Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my Steelers chat. Let's get started.

ShawnP: I think Mason is doing a pretty darn good job out there. Why do so many Pittsburgh sports writers, radio hosts etc. ( no names) think he is doing so poorly?

Ray Fittipaldo: I'm not sure. I hear a little bit of it. For what it's worth, I gave him a B on my report card against the Rams. I thought it was one of his better games. Plus, he had zero help from his receivers in that game. I think maybe some see the state of the offense and correlate some of the inefficiencies to the QB position. And by no means has Rudolph been perfect. But he is playing winning football. He's not making mistakes. And he's 4-2 as a starter. Can he improve? Yes. But it takes time for a young QB to get used to playing in the NFL. This will be only his seventh NFL start against the Browns.

Nathan: Ray is it that hard to bring Eli Rogers back now? He definitely could be a spark on returns and help at WR specially in short passing game.. We really need something on offense!! Would You give him a chance?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Good question. I haven't thought about Eli in a while. Ryan Switzer has a back injury. Practice starts in a few minutes so I'm not sure about his status for the Browns game. But the Steelers haven't made a move to this point so we shall see what happens. To my knowledge Rogers isn't on a roster. Perhaps that's another sign that he's not the same player he used to be.

livinthedream: Ray,I am looking for Minkah to have a great night against Johnny Mayfield. Am I on track?

Ray Fittipaldo: If the Steelers can stop the Browns rushing attack then yes. But the Browns have a good running game, and the Steelers have struggled at times stopping the run. If the run is there for the Browns, it will open up the passing game. Like last week against the Rams, the Steelers have to shut down the run, get the Browns and unfavorable downs and distances and get after Mayfield.

ALB: Ray, could Thursday vs. Brownies be perhaps this season’s most pivotal game?

Ray Fittipaldo: I wouldn't say that. If the Steelers lose Thursday and win their next three against the Bengals, Browns and Cardinals then I think they'd be just fine in playoff positioning. The more pivotal game could be against the Bills because right now they're ahead of the Steelers in the wild card standings.

Advertise with us

Emily: What’s going on with Nix Knee Ray? We need him in there, Is this a long term issue? What have you heard?

Ray Fittipaldo: Well, he's already missed six of the first nine games. This is will 7 of 10 so that's not good. He's been a guy who has dealt with a lot of injuries during his time with the Steelers. I guess there remains hope that he can be available for the final six games, but that knee has been bothersome for him all season.

BB: Ray - in the final minutes of the game, you have to milk down the clock and salt away the W. Running three dud plays for no gain and running less than 30 seconds off the game clock is unacceptable. How does that happen in professional football? Thanks.

Ray Fittipaldo: Mike Tomlin said he didn't want to risk putting the ball in the air. The decision turned out to be sound. The way the Steelers defense was playing I was actually OK with the Steelers running three times and making the Rams burn all three of their timeouts. That made the final drive much more difficult. But to your original point, maybe there could have been a rollout run/pass option for Rudolph. Get a WR or RB in the flat. If he's covered, Rudolph runs or gets on the ground and takes a loss. That's one way to get a little more creative than simply running up the middle three times.

DaquidoBazzini: What’s with all the dropped passes? Receivers just not that good? Rudolph’s throws hard to handle? Makes little sense.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe it's contagious. Drops have been a problem all season. Moncrief had four in the first game for crying out loud. The concerning thing is JuJu. He's pretty sure-handed, and he's had drops in the past two games. You can't have that from your No. 1 receiver.

Retire21: The 76th player in the 2018 draft, who thought he should have been a first round pick, may some extra incentive to excel against the No. 1 Pick of that draft.

Ray Fittipaldo: I'm sure you're onto something. I wrote about the 2018 QB class about a month ago before the Steelers played the Ravens and Lamar Jackson. Rudolph told me then he plays with a chip on his shoulder when it comes to competing against those guys. I was doing some research this morning and came across an old NFL Network interview when Mason was talking about how he thought he was the best QB in the class. I'm sure he'll be motivated after falling all the way to the third round.

Jay: Hi Ray. How do you feel about MR? Dont think hes gonna be a franchise QB. He is an upgrade over Landry/Dobbs, but his decision making is poor. He too often holds the ball too long or too quick to check downs. From stadium view he doesnt see open receivers well. Numbers suggests hes solid, but performance says otherwise.

Ray Fittipaldo: He's still learning. As I wrote in a previous answer he's 4-2 as a starter. He knows he's playing on a team with a really good defense. In a lot of these games all he has to do is not make mistakes and make a few plays here and there. It's not pretty to watch, but the Steelers have won four in a row.

