Mike Tomlin is lucky. Most coaches would have been fired after the Steelers’ drama of the past two seasons when they went from being a model NFL franchise to one that’s considered an out-of-control circus, Team Turmoil, if you will.
Tomlin wasn’t fired because his overall body of work has been so strong. Now, he gets a chance to take back control of his football team. We’ll see what he does with it. It’s nice to think he and co-enabler Art Rooney II, for that matter, learned from the Antonio Brown fiasco and, to a lesser degree, the Le’Veon Bell mess before it. It’s a painful and costly lesson, but one that should help Tomlin and the team moving forward.
Tomlin’s biggest mistake – with Rooney’s backing -- was treating Brown and Bell like men and expecting them to act accordingly. They responded by behaving like immature kids, taking advantage of him and making him look like a fool. Bell missed a walk-through the day before the Jacksonville playoff game after the 2017 season and arrived at Heinz Field late on game day. Brown routinely was late or missed meetings, which probably shouldn’t come as a surprise considering Tomlin allowed James Harrison to sleep through them. It wasn’t until Brown went AWOL before the final game last season that Tomlin finally took action. Even then, he benched Brown rather than suspend him, which meant Brown received his game check. That was a horrible mistake because the other players took notice and weren’t happy.
I get that handling star players is the toughest part of coaching these days. The players make more money – a lot more – than the coach. They have more power because they know they won’t be fired, the coach will. Their brands are so big on social media that they think they are bigger than the team.
Coaching can be so challenging.
I asked one former coach, whom I greatly respect, how he dealt with his superstars. I loved his response:
Read More
“I told them they get their perks in their checks. They get paid more than the other players. That’s fine, they earned it. But don’t disrespect me or your teammates by showing up late. You don’t treat every player the same way, but there has to be certain rules for everybody.”
I think back to something Mike Sullivan said in 2016 when his Penguins were on their way to the first of two consecutive Stanley Cups:
“For me, the biggest challenge of coaching in this league is your ability to build relationships with those guys, your ability to sell them on your message. Today’s athletes are very prepared. They’re very smart. You can’t just come in and bang it over their head and try to force it down their throat. It’s a cooperative effort. The balancing act is trying to inspire them and, at the same time, holding them accountable to a certain standard.”
Sullivan is a master at it. That’s why he has won so much and will continue to win. That’s why he’s Pittsburgh’s best coach, and it’s not even close.
That isn’t to say Sullivan’s job is easy. His stars – Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, Kris Letang, Matt Murray – are good people who don’t cause him the problems that Brown and Bell did Tomlin. But they also have egos. Sullivan walks the fine line between recognizing their greatness and being their boss.
Go back to soon after he took the Penguins job in December 2015. Remember him yelling at Crosby, Malkin and the others on the bench when he thought they were chirping too much at the game officials? “Shut up and just play.” It was a beautiful moment. Sullivan even has done a remarkable job of figuring out Phil Kessel, who’s been known to be tough on his coaches.
Tomlin could learn plenty from Sullivan.
Brown and Bell are all but officially gone. So is the poison they spread in the locker room. You can’t win with that type of people. It doesn’t matter if they are extraordinary talents, as Brown and Bell certainly are.
The Steelers’ locker room is filled with quality men. I’ll take Cam Heyward, Joe Haden, Ben Roethlisberger and the entire offensive line – just to name a few – on my team any day of the week. They want only to win and are willing to accept discipline from their coach to achieve success because they understand that’s the only true measure of greatness. As Ramon Foster has said, “When you win, everyone eats.”
All eyes will be on Tomlin in the days ahead. He has more young players who are headed toward stardom. JuJu Smith-Schuster. James Conner. T.J. Watt. Smith-Schuster already is a giant on social media. All will make huge money.
Does Tomlin allow them to become the next Brown or Bell? Or does he demand the accountability that Sullivan does?
Nothing less than Tomlin’s job and the Steelers’ success are at stake.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.