: Should Rudolph been able to field the high snap that led to the Ram turnover TD?
Brian Batko: Eh, it would've taken a pretty athletic play by him. And I think he would've gotten pasted by Dante Fowler if he had caught it. Looked high to me. Maurkice Pouncey needs to do a better job eliminating those. He had a few slip-ups snapping to Duck Hodges at the Chargers, too.

BringBackWeegie: Hi Brian - Which decision was worse: Play action from the end zone or switching up the OL? Thanks.
Brian Batko: I don't think the OL shift was that bad. Chuks Okorafor had a few lapses but was actually better than I thought he'd be given the way he played in preseason. I thought Matt Feiler probably played as well as anyone, with how much he had to deal with Aaron Donald inside. The play-action from the end zone was big risk and did not reap a big reward, obviously.
Tampa Too: I thought the clock management at the end of the first half was awful. The Rams had only one time out and we threw 3 incomplete passes which allowed the Rams to attempt a long field goal . Fortunately it was not good. Your thoughts on this clock management
Brian Batko: Here's the thing: if the Steelers complete those passes, maybe they get points. If they run the ball instead, people are asking why they weren't more aggressive. Case in point: the final possession when they ran three times to try to kill clock, and lots of folks didn't that either, because they couldn't grind out a first down and instead had to punt back to the Rams.
Plex a go: Seems like Coaches Butler and Tomlin got a lot smarter since Game 2? How and when will Coach Fichner get his IQ raised? And forget Danny Smith- apparently he's here for life no matter the results?
Brian Batko: Yeah, coaches are always smarter when they're winning. Danny Smith's return and coverage units have not been great, but let's give some credit for being hyper-ready on the fake punt pass. Trey Edmunds said they watched that on film a hundred times. It was the worst fake punt I've seen since Jeff George Jr. sneaked onto the field at Notre Dame last year...
Bobby Bottleservice: Come back to Pitt FB, nothings been the same since you left.
Brian Batko: You're right, Jeff George Jr. isn't lining up at punter anymore
Ronald : Brian , would you take Eli Rogers back? I really think right now he is a great choice (Switzer injury and performance) why not give it a chance? He would help in both returning and WR corps ..
Brian Batko: Sure, he might be able to help. But it seems that ship sailed a while ago when he cleaned out all his stuff and said farewell to the important people in the organization.
Mark in L.A.: Given the problems with the Steelers' kickoff coverage team, why are they having Boswell kick short? It could have cost them yesterday.
Brian Batko: Guess they think their coverage can improve. Kicking short has been working well for teams AGAINST the Steelers.
livinthedream: Brian, D outstanding. O not so much. Until Mason demonstrates a 2 second release he should never ever attempt a pass from his own end zone. We were lucky it only cost 2 pts . Your thoughts.
Brian Batko: I agree, the D was outstanding and the O not so much yesterday. You're spot-on, my dude.
The Peanut Gallery: Wait a second! IsTomlin doing a good job? Even the defense is playing...splendid. You might not even get a when to Fire Tomlin question today! Is that possible?
Brian Batko: I'm hopeful, TPG. But as Ellis Boyd "Red" Redding once said, hope is a dangerous thing. Hope can drive a man insane.
Melanie: Mr Batko this Offense is Horrendous (fundamentals, drops, execution) they better improved ASAP it’s becoming ridiculous, take the win but common !! Who is to blame for lack of improvement ?
Brian Batko: Please, Melanie, Mr. Batko is my father. I'm not sure there's a clear person to blame. It's tough to adjust on the fly in the NFL. The other guys are getting paid, too, to stop you. I suppose Randy Fichtner shoulders some responsibility for not coming out more crisp following the off week. But to his credit, I thought Mason Rudolph looked just fine yesterday.
JB: Have to be someone out there that can replace Switzer. Seems like a wasted roster spot. How about Jones or Griffey?
Brian Batko: Tevin Jones is on the p squad, but not really considered a returner type. Trey Griffey been out of work since preseason cuts. Terrelle Pryor is out there.
Susy: If make Playoffs is there any small possibility Big Ben could be back? We really need Offense
Brian Batko: No
From afar: When do you think that the Steelers will slip up? This week at Cleveland? They always seem to play down to the competition.
Brian Batko: Could be. Browns still have talent, mainly at the skill positions and in the front seven. Gotta think even at 3-6 the Dawg Pound will be pumped up for this one. They are favored by 2 last I looked.