Advertise with us

Eddie C from KY: With Only 8 catches the entire year and Punt Return average of only 3.7 yards per return, why did the Steelers keep Switzer over Eli Rogers? Was it the uncertainty of Rogers health?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not entirely sure, but I never though Rogers would beat out Switzer for that final WR spot. Switzer is tight with Ben, and that matters. He's fallen off the radar with Rudolph as the QB. He's only getting a few snaps a game. I think you see the coaches seeing what you're seeing in terms of the punt returns. Diontae Johnson was back there half the punts against the Rams. I think you'll see that continue especially when there is a good chance for a return.

Nick: Hi Ray, do the Steelers practice just on Tues this week with pads? Do they rest on Weds when the game is on Thurs? Is James connor healthy enough for full participation in the game?

Ray Fittipaldo: Just one practice today. No pads. It'll basically be a walk-through with another day-before-the-game walk-through tomorrow. Playing an NFL game on three days' rest is ludicrous. The NFLPA should look out for the safety of their players in the next CBA negotiation. And the owners should realize it's not good for their players.

Ray Fittipaldo: And yes it appears Conner will be good to go.

Advertise with us

MTScott: Why is the O-Line not being dominant this year? Is age catching up with them?

Ray Fittipaldo: I would disagree with you if you thought they were dominant last year. They were a very good pass protecting group, but the struggles in the run game date to the middle of last season. I think some of the struggles in the run game are because of the young QB not being able to push the ball down the field. Safeties and LBs don't really have to worry much about Rudolph making big plays. But I do think much of it has to do with the players not aging very gracefully. I wouldn't be surprised if they drafted an offensive lineman with one of their first three picks in April.

MTScott: Do you think Cam Sutton is capable of replacing Mark Barron in that role?

Ray Fittipaldo: Well, he played that role last season in a pinch when there were some injuries. But why do you want to switch? Barron just played 71 defensive snaps against the Rams and played well.

574Fan: Thanks for chatting Ray. Gerry wrote an article yesterday that touched on Conner's running style. Obviously Bell's style is unique in the league with his patience. But I remember analysts mentioning more than once during the Bell years how his style made it more difficult for his line to block for. It seems like, in hindsight, that style might have been easier for this particular group to block for than Conner's more traditional style. And does Conner's style, which is more sudden and straight ahead, contribute to his frequent injuries?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I'm not sure about what's causing Conner's injuries. But the RB position is one where you take a lot of hits. Conner has a long injury history dating to his days at Pitt. It's obviously an issue for the Steelers as they move forward and plan for the future. I just don't know if an RB is capable of changing their style in mid-career. I mean, they made it this far by playing one way. I just don't think they can change on the fly and be successful.

BoKnows: Hey Ray, thanks as always for taking time to do these chats. Thursday night will be the first real hostile road environment we've faced since NE - and the first one Mason has ever faced as a starting QB. (Sorry, i can't rank the fans of the Santa Clara 49ers as equivalent to Browns fans when it comes to hostility.) How significant an aspect do you think this will be?

Ray Fittipaldo: It'll be a tough game. But remember, if the Browns scuffle early that crowd will go from being loud to booing Baker Mayfield if the defense has a good game.

Spanky LaValliere: The problems in the run game seem to stem from the offensive line. Are the problems scheme related or player related. What is it going to take to be able to run the ball and close out games?

Ray Fittipaldo: Well, we're nine games in, so I'm not confident things will change drastically. Anything can happen, but the personnel is the personnel. Maybe the return of Ramon Foster will help some, but it's not like the running game was good when Foster was playing. It's been pretty bad all season long.

Advertise with us

VAsteelersFan: Hi Ray, 20+ penalties in the game against the Rams. Unwatchable. Do you think an NFL ref should make the cover of Madden 2021?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yeah and maybe then they'd get jinxed.

Harold H.: Hello, Ray - A little concerned about the Browns’ two RBs. How confident are you that the Men of Steel can contain them?

Ray Fittipaldo: That's probably the No. 1 thing the Steelers have to accomplish in this game. That's one of the ways they can lose this game.

Ray Fittipaldo: And no, I'm not completely confident. The Steelers are very average against the run.

Advertise with us

Harold H.: Last year, the Steelers’ D was very effective in confusing Mayfield - especially in the game at Heinz Field. How do you expect the Browns to attack the Steelers with Mayfield?

Ray Fittipaldo: Any QB struggles when they're under pressure. The nice thing about the Steelers this season is they can pressure with four. That leaves seven to defend the pass. I think that's why you're seeing more turnovers this season. Being able to get pressure with a four-man rush is key.

