Ed Bouchette and Gerry Dulac break down Steelers vs. Panthers

Antonio Brown is symptomatic of what’s going on in the NFL.

After eight games, he is on pace for another season of at least 100 catches and 1,000 receiving yards. He also has nine touchdown catches, which leads the league and puts him well on track to eclipse his personal best of 13 touchdowns in 2014.

But, in terms of bigger pass plays, Brown is well behind what everyone is accustomed to seeing from the All-Pro receiver.

He has only seven catches of at least 20 yards after eight games, including just three of 40 yards or longer. That is well off his pace of averaging 25 catches of 20-plus yards over the previous three seasons. And it is behind his pace of eight catches of 40-plus yards in 2015, when he led the league, and seven in 2017, when he was second.

Advertise with us

What’s more, his av­er­age on 51 catches is 11.6 yards, which is third-low­est among wide re­ceiv­ers with at least 500 yards and would be his low­est since his rookie sea­son.

None of this is to sug­gest some­thing is wrong with Brown, who has six touch­down catches in his past four games. Even his short­est touch­down catch — a 6-yarder Sun­day in Bal­ti­more — in­cluded an in­cred­i­ble quick-step move that had Ravens cor­ner­back Tavon Young fly­ing through the air like Wile E. Coy­ote on a whiffed tackle at­tempt.

Rather, it’s just a shin­ing ex­am­ple of how big plays — splash plays, Mike Tom­lin calls them — are on the decline, even though the league throws more passes for more yards than ever be­fore.

“I think most de­fenses are try­ing to keep a lid on it or keep a cap on and make you throw it short, get the ball out of your hand,” said Steel­ers of­fen­sive co­or­di­na­tor Randy Ficht­ner. “They re­al­ize that maybe they can’t al­ways get to you in pro­tec­tion, so they’d rather just play the cov­er­age and um­brella it and make you throw short.”

Head­ing into Thurs­day night’s prime-time game be­tween the Steel­ers (5-2-1) and Car­o­lina Pan­thers (6-2), the num­ber of pass plays of at least 40 yards is down for the third year in a row. Not sur­pris­ingly, the num­ber of running plays of at least 40 yards is even on a sharper de­cline.

Advertise with us

Consider:

After nine weeks, there have been 165 com­ple­tions of at least 40 yards, which would proj­ect to 293 for a 16-game sea­son. While that is slightly more than last sea­son (273) and sim­i­lar to 2016 (294), it is well be­low the 338 com­ple­tions of at least 40 yards in 2015.

Ben Roeth­lis­berger has eight com­ple­tions of 40-plus yards, tied for fifth in the league, while his Thurs­day night coun­ter­part, Cam New­ton, has just one, tied for few­est in the league.

There have been 26 runs of at least 40 yards this sea­son, well be­hind the pace of last sea­son, when there were 63. But even that num­ber was the low­est since 2011, when there were 70 runs of 40-plus yards.

Un­like the pass­ing stats, the Pan­thers have the most runs of 40-plus yards in the league (5); the Steel­ers have none.

Advertise with us

How­ever, even though the num­ber of com­ple­tions of at least 40 yards is de­clin­ing, the num­ber of pass plays of 50 yards or lon­ger has in­creased. Ac­cord­ing to the Elias Sports Bureau, there have been 85 com­ple­tions of 50-plus yards af­ter nine weeks, more than at a sim­i­lar point in 2017 (73) and 2016 (78).

De­signed to bend

What has hap­pened to all the big plays?

While scor­ing and pass­ing are way up in the NFL — the cur­rent team av­er­age of 24 points and 250.9 yards pass­ing would be the high­est in his­tory — the man­ner in which teams are scor­ing those points has been al­tered. The chunk plays — an­other word for splash plays — ha­ven’t dis­ap­peared. There are just fewer of them.

“It’s teams play­ing that kind of deep cov­er­age type of thing,” Roeth­lis­berger said. “The bend, don’t break, kind of de­fenses, what­ever you want to call it.”

Advertise with us

The tech­ni­cal ex­pla­na­tion for such de­fenses is the cover-2 and cover-3 schemes that are pop­ping up more frequently around the NFL in an at­tempt to pre­vent the big play. The Steel­ers saw a lot of those cov­er­ages Sunday against the Ravens, who were one of just two teams that hadn’t al­lowed a 40-plus com­ple­tion un­til tight end Jesse James had a wide-open 51-yard re­cep­tion to set up the fi­nal field goal.

And they will likely see more of that against the Pan­thers, who played zone cover schemes 72.5 per­cent of the time in 2017, more than any other team, ac­cord­ing to Pro Foot­ball Fo­cus. The Steel­ers were sec­ond (70.1).

