Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my weekly Steelers chat. Happy New Year. Let's get started.
Steeler Joe: I really want to understand: Help me. Does Keith Butler manage the defense or Mike Tomlin? What role does Tomlin have--is he in charge of the secondary? If so, should the blame for defensive secondary miscommunication fall to him instead of Butler? There has been a lot of "nudge" and "wink" stuff from PG staffers about the defense, and who is really in charge, but I'd like to hear it out loud and clear. Would firing Butler really resolve the issue? Or is Tomlin the problem?
Ray Fittipaldo: I can tell you Mike Tomlin is more involved in the defense than he has ever been. He let it slip in the postgame news conference after the Patriots game that he was too distracted by arguing with an official that he failed to communicate the correct call to the secondary on the play where Chris Hogan scored. That kind of went unnoticed, but I noticed it. So he is obviously involved to the point where he is communicating calls on the field. Whether that's directly to players or through another coach does not matter. Will Keith Butler become the scapegoat? Perhaps. But there is going to come a time where the buck stops with Tomlin. The Rooneys like coaching continuity, but there is also a time for change. It will be interesting to see what Art Rooney Ii does.
BB: Ray - Over under on Steelers coaching staff changes?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know a number, but inevitably there will be change.
Steeler Joe: Chance that we'd be able to pry CJ Mosely away from the Ravens, since he's a free agent this year? Maybe if we throw some of the Le'veon Bell savings at him? Money better spent, I'd say.
Read More
Ray Fittipaldo: Teams like the Ravens don't let good players like Mosley walk away. He's still in his prime. Only older players like Terrell Suggs and Sean Lee will be available. Suggs because he's old and Lee because he can't stay healthy. And other players like them. I can't imagine a scenario where Mosley walks away from Baltimore.
DaquidoBazzini: Hi, Ray….I can go either way on Mike Tomlin. But I’ve been hard pressed to find any Steeler fan that likes him.
That’s not his purpose as a HC, but isn’t it a growing concern by ownership that he does not give off a fan friendly vibe and his critics are growing?
Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers don't care if he's well-liked by fans. The Steelers care if he makes the playoffs and wins Super Bowls. He hasn't wonder a Super Bowl in a decade.
Steeler in Charlotte: Is there any talk around the team about Shazier's role moving forward with his contract ending?
Ray Fittipaldo: No they haven't discussed that with us. I am sure if Ryan wants to hang around they'll let him hang around. He did some work in scouting this year. He was around the players a lot. But they have not announced anything about his future.
Hasobesecats: Do you think the Steelers will save themselves $9 million of wasted, chewed up bubblegum by letting Dupree go?
Ray Fittipaldo: I can't imagine a scenario where the Steelers pay Dupree $9.2 for his services next season. Now they might come to terms with him on a cheaper long-term deal. Maybe he's worth $5 million a year over a three-year prove-it type of deal. And you bring in someone to challenge him for the job. But you don't pay that type of money to someone like Dupree who hasn't earned it. It would be foolish.
Steeler Joe: Marvin Lewis as defensive coordinator? Plausible?
Ray Fittipaldo: Let's wait to see what happens with Keith Butler first. Sure Lewis would be a candidate. He has a strong history as a coordinator and knows the 3-4 defense as well as anyone. I would be a little scared off because of the types of players he had in Cincinnati, but at the same time, he would have no say in personnel here so that wouldn't really be an issue.
DaquidoBazzini: What do you think the Steelers could get (and I’m not expecting a lot because of age) for AB in a trade between now and the draft?
Also, what ever happened to the always laughing, upbeat AB? Seems very sour these days.
Ray Fittipaldo: That's a great question. What did the Raiders get for Khalil Mack? I know there was a first-round pick involved, maybe two. Brown is 30 so the price might be a little lower. But I'd have to get a high No. 1 for him. That being said teams would know the Steelers want to deal Brown for a reason so they might have some leverage.
BB: Ray - Tomlin's Steelers a lock when they are big point favorites against a weak opponent.....like printing money.
Ray Fittipaldo: You are correct. It's the reason they missed the playoffs this year. They lost to a 4-12 Raiders team, a 6-10 Broncos team and tied a 7-8-1 Browns team. Bud Dupree said it after the game: This group plays down to the level of its competition. There is no denying that.
Larry in KY: Did the Killer B's sting us this year? Bryant's bad behavior forcing a trade, Bell's merecurial holdout, Boswell forgetting how to kick, Antonio's media antics, Ben's untimely INT's, Butler's passive D???
Ray Fittipaldo: You pretty much covered it.