574Fan: RE: Lacking WR play - this team could have many needs in the offseason (aging OL, Bud, Hargrave may leave,TE play still not settled,etc). Washington and Johnson have shown flashes, but not consistency. JuJu looks like he needs those guys to develop so he can move inside to the slot at least occasionally. So, are these flashes enough stick with those 2 young guys as 2 of your top 3 WRs going into next season?

Ray Fittipaldo: That's a good question. I don't think they want to invest another high draft pick in a WR. They've done that three years in a row. A 2 for JuJu, a 2 for Washington and an early 3 on Johnson. As you mention they'll have other needs. It'll be interesting to see how the coaches and GM are thinking after the season ends. JuJu is going into the final year of his contract so a lot of that will depend on whether they think they have a good chance of re-signing him.

MrCJJr: Hello Ray, I didn't get a chance to formally say "Thank you" for correctly predicting the Cincy game awhile back. I was able to go to work (here in Cincy) w/o the embarrassment of the Steelers losing. On to the question: Can the NFL make "stick-um" legal again? The receivers need something to cure the case of the dropsies ASAP.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Some call Lester Hayes!

574Fan: Any feel for how long until Snell is able to go again?

Ray Fittipaldo: The time frame is 2-6 weeks and we're about at week 3 now. I'm guessing he'll be ready for the Cardinals game or the Bills game. Not sure about the Bengals.

Fitzburgh: Do the Steelers have the 5th year option on #39 or is that reserved only for the team that drafted him?

Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers have the fifth-year option. Control his right through 2022. I'm sure they'll try to sign him to a second contract when the time comes.

Advertise with us

Goldstar: Seems like Bush has been much less noticeable last few games - has his play slacked off a bit or just overshadowed by others?

Ray Fittipaldo: Well, in the Rams game he didn't play all that much because the coaches used Mark Barron for almost the entire game and played with six defensive backs. But I agree with you for the most part. He hasn't been as noticeable. I think he's struggled in coverage some so that's the reason. He's simply not playing as much as he was earlier in the season when Barron and Vince Williams were injured.

Goldstar: Would this team be a legitimate super bowl contender with a healthy Ben?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think so yes. I wasn't really impressed with the offense against the Patriots or in the first half of the Seattle game. Ben wasn't playing very well. But we now know Ben was injured before the Seattle game so that explains why there might have been some struggles in that game. Whatever the case, I think he would have been better if he was healthy, and this team would be dangerous.

Utah Jim: Is it time to put Nix on IR and sign a fullback? I think they desperately need one.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I wouldn't rule it out. Only six games left after the Browns. But it's not like there are a lot of quality FBs on the street. Not many are being produced by the colleges. The Steelers had to convert Nix from a DL to a FB when they signed him.

Justin: In the last game, right before the Steelers kicked the field goal to go up 17-12, Mason Rudolph threw what was later called an incomplete pass that Villanueva recovered at midfield. My question, when the ball was loose it appears that Clay Matthews purposely kicked ball towards the Steelers endzone. I thought that was a penalty, why wasn't it called? Because it was an incomplete pass or did they miss it? Sorry for a long worded question.

Ray Fittipaldo: I asked the same thing. I know batting the ball forward with your hand is illegal. The Steelers got called for that a few years ago. I think it's probably more difficult to prove with a kicking motion. But I agree with you. I thought he purposely kicked it. Which really was kind of dumb. If he fell on it (if it was a fumble) the Steelers would only have had a 2-point lead the Rams had plenty of time for a winning drive.

CincyJoe: What percent of the time does McDonald fumble his catches, if he completes the catch?

Ray Fittipaldo: He's another one who had a drop against the Rams. He also had a bobble on one of his three catches. Not having a great year.

Advertise with us

Munchak’s ghost: Thought the O-line experiment an unusual mid-season re-arrangement, any insight as to the reasoning and how would you grade the result?

Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin said he want three tackles against the Rams for pass protection purposes. In other words, he didn't think BJ Finney was athletic enough to handle Aaron Donald. That's basically what went into the decision.

Rob : Do you expect to see the same OL lineup vs the Browns' pass rush? It would seem the weather will dictate more of a smash mouth game, especially with Conner back.

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't. If Ramon Foste r is able to play he'll go back to starting at LG and Matt Feiler will go back to RT.

Lenny from NY: Morning Ray. Why go shotgun on 3rd and 1. You take away the defense defending against a possible QB sneak. Horrible play calling. Something Haley would have done. Thanks

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I agree. But Rudolph almost never took a snap from under center in college. I think that probably has something to do with it.

Jerry: With our schedule I think we can win the North! Your thoughts

Ray Fittipaldo: My crystal ball says 3.5% chance. But hey, the Ravens overcame a similar deficit after nine games last season so never say never!