“You do see teams try­ing to com­bat that,” Car­o­lina coach Ron Riv­era said. “You talk about great play­ers, look at the Steel­ers. An­tonio Brown is as scary as it gets, and you throw in JuJu [Smith-Schus­ter], now you say, man, these guys can get ver­ti­cal.”

Against the Ravens, the Steel­ers were so con­cerned about stop­ping Joe Flacco, who threw for 363 yards in the first meet­ing at Heinz Field, that they were in their nickel and dime de­fenses for 53 of the 61 plays, a whop­ping 87 per­cent of the time.

“You are def­i­nitely see­ing more pack­ages with more than four de­fen­sive backs on the field,” Steel­ers coach Mike Tom­lin said. “[Sub-pack­age] is base in to­day’s NFL.”

Advertise with us

•

“I’ve al­ways felt that three things can hap­pen when­ever you throw the foot­ball, and two of them are bad. You can catch the ball, you can throw it in­com­plete, or have it in­ter­cepted.”

— Former Univer­sity of Texas coach Dar­rell Royal

•

Change in think­ing

Advertise with us

In to­day’s NFL, that phi­los­o­phy has changed.

Now, teams be­lieve if you throw the foot­ball, es­pe­cially deep, three things can hap­pen and two of them are good.

With all apol­o­gies to Dar­rell Royal, you can catch the ball, you can throw it in­com­plete or you can get a pass inter­fer­ence pen­alty.

“If I’m an of­fen­sive co­or­di­na­tor, I’m do­ing about four go-balls a game, six if I can,” said wide re­ceiver Dar­rius Hey­ward-Bey, whose speed as the fast­est timed player at the 2009 scout­ing com­bine made him the consummate deep threat. “I’m go­ing to ei­ther catch it or it’s go­ing to be a pass in­ter­fer­ence or in­com­plete. I’m cool with that. The per­cent­ages are on my side. I think of­fen­sive co­or­di­na­tors are get­ting away from that. I’d call it more.”

Part of the rea­son is be­cause more and more teams are play­ing cover-2 or cover-3 de­fenses in the deep half of the field, a lot of time with man cov­er­age un­der­neath. That, though, never stopped play-call­ers such as Bruce Ari­ans, who al­ways liked the per­cent­ages of draw­ing an in­ter­fer­ence pen­alty on a deep pass. Or Al Saun­ders, a se­nior of­fen­sive as­sis­tant with the Cleve­land Browns who was Hey­ward-Bey’s of­fen­sive co­or­di­na­tor when he was with the Oak­land Raid­ers.

Advertise with us

“I think a lot of teams, if you have a good pass­ing game and a No. 1 re­ceiver like we do, you’re go­ing to see a lot more two-up-top, man-un­der­neath,” Hey­ward-Bey said. “That makes it tough for a top guy. He’s dou­ble covered with­out it look­ing like he’s get­ting cov­ered. That’s what teams started to do to us four years ago. Cincinnati showed it and ev­ery­body cop­ied.”

Despite the in­crease in pass­ing at­tempts and yards, the num­ber of de­fen­sive pass in­ter­fer­ence pen­al­ties has de­clined the past cou­ple years.

There have been 124 pass in­ter­fer­ence pen­al­ties en­forced this sea­son, which would proj­ect to 220 over a 16-game sched­ule. That would be the few­est since 2014 (206) and the sec­ond few­est since 2011 (207).

Last sea­son, 266 pass in­ter­fer­ence pen­al­ties were en­forced. In 2016, the num­ber was 280. Pass in­ter­fer­ence has been the third-most en­forced pen­alty ev­ery year ex­cept one (2014) since 2011, be­hind false starts and of­fen­sive hold­ing. What­ever the rea­son, teams are find­ing it more dif­fi­cult to make the truly big splash plays, whether run­ning or throw­ing.

Since he com­pleted a 71-yard pass to John Brown in a 26-14 vic­tory at Heinz Field in Sep­tem­ber, Flacco has com­pleted just one pass lon­ger than 30 yards in the past five games — a 56-yarder to Brown against the New Or­le­ans Saints.

Advertise with us

“Teams al­ways want to take away the deep ball,” Ravens coach John Har­baugh said. “Some­times you’re in a quandary be­cause you get too deep back there and there’s a lot of holes be­hind the line­back­ers and the seams and on the side­lines, where quar­ter­backs like Big Ben take ad­van­tage of you. You got to do all that, you got to play good de­fense.”

They are just do­ing more of it.

Gerry Du­lac: gdu­lac@post-ga­zette.com and Twit­ter @ger­rydu­lac.