Steelers looking to contain Baker Mayfield in Cleveland

The Steelers had big plans for tight end Vance McDonald this season. Coming off the best season of his career when he set career highs for receptions (50), receiving yards (610) and touchdowns (four), offensive coordinator Randy Fichtner wanted to lean on McDonald as his young receiving corps adapted to new roles.

The plan hasn’t unfolded the way the Steelers had hoped. Through nine games, McDonald’s presence in the offense is somewhere between lost and forgotten. He does have 25 receptions, but for only 187 yards. The 7.5 yards per catch average is by far the lowest of his career. Entering this season, he averaged more than 10 yards per catch in each of his first six NFL seasons and four times averaged more than 13 yards per catch.

“We had big plans for everybody in general, and the road has kind of winded left and right, and left and right, and up and down,” Fichtner said. “But we’re trying to get all of them involved.”

Surely the absence of Ben Roethlisberger has something to do with McDonald’s lagging numbers. He was a favorite target of Roethlisberger, garnering 72 targets last season, 26 more than any other season in his career. And big tight ends that are visible in the middle of the field should be appealing to young quarterbacks, especially one such as Mason Rudolph, who has embraced the short passing game in his six starts since Roethlisberger was injured.

Advertise with us

Many NFL teams use tight ends as focal points of their passing games. And this is especially the case with teams that are starting young quarterbacks.

The Texans have three tight ends on their roster with more receiving yards than McDonald. The Ravens, Rams, Cowboys, Eagles and Colts each have two tight ends with more receiving yards than McDonald, who is 32nd in the league in receiving yards for tight ends.

McDonald’s season started off with a rough outing in New England, and it hasn’t gotten much better since. McDonald had two catches for 40 yards in the opener, but both came in the waning moments after the result had already been decided.

The Patriots played mostly man-to-man coverage on the Steelers and had great success, limiting them to three points. Defensive coordinators took notice. In almost every game since, the Steelers have faced man coverage.

“Starting off with the Patriots and then Miami, so many of those defenses you have guys that sort of trickled through the [New England] system,” McDonald said. “And it’s a copycat league. Yeah, there’s been a lot of man coverage. It’s something that you can feast on. But at the same time, if you’re not playing well against it that day, it can be feast or famine.”

Advertise with us

McDonald isn’t the only Steelers pass catcher struggling to find open space against man coverage. JuJu Smith-Schuster’s numbers are way down, too. The Steelers are 27th in the league in passing yards.

Short week a challenge for the Steelers

“If you’re getting a lot of man they’re going to make sure you’re not running the football,” Fichtner said. “If they’re capable of manning you up then everyone has to win their one-on-ones. Sometimes, young quarterbacks get pressured a lot. You might have noticed our tight ends have been in protection, so that has limited opportunities. Sometimes he’s been called into protection by our quarterback. There are a lot of those factors. I couldn’t pinpoint one thing. His work has been excellent. He did miss some time, even in games. Some of that might come into play, as well.”

One other issue the Steelers are facing is the changing offense. They threw the ball more than any other team last season. This season, with a defense that’s leading the way, Fichtner is calling a more conservative game.

“Everyone knew last year they were going to get opportunities,” he said. “They were going to present themselves in every series. It’s been a little bit different. We have to put the team in the best position to win. If we do not turn the ball over, I don’t know who is going to beat us.”

That has meant fewer opportunities for McDonald and the other playmakers on the roster. One byproduct of that has been an eagerness to make plays when the ball is thrown their way. That has resulted in too many turnovers and drops.

Advertise with us

McDonald had one of the team’s four drops last week, and even though the Steelers won, he wasn’t celebrating afterward in the locker room.

“It sucked,” McDonald said. “It doesn’t feel good. I was unhappy. I shouldn’t have felt that way because we won. But with the lesser amount of opportunities, that’s definitely a real thing for receivers.”

Injury report

Running back James Conner went through a full practice Tuesday and is on course to return to the lineup after missing two games with a shoulder injury. Reserve outside linebackers Anthony Chickillo (ribs) and Ola Adeniyi (hip) were limited. Receiver Ryan Switzer (back) did not practice.

The Steelers re-signed outside linebacker Sutton Smith to their practice Tuesday. He could be called up to the active roster if Chickillo or Adeniyi cannot play.

Advertise with us

“We'll see,” Smith said. “I don't know. We'll just have to see what Coach says, see what the need is, and if they need me to come up, I'm more than happy to.”

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.