Spaniard: Hi Ray! Hope you had a good holiday, and a safe and happy 2019! Tomlin has never had a losing season. Every coach has pros and cons; Tomlin's biggest faults are his bad game day decision-making (in real time), and the tendency of his teams to either play down to (and sometimes up to) opponents.
Do you think that Tomlin is a good coach that has exceeded expectations considering the talent level of his teams, or is he an average coach who hasn't been able to capitalize on the talent he has? In other words, Cowher had bad seasons (in 15 years he had 3 losing seasons, including 2 that the team went 6-10)--do you think that his bad records in certain years were just a reflection of really, really bad teams, or does it show that Tomlin is a better overall motivator/better at working what he has? Or is there no correlation in your opinion?
A follow up question, a conundrum: would you rather have a consistently good-to-average coach who's
Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin is a good coach, but every coach has a shelf life. You saw what happened in Green Bay. It happened here with Chuck Noll and Bill Cowher. There will come a time it happens with Tomlin. Art Rooney II has to figure out if this team truly is among the most talented rosters in the NFL. If he believes that then he must seriously consider a change because Tomlin coaches in way too many close games, especially against inferior competition. However, has the media overrated the talent he's had to work with? In that case, he has to expect more out of Kevin Colbert. I tend to think the Steelers have a talented offensive roster that has largely underachieved. And I tend to think he has a defenisve roster that lacks playmakers.

Jocko from Morningside: I know how the Steelers operate but hasnt the NFL changed..New coaches are successful..Nagy..Pederson..McVay...why can't they fire Tomlin? Why is it unheard of?
Ray Fittipaldo: It's not unheard of and they certainly can. I just don't expect it this year. We'll see what happens.
Marc S: What is it going to take for Art 2 to fire Tomlin, honestly?
Ray Fittipaldo: Joe Starkey had a good column on Tomlin last night. It's online at post-gazette.com right now. The seat should be hot next year. Others might feel the time is now. We don't know how Art II feels. He'll meet with reporters in a few weeks and we'll get a better idea. I suspect he'll keep Tomlin but ask for a better running game, fewer turnovers, yada yada yada.
Sonny: Ray, when this organization be more active in free agency. It needs to be more aggressive
Ray Fittipaldo: They'll have more cap space than usual. However, they need to sign the QB to another contract. That will eat up a lot of money and they won't be signing him to a longer-term deal so they can't spread out the $ as much as they previously did. They also have some others guys like Joe Haden they'll want to extend.
Steeler Joe: I found DeCastro's comments in yesterday's piece by Gerry Dulac really unsettling. How does a team come into a must-win game with that kind of mindset? I've never been a "fire Tomlin" guy at all, very much acknowledge his skills. But that just seems like a giant waving red flag.
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree with you. The Browns almost pulled off the upset. Can you imagine the outrage in Steelers Nation if they lost to a depleted Bengals team?
Doug in Raleigh: I would hate to see the Steelers keep Tomlin and lose Munchak . Is there any chance they would go totally out of their comfort zone, and fire Tomlin and promote Munchak to the head-coaching job?
Ray Fittipaldo: That's not their style. They've been able to keep Munchak int he past. Maybe they can do it again. Apparently, the Broncos already asked for permission to interview him. And Arizona wanted him last year. They're looking again and could come after him harder if they really want him. He might be tough to keep this time.
Hasobesecats: Was it just me or did that Hilton, corner blitz get less and less effective since week five of last season?
Ray Fittipaldo: It wasn't you. Teams were ready for it.
mrbig: tomlin does nothing to improve himself!! same bad challenges, poor situational, playing down, etc year after year! 3 playoff wins since 2010! Why keep finding scapegoats??
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't disagree with you. Sometimes change is good. If not with the head coach then maybe with changes in personnel or other changes on the coaching staff. You can't stand pat if you're Art Rooney II. Change is inevitable.
Bob : Hi Ray. First-time on your chat. I’m not sold on Tomlin being fired as seems to be the case with a lot of people. He does have responsibility but I think there needs to be a thorough accounting of all the assistants and do what is necessary. What say you?
Ray Fittipaldo: I's an interesting situation for Art Rooney II. Maybe the best thing for this team would be a new voice. But you better have the right man signed sealed and delivered. And you better have confidence that he'd be able to find assistant coaches that could mold this roster into a winner. I'm not sure if Art has gone down that road which is why I think Tomlin will return. If you're asking me, I don't think now would be a bad time for a major change. But I readily admit I have more of a hockey owner's mentality when it comes to coaching changes. And like I said, I don't think Rooney will make that move.