Steelchuck: Hey Brian - how’s Conner looking for being active Thursday?
Brian Batko: Looking good, by his own estimation and Mike Tomlin's as well as Gerry Dulac's reporting https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2019/11/11/pittsburgh-ste...
Meath Hiller: How do we get Vance going? He is a beast who should be getting 6-7 targets/game.
Brian Batko: He had a drop on one of his seven targets last night, the second game in a row with that many. It depends on what the defense is giving Mason Rudolph. Seems pretty clear to me that he's not going to try to force balls into spots that aren't open very often, if at all.
Scott Cook via KY: Why don’t we sign someone to play fullback if Nix can’t go. Our running game improves with a fullback.
Brian Batko: Good question. There are only so many roster spots to go around. Rosie Nix's knee cropping up again isn't ideal, but not putting him on IR tells me they're still hopeful he'll be back in another week or two. But hey, maybe the correct move was to put him on IR long ago and sign someone else there so you can still run power.
Thumper95 : Hey Brian: Minka stating his case as potential DPOY?
Brian Batko: The counting numbers are definitely there. Tied for the league lead in picks. Plus, voters will take into consideration the way he's transformed this Steelers defense. But Aaron Donald is still doing Aaron Donald things. Stephon Gilmore doesn't get stats because he's just a lockdown corner. Joey Bosa and Khalil Mack are very good. But Minkah is in the conversation, no doubt.
Lloyd: More of a fun fact, but Trey Edmunds the running back now has as many career interceptions as his brother Terrell who has been a starting safety for 1.5 seasons...
Brian Batko: Someone should write about that https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2019/11/10/nfl-running-ba...
elcid97: Hi Brian! One of the really obvious differences with how we're playing defense is how few times Bud and TJ drop into zone coverage. Would you say that's a change in scheme/ philosophy or is it greater confidence that the secondary can cover? Either way, it's paying dividends - esp for Bud's career!
Brian Batko: Some of both, I'd say. This defense is playing really well with the amount of pressure they're generating, even without Stephon Tuitt and in the times they're bringing four when they go nickel. Then, that extra DB - whether it's Mike Hilton or Cam Sutton - is doing his job in coverage on the slot more often than not. Minkah's presence is also allowing them to do some different things with the way he can cover.
Heavy Sigh: Mike Tomlin informed, in his post game conf., us that he is calling plays on offense, including the "play-action at minus six" that resulted in a safety for LA. Was it his call to put Rudolph in shotgun on 3-inches too ?
Brian Batko: I think he meant that he signed off on that play. Obviously, Randy Fichtner has not lost play-calling duties or anything like that.
JSteel: Why so little respect for BJ Finney? I feel like he always performs admirably when called on. Sometimes I feel like he is even superior to Foster. Didn’t get the decision to put Feiler at LG especially since he is taller. All we heard about all week is how Aaron Donald uses his stature to his advantage to gain leverage. Wouldn’t Finney’s shorter stature be better than Feiler’s length?
Brian Batko: Tomlin's explanation was that they wanted to emphasize pass protection, so they basically put a tackle at guard in Matt Feiler. Finney is fine. He's a handsomely paid backup, all things considered. Got the job done in place of Ramon Foster against Indy. Clearly, they opted for length over leverage, but Feiler's guard history helped, too. He knows what he's doing there and played well.
Gregg: Is the moral of the cautionary story that is Donte Moncrief for the Steelers to only sign players in FA that were cut by their former teams so that our comp picks won’t be endangered?
Brian Batko: Sort of. Or it's like renting a player. Unless they change that rule/process, which they probably should.
Avoid LLoyd: Brian, sure seems like the lionshare of our WR fumbles happen when these guys are running sideways instead of upfield. What gives? Catch the ball and hold the ball, we didn't do either very well yesterday.
Brian Batko: Yeah, the fumbles have been brutal. It's an unfortunate byproduct of guys trying to do too much, and you're never gonna knock them for effort on those plays. Need to do a better job with ball security, no doubt. But with one practice before playing the Browns, there's not a whole lot of time to harp on that issue.
Brian in CA: Overall d is exceeding expectations, but looks suspect vs the run. Is Cleveland going to run over them?
Brian Batko: That's the big worry vs. these Browns. The OL ain't great, but Nick Chubb and Kareem Hunt are ballers. Todd Gurley ripped off a couple nice ones early. Marlon Mack was slicing them up at times two weeks ago. Not to sound like every football coach ever, but there are a reason sayings become cliches. It starts with stopping the run this week.
