Free agency is about to begin Wednesday, and the Steelers traditionally play that part of the game conservatively. While the loss of Le’Veon Bell and the trade of Antonio Brown will attract most of the attention, they do usually sign a body or two.

This will be Kevin Colbert’s 20th season as Steelers general manager/director of football operations. During that time, the Steelers have not signed many top-of-the-line unrestricted free agents, but they did find some quality players who helped them win Super Bowls.

Also during that time, they signed some real clunkers who stole their money.

Here, in our judgment, are the five best free-agent signings under Colbert and the five worst.

Advertise with us

They do not include the so-called “street” free agents such as James Harrison, who originally signed with them as an undrafted rookie, was cut, joined the Baltimore Ravens, who then cut him before he signed back with the Steelers. Otherwise, he would have ranked No. 1 on our best list.

That also goes for quarterback Kent Graham, who was cut by Arizona and signed by the Steelers in 2000; he would have ranked No. 3 on our worst list if he qualified as an UFA.

Here, then, are our two lists:

THE 5 BEST

1. James Farrior, ILB (2002-2011) – He became a leader of what was the best defense in the NFL during the middle of that decade, when they captured two Super Bowl victories and made a third visit. He was a first-round draft pick by the Jets, who played him on the outside; the Steelers moved him to inside linebacker, where he thrived playing all over their defense as the mack linebacker. He consistently led them in tackles – six times he had over 100 during his 10 seasons.

Advertise with us

2. Jeff Hartings, C (2001-2006) – Starting in the mid-1960s, the Steelers basically had three centers into the new century – Ray Mansfield, Mike Webster and Dermontti Dawson, the latter two in the Hall of Fame. With Dawson’s retirement after the 2000 season, the Steelers needed his replacement. They signed Hartings, who played right guard in Detroit. He moved to center with the Steelers and kept their tradition of excellence at center, making two Pro Bowls.

3. Ryan Clark, FS (2006-2013) – The Steelers needed a playmaker at free safety, and although Clark was so-so with 11 interceptions over his eight years with them, he had a more important job – he was the leader of the secondary and paired perfectly with Troy Polamalu. Clark often covered for Polamalu’s extraordinary freelance play that otherwise could have left large holes in the middle of the field.

4. Kimo von Oelhoffen, NT/DE (2000-2005) – One of their first free-agent signings under Colbert. KvO played nose tackle his first season, then moved to defensive end. He missed just one game and two starts over his six seasons with the Steelers. His most memorable play came when he hit Bengals quarterback Carson Palmer early in their 2005 wild-card playoff game in Cincinnati on the second play from scrimmage. The hit blew out Palmer’s knee and the Steelers went on to win on their march to their first Super Bowl victory in 26 years.

5. Mike Mitchell, FS (2014-2017) – His inclusion tells you everything about their lack of success signing free agents in this century. He signed for five years, $25 million. He was mostly a durable player, having started every game until his fourth season, when he missed three games and four starts. But he wasn’t the playmaker they hoped he would be. He had four interceptions for Carolina in 2013 and just four total in his four seasons with the Steelers, who cut him with one year left on his deal.

THE 5 WORST

Advertise with us

1. Ladarius Green, TE (2016) – The Steelers needed another tight end after Heath Miller retired and they opted for Green from San Diego as primarily a receiver for the position. They gave him $20 million over four years, but he lasted less than one. They weren’t aware he had a history of concussion problems, and they resurfaced early in his first training camp with them. He played just six games, caught 18 passes, and that was the end of his NFL career.

2. LeGarrette Blount, RB (2014) – It’s not that Blount was a bad player, just a bad fit with the Steelers. After someone apparently promised him more time on the field, he was not used much – 65 carries (266 yards) in 11 games as Le’Veon Bell’s backup. He and Bell were arrested for smoking marijuana in a car the day they were to leave for a preseason game. Blount then left the field before their 11th game in Tennessee ended, and he had no carries. He was cut the next day, signed quickly by the Patriots and won a Super Bowl ring.

3. Todd Peterson, K (2002) – After declining to match Kris Brown’s RFA contract with Houston, the Steelers signed Peterson to a deal of four years, nearly $4 million. He made just 12 of 21 field goal tries in 10 games before they cut him. His agent claimed he was hurt and maybe he was right — Peterson played three more seasons with two other teams and made 53 of 62 attempts. The Steelers signed Jeff Reed midseason to replace him.

4. Sean Mahan, C (2007) – Mahan signed a five-year, $17 million contract from Tampa Bay after Hartings retired. The Steelers did not get so lucky at center this time. Mahan could not handle big defensive linemen. He did start all 16 games but before the start of the 2008 season, the Steelers traded him back to Tampa for a seventh-round draft choice.

5. Jay Riemersma, TE (2003-2004) – Between Mark Bruener’s final season and Heath Miller’s first, the Steelers had a tight end void and tried to fill it with Riemersma. He played his first six seasons with Buffalo and seemed to always play well against the Steelers. Once he joined them, he did little. He played in 22 games, started nine and caught just 17 passes for 220 yards and three touchdowns and never played for another team.