Alan: This organization seems to be stuck with no progress over the past several years. I think the Steelers need to go outside the norm this offeseasaon by either spending a bit more in free agency and/or moving up in the draft and grabbing an impact defensive player. What say you?
Ray Fittipaldo: I just don't see it. Yes, they'll have cap space, but they have a lot of guys, including the QB, to sign.
Harry Newsome: Lamar Jackson is a rookie QB and wins the division..Baker is great already..are the Steelers and Tomlin now becoming the old outdated Bengals and Marvin Lewis?
Ray Fittipaldo: I would say "Baker Mayfield is great" already. He'll make the Browns a much tougher challenge than usual, but let's not make him out to be the next Joe Montana yet either. And let's hold off on the Lamar Jackson stuff too. I still think Roethlisberger is the best QB in the division. The coaches and maybe the owner have to convince him that his gunslinger ways might not be the best thing for this team right now. I know it's toough to change, but you can't lead the NFL in interceptions and expect to make the playoffs. It was kind of weird last night to hear Rotherlisberger lament the turnovers on one breath and then in the next revert back to the 'I'm not going to change my gunslinger ways'. He has to change if this team is going to be successful next season.
Bob M: How soon to we clean house.Some new blood needed.Coaches and players way to complacent with the way things are.
Ray Fittipaldo: Change will be inevitable. Many players won't be back. Ramon Foster and Marcus Gilbert might have played their final games as Steelers. There are plenty of others won't won't be back.
ryanh: do you think butler, and danny smith will be brought back
Ray Fittipaldo: We'll find out soon. They usually make decisions on their assistant coaches with a week or so of the season ending.
Hasobesecats: Please tell me the Steelers will go with some middle grade FAti replace Dupree next year instead of paying out nearly $10 million
Ray Fittipaldo: They can't keep him for the $9.2 million. That's just not good business.
Devin: I know they were 13-3 last year and I might get made fun of for this but am I dumb to think that this years Steelers team was better than last years? I know they gave up leads and minimal turnovers but the defense was ranked in the Top 10, offense was great in red zone and third downs. I think last year they played an easy schedule and got a lot of bounces. This year, a hard schedule mixed with bad luck (missed calls), bad bounces and too many interceptions. I might be in the minority and naive, but I feel better entering this offseason than last and I feel good about next year.
Ray Fittipaldo: You are certainly in the minority, Devin. I get your point about last season. They didn't face a lot of good QBs en route to those 13 wins. That's the luck of the draw. But there is no excuse to losing to the Raiders or the Broncos or tying the Browns with Tyrod Taylor at QB. None. You have to win those games. I know there were bad calls in some games and some untimely turnovers, but you have to be good enough to overcome that stuff. They weren't good enough.
Ed Bouchette and Gerry Dulac break down the Steelers' win over the Bengals.
Colin: Promote Munch and can Tomlin? I would do it, then fire Butler and st coach. Thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not their style to do that.
Andrew in ATL: A lot of discussion about Tomlin's coaching but to me the biggest problem for the Steelers is Ben's interceptions. What can the team do to get him to have better ball protection. I understand you can't sit him but something has to change.
Ray Fittipaldo: It doesn't sound like the offensive coordinator will do it. Did you hear him back in November when he was asked about the pass-run ratio? I think the quote was: "I have Ben Roethlisberger. I have Antonio Brown. Why wouldn't I throw it?' So it would have to come from ownership.
ryanh: what players shouldnt be brought back next year
Ray Fittipaldo: Ramon Foster almost certainly is gone. Others as well.
Clark: Ideal Draft: Corner in the first. ILB in the second. Thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not a bad assessment. But as always, what's going to be available? This year at least they have No. 20.
Juice: Put a good word in for me with the Steeler higher ups....I'll sit in the booth and help Tomlin with the challenges for free next season.....I only ask for a 6 pack of Iron City each game. I couldn't do worse than him.
Ray Fittipaldo: I'll let Art know.
Mike: First round pick has to be used on either a corner or a linebacker correct?
Ray Fittipaldo: I would think so, yes.
mrbig: cb, ilb, blah blah, I'm tired of talking about players... we have the roster to AT LEAST make the playoffs! Would you agree??
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes I think they underachieved and were outcoached in several games. Can't happen.
thomastown: Lost in all the talk of the Steelers' collapse is the fact that the Ravens really took the bull by the horns and won the games they needed to win. Compared to the Steelers, do you think this was due to the Ravens coaches doing a better job at preparing and keeping the team focused or was it due to having better talent?
Ray Fittipaldo: The Ravens don't have better talent than the Steelers. But John Harbaugh certainly did a better job of coaching his team this year. I don't think there is any doubt about that. He got more out of less and knew how to get the most out of his players.