Titan in Charlotte: Do you know if coaches watch other teams for a way to improve? Example Steelers watching the 49ers film for improvements in their running game?
Brian Batko: It's certainly a copy cat league, as they say, but this time of year I think it's more about learning everything you can about your opponent in a given week.
Steeler1974: How many more drops is Tomlin going tolerate? Juju seems to drop a couple each game now. Rudolph would have had a way better stat line and we may have even scored a time or two more.
Brian Batko: What's he going to do, bench them all and run the single wing? I'm sure he's not happy about it. But as he just said in his press conference a couple hours ago, it doesn't do much good talking to receivers about receiving. They just have to go out and do it.

Joe: Been a fan since the 70s. I am really shocked fans are not more level headed in their view of the team. To lose your hall of fame QB and still be in it is really amazing. With the win last night do you believe 9-7 is possible. And if so regardless if they make the playoffs does Tomlin finally get consideration for coach of the year?
Brian Batko: Fan is short for fanatical. Our job as reporters is to be level headed while the fine people on the other side of this chat can react and overreact and fire everyone after each loss. Tomlin may very well be in that conversation if they keep this up. A lot of other coaches are doing a nice job, though. Belichick, Harbaugh, Kyle Shanahan come to mind from the teams with the best record.
Jack 58: The ongoing awful NFL officiating clearly benefited the Steelers yesterday but what goes around... Did you think Goffs fumble was actually a incomplete forward pass. Edmunds play at the goal line could have been called pi imo but was still a nice change for TE.
Brian Batko: I did, but the replay showed me why the call was upheld. Looked like there was juuuuuuuuuuuust enough inconclusivity (new word I just made up) there to call it a fumble.
rcc prof: Brian, welcome to my neighborhood. In my neighborhood, I resign Dupree now that he's finally an impact player. I draft a tight end in the 2nd round who can catch the ball, and a shifty runner who doesn't go Letang
Brian Batko: I don't want to live here. In my neighborhood, we're still letting Bud walk and replacing him with an edge-rusher in the second round.
Jon Snow: I think one of the most under reported stories is the great play of Davis. His signing is a key to this defense playing as well as they have. Do you know for how long he is signed.
Brian Batko: I'm going to assume you mean cornerback Steven Nelson, and if so, I agree. He's signed for two more years after this one. But as for Sean Davis, if he doesn't get hurt, do the Steelers still trade for Minkah Fitzpatrick? I wonder...
Batko Fan: Is it worth it to franchise Bud?
Brian Batko: Not in my humble neighborhood
Jeff: 3rd and inches and we go shotgun? twice! why?
Brian Batko: I dunno!
574Fan: Thanks for chatting, Brian. Seems like Bush has been quieter in recent weeks and it also seems a little early to hit the "rookie wall". With Barron (finally, maybe) coming on, does Bush's role diminish?
Brian Batko: Yeah, he's been quiet. Still reading and reacting quickly to the run, so that's good. Still playing a lot. Just not making those splashy plays. Jack Doyle put him in the blender on that one touchdown last week. But Vince Williams barely saw the field yesterday. Only 11 snaps vs. the Rams, same number as Isaiah Buggs.
Robert: Do you agree that a lot of the troubles with the run game and passing can be attributed to the VERY poor offensive line play? Sacks, a safety, no run lanes? Peer snaps.
Brian Batko: Pretty much. As solid as they've been in pass pro (against teams that don't have Aaron Donald) they just haven't been able to win at the line of scrimmage in the run game. They'd hoped things were coming together after that Chargers game, but one step forward, two steps back.
Ken Ward: Hi Brian, I believe that MR and the offense are close to being decent, assuming a running game is sustainable. It is not small feat to have won the last 5 out of 6 games. The D looks really solid and potentially a top 5 D. What say you? Thanks
Brian Batko: I don't know how close they are, Ken. Rudolph looked better yesterday, but his receivers looked worse. Even JuJu continues to have drop issues. Still a lot to fix on that side of the ball, but I have trouble poking holes in this defense. It's excellent.
James from Philly : Hey Brian! Thanks for the chats. Do you consider this Tomlin's best coaching performance since he has been in Pittsburgh?
