Ed Bouchette and Gerry Dulac break down Steelers vs. Panthers
Antonio Brown is symptomatic of what’s going on in the NFL.
After eight games, he is on pace for another season of at least 100 catches and 1,000 receiving yards. He also has nine touchdown catches, which leads the league and puts him well on track to eclipse his personal best of 13 touchdowns in 2014.
But, in terms of bigger pass plays, Brown is well behind what everyone is accustomed to seeing from the All-Pro receiver.
He has only seven catches of at least 20 yards after eight games, including just three of 40 yards or longer. That is well off his pace of averaging 25 catches of 20-plus yards over the previous three seasons. And it is behind his pace of eight catches of 40-plus yards in 2015, when he led the league, and seven in 2017, when he was second.
What’s more, his average on 51 catches is 11.6 yards, which is third-lowest among wide receivers with at least 500 yards and would be his lowest since his rookie season.
None of this is to suggest something is wrong with Brown, who has six touchdown catches in his past four games. Even his shortest touchdown catch — a 6-yarder Sunday in Baltimore — included an incredible quick-step move that had Ravens cornerback Tavon Young flying through the air like Wile E. Coyote on a whiffed tackle attempt.
Read More
Rather, it’s just a shining example of how big plays — splash plays, Mike Tomlin calls them — are on the decline, even though the league throws more passes for more yards than ever before.
“I think most defenses are trying to keep a lid on it or keep a cap on and make you throw it short, get the ball out of your hand,” said Steelers offensive coordinator Randy Fichtner. “They realize that maybe they can’t always get to you in protection, so they’d rather just play the coverage and umbrella it and make you throw short.”
Heading into Thursday night’s prime-time game between the Steelers (5-2-1) and Carolina Panthers (6-2), the number of pass plays of at least 40 yards is down for the third year in a row. Not surprisingly, the number of running plays of at least 40 yards is even on a sharper decline.
Consider:
After nine weeks, there have been 165 completions of at least 40 yards, which would project to 293 for a 16-game season. While that is slightly more than last season (273) and similar to 2016 (294), it is well below the 338 completions of at least 40 yards in 2015.
Ben Roethlisberger has eight completions of 40-plus yards, tied for fifth in the league, while his Thursday night counterpart, Cam Newton, has just one, tied for fewest in the league.
There have been 26 runs of at least 40 yards this season, well behind the pace of last season, when there were 63. But even that number was the lowest since 2011, when there were 70 runs of 40-plus yards.
Unlike the passing stats, the Panthers have the most runs of 40-plus yards in the league (5); the Steelers have none.
However, even though the number of completions of at least 40 yards is declining, the number of pass plays of 50 yards or longer has increased. According to the Elias Sports Bureau, there have been 85 completions of 50-plus yards after nine weeks, more than at a similar point in 2017 (73) and 2016 (78).

Designed to bend
What has happened to all the big plays?
While scoring and passing are way up in the NFL — the current team average of 24 points and 250.9 yards passing would be the highest in history — the manner in which teams are scoring those points has been altered. The chunk plays — another word for splash plays — haven’t disappeared. There are just fewer of them.
“It’s teams playing that kind of deep coverage type of thing,” Roethlisberger said. “The bend, don’t break, kind of defenses, whatever you want to call it.”
The technical explanation for such defenses is the cover-2 and cover-3 schemes that are popping up more frequently around the NFL in an attempt to prevent the big play. The Steelers saw a lot of those coverages Sunday against the Ravens, who were one of just two teams that hadn’t allowed a 40-plus completion until tight end Jesse James had a wide-open 51-yard reception to set up the final field goal.
And they will likely see more of that against the Panthers, who played zone cover schemes 72.5 percent of the time in 2017, more than any other team, according to Pro Football Focus. The Steelers were second (70.1).
“You do see teams trying to combat that,” Carolina coach Ron Rivera said. “You talk about great players, look at the Steelers. Antonio Brown is as scary as it gets, and you throw in JuJu [Smith-Schuster], now you say, man, these guys can get vertical.”
Against the Ravens, the Steelers were so concerned about stopping Joe Flacco, who threw for 363 yards in the first meeting at Heinz Field, that they were in their nickel and dime defenses for 53 of the 61 plays, a whopping 87 percent of the time.
“You are definitely seeing more packages with more than four defensive backs on the field,” Steelers coach Mike Tomlin said. “[Sub-package] is base in today’s NFL.”
•
“I’ve always felt that three things can happen whenever you throw the football, and two of them are bad. You can catch the ball, you can throw it incomplete, or have it intercepted.”
— Former University of Texas coach Darrell Royal
•
Change in thinking
In today’s NFL, that philosophy has changed.
Now, teams believe if you throw the football, especially deep, three things can happen and two of them are good.
With all apologies to Darrell Royal, you can catch the ball, you can throw it incomplete or you can get a pass interference penalty.
“If I’m an offensive coordinator, I’m doing about four go-balls a game, six if I can,” said wide receiver Darrius Heyward-Bey, whose speed as the fastest timed player at the 2009 scouting combine made him the consummate deep threat. “I’m going to either catch it or it’s going to be a pass interference or incomplete. I’m cool with that. The percentages are on my side. I think offensive coordinators are getting away from that. I’d call it more.”
Part of the reason is because more and more teams are playing cover-2 or cover-3 defenses in the deep half of the field, a lot of time with man coverage underneath. That, though, never stopped play-callers such as Bruce Arians, who always liked the percentages of drawing an interference penalty on a deep pass. Or Al Saunders, a senior offensive assistant with the Cleveland Browns who was Heyward-Bey’s offensive coordinator when he was with the Oakland Raiders.
“I think a lot of teams, if you have a good passing game and a No. 1 receiver like we do, you’re going to see a lot more two-up-top, man-underneath,” Heyward-Bey said. “That makes it tough for a top guy. He’s double covered without it looking like he’s getting covered. That’s what teams started to do to us four years ago. Cincinnati showed it and everybody copied.”
Despite the increase in passing attempts and yards, the number of defensive pass interference penalties has declined the past couple years.
There have been 124 pass interference penalties enforced this season, which would project to 220 over a 16-game schedule. That would be the fewest since 2014 (206) and the second fewest since 2011 (207).
Last season, 266 pass interference penalties were enforced. In 2016, the number was 280. Pass interference has been the third-most enforced penalty every year except one (2014) since 2011, behind false starts and offensive holding. Whatever the reason, teams are finding it more difficult to make the truly big splash plays, whether running or throwing.
Since he completed a 71-yard pass to John Brown in a 26-14 victory at Heinz Field in September, Flacco has completed just one pass longer than 30 yards in the past five games — a 56-yarder to Brown against the New Orleans Saints.
“Teams always want to take away the deep ball,” Ravens coach John Harbaugh said. “Sometimes you’re in a quandary because you get too deep back there and there’s a lot of holes behind the linebackers and the seams and on the sidelines, where quarterbacks like Big Ben take advantage of you. You got to do all that, you got to play good defense.”
They are just doing more of it.
Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com and Twitter @gerrydulac.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.