Mark: Happy New Year, Ray! Question: which 5 veterans would you say are least likely to be with the team when training camp opens? I'll spot you Stevan Ridley...
Ray Fittipaldo: Foster and Gilbert are two great candidates. Foster is 33 and Gilbert will be 31 and has been injury prone.
Juice: ILB has to be a priority for next years draft right? Also, should we target a veteran CB in free agency to help Haden? No one on the roster seems to have separated themselves.
Ray Fittipaldo: I'd prefer the draft. Get a good one at No. 20 if he's there. Let him learn from Haden.
ryanh: do you think the team has to trade up in the draft this year to finally get a game changer on defense
Ray Fittipaldo: I wouldn't be against it. And this year they'll be in better position to do that because they pick earlier. It's harder to do when you're picking at the end of the first round.
mrbig: In your honest opinion, do you think Tomlin has hit his ceiling? I don't think he has what it takes to put together a complete season -
Ray Fittipaldo: He has a team that's built to win now and hasn't delivered. I think he might have, but I also think he'll get at least one more opportunity to get it right.
Rocky: Ray, Happy New Year! I hope this year they can finally get a punter to help the defense in the 5th or 6th round. This has been a problem for the last 6 years but it never seems to get addressed. What say you about the current punter?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think he could do a better job of directional kicking, pinning opponents inside their 10, that type of thing. Even when the Steelers are at midfield it seems like the returners are fair catching it at the 20. That's not good enough. He's not the worst punter in the league, but they can do better.
Jeff G: It seems to me the Steelers challenges with lesser teams all start with Big Ben. Would love to know what is QB rating is in our losses to bad teams. The defense played great for nearly the entire game and did not give up a touchdown. Ben plays down to lesser teams. 3 picks in Cleveland, stunk in Denver, stunk in Oakland before getting hurt and a pick six yesterday. He's awful against bad teams.
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know about awful, but they shouldn't have as many close games as they do.
Gregory: Steelers failed to sign Weddle and Hightower when they had the chance, but did sign Burnett, Green, and Bostic. Terrible evaluations of need and their find talent on the cheap really cost them. Really should consider changes in the front office. Agree?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm with you on Weddle. That's a bad one that really hurt this team because they signed Green instead. I'm not convinced Hightower would have been a good signing. He's been injury prone since then.
Pat: Is there a rift in the locker room with AB and others.
Ray Fittipaldo: I think that's a fair assessment. Not sure if anyone other than Brown is a big problem though.
Juice: Watching the Browns and Ravens yesterday, I get the feeling that the Steelers will be on the outside looking in for quite some time in that division. Any hope we win the North in the next 3 years?
Ray Fittipaldo: It's certainly going to be tougher, but let's hold off on the Super Bowl parades for the Browns and Ravens please.
Ryno: Will the following playrs return to the Steelers next season? Yes, no or release and resign for less money are fine answers. Dupree, Boswell, Burnett, Bostic, Roger's, Burns, Foster, Berry, DHB.
Ray Fittipaldo: Of that group I think Foster and DHB are the only one who is gone for sure. Some others you mentioned are possibilities
Steve: With Gilbert & Foster perhaps gone they may need to draft Offensive lineman first ….Thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not first. Finney or Feiler can replace Foster and Chucks might be ready to play right tackle. But they'll need to replenish the depth to replace those guys. So maybe a middle- to late-round pick or a high priority undrafted free agent to develop much in the same way they developed Finney and Feiler.
Alphaf: Why are the Steelers so bad at assessing secondary talent when Tomlin was a secondary coach?
Ray Fittipaldo: Good question. It has to get better,
MARK PACE: Ray in your opinion what receivers are worth keeping?
Ray Fittipaldo: JuJu for sure. And you have to keep James Washington and hope he develops. Ben likes Eli. Switzer showed some promise.
Ironcitypat : Does Kevin Colbert get a pass on all these problems facing this team?
Ray Fittipaldo: No, nor should be. He's drafted some good players, but he's missed on too many first-rounders.
Steve: Ray Id not pay Ben 25M a year for next 2-3 yrs, they have proved that with him they are still a slightly above average team, play Mason, take $$$ and draft or trade for Defense...a bit of a rebuild but same old and getting $$ tied up in same old is bad business.
Ray Fittipaldo: Not sure he'd settle for $25 million a year, but I wouldn't pay him $30 million a year. Might be somewhere in the middle.
Ray Fittipaldo: Ok sorry I didn't get to all of your questions. The Steelers have an open locker room in a few minutes. I'll do another chat next Monday. Happy New Year.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.