The football playing careers of Antonio Brown and Le’Veon Bell long ago ended. It is the year 2026.

They last played into 2021. Bell succumbed to wear and tear like so many other running backs. Brown retired.

They now are each eligible for the Pro Football Hall of Fame. Not just that, they remain eligible for the Steelers’ Hall of Honor, as they have been the past two years.

The question today, will those two ever be honored by the Steelers, ever be embraced by the franchise and their fans again? Or are their Steelers legacies ruined even if they do make it into the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Advertise with us

It may not matter to Brown and Bell today. Still, just over one year ago, they were adored by the franchise and its far-reaching fan base. They were on pace to be the most productive at their positions in team history. Now, for the most part, they are despised by those fans, and management and coaching staff are disgusted with both of them.

That may ease over time. As an example, Santonio Holmes left on uncertain terms when he was traded to the New York Jets in 2010. So did Rod Woodson, who bitterly departed as a free agent when the Steelers would not meet his contract demands. Neither, however, forced his way out of town, and both have returned to be honored by the franchise and are considered favorite sons today by the team.

On the other side, two other would-be great Steelers have not exactly been embraced here.

Linebacker Mike Merriweather still was under contract when he held out the entire 1988 season demanding a new one. The Steelers then traded him to Minnesota for a first-round 1989 draft pick. Merriweather, who once held the Steelers record with 15 sacks in 1984, floundered and had just 10 combined over his final five seasons in the league. All-Pro wide receiver Roy Jefferson was the star of the late 1960s Steelers. He challenged Chuck Noll’s authority in the 1970 preseason, and Noll traded him to Baltimore for a receiver and a fourth-round draft pick that became Dwight White in 1971.

There is so much story yet to be told for both Brown and Bell, who can sign with another team starting at 4 p.m. Wednesday when he becomes an unrestricted free agent for the first time.

Advertise with us

The narrative around the NFL is that Brown won his duel with the Steelers. Indeed, if that is based on money, he won in a big way — more of it and more of it guaranteed over the next three years.

But when Brown wakes up one morning, he will realize that he plays for the Oakland Raiders, who were 4-12 last season, which is not unusual for them. It was their fourth record of 4-12 or worse in seven years. They have had one winning record in the past 16 seasons — and many of those were deep dives of 4-12 or worse.

He also may realize that Derek Carr is his quarterback. Brown joins a team that is trying to turn things around — eventually — with a youth movement, as he turns 31 years old this summer.

And the narrative that Ben Roethlisberger showed up Brown took on a life of its own when the opposite was true — Brown often tried to show up his quarterback. Roethlisberger said one mild thing on a radio show, and another time he wanted a play run again in practice when Brown ran a wrong route.

In the meantime, Brown showed up Roethlisberger, or at least tried to, by often waving his arms in the middle of the field when the ball did not come his way, sulking on the field, attacking water coolers and other fits he threw on the sideline when he felt ignored in the passing game.

Advertise with us

Roethlisberger never said a word publicly about it.

Bell is about to sign a big contract with someone, then the long-standing question will be answered — did he make up the $14.5 million he lost by not playing last season or by not signing the multi-year contract the Steelers offered him? There also will be a longer watch — can he be as effective with his new team as he was with the Steelers?

How will the Steelers ever win again without Brown and Bell? The New England Patriots won two Super Bowls in the past three seasons without them or anything close to them. Quick, name the halfbacks and wide receivers who led the Patriots during those Super Bowl runs. The Steelers still have more talent at both positions than the Patriots.

The Steelers are about to embark on a new era without Brown and Bell. Maybe they won’t be as good, maybe they won’t win another Super Bowl for a while. But then, they did not win one with them either.

Ed Bouchette: ebouchette@post-gazette.com and Twitter @EdBouchette

Advertise with us