Brian Batko: You're welcome, James. You might be the most polite person from Philadelphia. Anyway, I'd have to really sit down and look at that. He's had a lot of good seasons in 13 years at the helm. This one is completely different, though, and there's so much to be said for the way he kept this thing from spiraling out of control, even with the caveat that Kevin Colbert and company delivered him a game-changer in the form of Fitzpatrick.
Retire21: The Rams and the Arizona games were the two being least important for the Steelers to win because they were NFC games and not factors in tie breakers. Could that have had any impact on resting Conner or Ramon?
Brian Batko: I don't think so. That was still a huge, huge game. Just don't think either of those guys were ready for that one.
Mr Medium Chest: Drove from NYC for the game yesterday what a great atmosphere. Was yesterday JW coming out party?
Brian Batko: They should hope so. He made some of the catches you need to see from your No. 2 receiver. The fade in the end zone was something that's been missing for this offense, no doubt. Let's see him string some together, though. Hope you had a nice drive.
Mark in VA Beach: A win is a win and we're in a playoff spot. Lots of upside right now, especially with the way the second half schedule pans out. I was wondering if anyone else noticed how we snapped the ball way early in our last possession. The play clock was only down to 15 or 16 with the clock running and we were snapping the ball. Seems we could serve ourselves better by allowing as much time off the clock as possible, especially in a tight game like this one was. Hopefully, it was picked up on by the team and they will make the correction in regard to late game time management.
Brian Batko: Yeah, that last drive was not ideal. To force the defense to go back out there after the stop they made was a big ask, and yet, they clamped down in another sudden change situation. That was an area of improvement from Indy to Rams.
Blackhawk Bob: Have we seen the last of Ryan Switzerland as a return man ?
Brian Batko: Ehhh I'm neutral
Gravel: Brian - Thanks for the chat. With each passing week, I think it is more obvious that the problems on offense are Randy problems not Mason or personnel problems. His play calling is too predictable and when a call is unexpected it is generally an atrocious call. Mason doesn't check out like Ben does. How can Randy's shortcomings be overcome?
Brian Batko: See ball, catch ball, don't fumble ball. Not necessarily trying to defend Fichtner, because I don't think he's doing a great job, but some of these offensive numbers look considerably better if individual players make plays.
CanadianSteelersFan : So... The Defense is finally good! Oh, but the Offense is now terrible. Sigh. Our Offensive Line and WR’s have always been a strength and now seem to be a weakness. Have you ever seen so many dropped passes in one game?
Brian Batko: Yeah, Week 1 at New England, all by the same player.
Steelchuck: Do you go to all the Steelers games as part of your job covering? Are you in a PG booth with catering etc or where do you sit?
Brian Batko: I go to all the home games and now will be traveling to the divisional road games, as was the preseason plan. We sit in the press box with all the other scribes. It is catered. I sit in seat No. 6. I am Duck Hodges.
Morty: Another benefit of Fitzpatrick trade. Despite losing one year of rookie contract, his bonus won't count much vs cap going forward (unlike their own R1 2020 pick would). Do you see this as a benefit or will they need to extend him sooner?
Brian Batko: Definitely a benefit, but I'm not sure how they'll approach his contract situation. He's certainly outplaying his rookie deal, obviously.
ALB: Kinda lost in the Minkah, TJ and Bud accolades, has anyone noticed how great Cam is playing?
Brian Batko: I have. My coworkers have. Keep an eye out for our coverage this week.
jerome: do you think the steelers should trade ben now??
Brian Batko: Nah
STEEL72: Dr. Batko, you are one step close to shaving your head and getting a temporary Dulac tattoo.
Brian Batko: Heh. I did say in last week's chat that if the Steelers run the table, I'll shave my head. Never mentioned anything about a Dulac tattoo. But hey, I'll stand by my original proclamation and double down: if they win the Super Bowl, I'll do both.
Alberto : What is your prediction of the Steelers record? Mine is 10-6. I see them losing against the Ravens and a classic Tomlin lose, probably the Cardinals.
Brian Batko: Nice one, Alberto. I'm torn. Don't know how to feel about this Thursday night game. Might just be their toughest one until Week 17 at Baltimore. Or maybe Buffalo, but that's at home. I'll go with 5-4-7.
Brian Batko: Just like that, our hour is up. It flew by! Thanks for stopping. Ray Fittipaldo with you all tomorrow. Enjoy the rest of your Veteran's Day, and shoutout to all of those who have served our country.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.