Harold H.: The Browns received more hype prior to the season than any other team I can remember in recent memory. Of course, their starving, gullible fan base bit on the hype fish hook like a hungry walleye. Was it all because of OBJ and Mayfield - or did the national media truly believe they were going to be legitimate? What were your thoughts while the hype machine was humming?

Ray Fittipaldo: Who knows what goes into forming the opinions of national people. I don't think they're very informed for the most part. They're easily swayed by free agency and acquisitions and give little thought to other aspects that go into team-building. I picked them to finish third in the AFC North. And so far I'm right!

Advertise with us

Guest: Ray - How does a QB get hit from the front, driven backwards, and "fumble" a ball 10 yds downfield? The genius broadcasters never address this, so maybe you can help.I'm not a rocket scientist, so perhaps I don't understand the special laws of physics that apply on - and only on - a football field.

Ray Fittipaldo: The open hand. That's what the officials look for. So even though the momentum of the hit took him forward the arm didn't necessarily cause the ball to go forward. In other words, the arm has to be coming forward. And from the angles I saw it was difficult to determine if it was.

Jon Snow: I predict the Steelers MVP for the thursday game will be Vince Williams for helping to shut down their run game. what do you think?

Ray Fittipaldo: He might get to play a lot because of that. The Browns have a very good running game.

Jake: Ray, What is up with Vance? As No. 1 TE he can't be dropping passes? Has to be more involved? He is due for a big game don't you think? Thank you.

Ray Fittipaldo: I'm not sure. I'm writing about his struggles later on today after practice. Make sure to come back and read it!

Mark M: Seems a lot of people especially the national media/talking heads have forgotten the 3 losses to Seahawks, 49'ers, and Ravens (all considered top teams) could have easily been wins if not for turnovers in the 4th quarter and all in scoring position. I think we are a lot better then we get credit for...agree?

Ray Fittipaldo: I tend to agree. But good teams find a way to beat other good teams. Have to find a way to win some of those.

Professor Flush: Do the Steelers intend to use Banner as an eligible receiver in their 3 tackle set?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not really.

Tony: I still think the Browns are a team to be careful with the Steelers always play down to their competition what do you think

Ray Fittipaldo: They're 3-6. They're not terrible. They've won against the Ravens and Bills, two teams that are currently in the playoffs. They'll be at home. They have tons of talent. I know they have problems, but this will be a tough game.

rcc prof: Let me try this on you: in my neighborhood, I sign Dupre now that he's becoming an impact player and not mess with the defense. I would then draft a tight end who can catch and run and a running back who can carry the ball 100 times like Tomlin wants. Now, do you stop in my neighborhood for a brewsky or keep driving?

Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers don't negotiate contracts during the season. Company policy. I like your line of thinking. In a perfect world they'd be able to keep Dupree and address those other needs. But you can only pay so many players. You have to pay JuJu, Watt, Minkah. Not sure if there's enough $ to take care of Bud, too.

jud: What's your predicted result 10-6?

Ray Fittipaldo: I'll say 9-7.

jud: Who is your team MVP?

Ray Fittipaldo: Minkah

MrCJJr: Ben benefited from having a great defense his first yr as a starter. Why is the expectation so much higher for Mason?

Ray Fittipaldo: Different expectations. He has no running game. Ben had the No. 1 running game in the NFL. It makes a huge difference. I'm not saying Mason is as talented as Ben. But things might be different if they even had the slightest threat of a running game.

BigAl456: Ray, if you had to attribute the accolades to one player for effectively shutting down Cooper Kupp, who would it be? Thanks

Ray Fittipaldo: Mike Hilton was on him quite a bit, but they doubled him a lot. It wasn't all Hilton.

Bob: Could McDonald go to FB? I saw at least one play were he did it Sunday.

Ray Fittipaldo: He could, but he's also their No. 1 TE.

Kiwi Jimmy: Special teams coverage has been very good this season. Who do you single out?

Ray Fittipaldo: Johny Holton has been good. The kickoff unit has been pretty good overall, but they gave up a 35-yard return when the game was on the line against the Rams. That wasn't good.

Stuckinnj: Was that really McDonald I saw taking a rush on a 2nd and long play? Why?!?!?!?!

Ray Fittipaldo: I have no idea. That was bizarre.

bambam: didn't the steelers resign the lb/fb, why not put him on the 53 and nix on IR?

Ray Fittipaldo: They can still do that tomorrow.

Ray Fittipaldo: OK that's all the time we have for this week. I have to go watch some practice and see who might play Thursday night. We'll do another chat next Tuesday.