Antonio Brown had another one of his immature sideline meltdowns Sunday. Post-Gazette columnist Ron Cook wrote that Brown’s act has grown tired, and that he needs to grow up.
It is true that some people overreact to every single thing Brown does, even though most of it is harmless. There are others, though, who staunchly defend him and shout down anyone who criticizes him. That makes Brown perhaps the most polarizing athlete in Pittsburgh right now, and that’s a shame because he is such a talented player.
Brown has been the Steelers’ best player the last few years. He is the best receiver in football. He has carried the Steelers to wins in games the other players seemed determined to lose. He has made incredible catches, had incredible games and does a lot of things that very few players can do.
That being said, it is laughable that anyone believes the Steelers would collapse and turn into some 2-14 disaster without him.
Every player, every coach, every general manager is replaceable. Teams trade away or don’t sign players every single year in every single sport, and they survive. Brown is great, but the Steelers have moved on from Hall of Famers — who, unlike him, have actually won Super Bowls.
I’m not yet in the “trade Brown” camp, but he continues to make it harder to justify keeping him around. His actions Monday seem to suggest that maybe he doesn’t want to be around, either.
Read More
The day after an embarrassing loss, Brown apparently had nothing better to do than get into a Twitter beef with former Steelers media relations staffer Ryan Scarpino. Scarpino tweeted “AB needs to thank his lucky stars, because he was drafted by a team that had [Ben Roethlisberger]. And Ben got AB paid. You know darn well he wouldn’t put up those numbers for other teams.”
Brown’s reply was classic: “Trade me, let’s find out...”
First off, it’s ridiculous that a world-class wide receiver is insecure enough to get into a Twitter beef with a person who is, essentially, a fan. Why does he care what Scarpino (or anyone else) thinks? He has money, he has fame, he has God-given talent, and he is a wildly popular player. Brown should be embarrassed.
Secondly, is Brown, who was seen yelling at offensive coordinator Randy Fichtner on the sidelines and had some sort of exchange with Roethlisberger, suggesting he is unhappy here, or unhappy with his situation? Why go that route publicly if there wasn’t more to the message?
I suppose we should be happy that Brown has progressed from last week’s Twitter activity, when he threatened to break a reporter’s jaw. but this one may be more troublesome; it suggests the Steelers might have a real problem on their hands.
If that’s the case, the Steelers, specifically Mike Tomlin, need to get Brown under control. This is the kind of nonsense that divides a locker room, and Brown always seems to be at the center of it.

Tomlin has often gone to the cop-out line of “what am I supposed to do, sit him?” I’ll answer that question, even if it is rhetorical. Yes, bench him for a game and make it clear this kind of nonsense won’t be tolerated. The Steelers haven’t won a game with Brown this year. They can certainly fail without him.
There are some who think Brown’s talent should trump his shenanigans, but the Steelers need to be beyond that point. If Brown still doesn’t get it, the Steelers should pursue the idea of trading him. It may become a situation of addition by subtraction, as in, the Steelers will become a better TEAM by shedding a selfish player.
The Steelers will lose Le’Veon Bell to free agency, so it would be tough for them to get rid of Brown. That would be a lot of talent sent out in one offseason, and if that happened they might fall back to the middle of the pack or worse. However, the Steelers’ expectation is — or at least used to be — winning Super Bowls. Bell and Brown are all-world talents, but the Steelers haven’t sniffed a ring with either. They can fail without them while dealing with half as many headaches.
Brown’s talent is not questioned. His work ethic is not questioned. His commitment to trying to win a title, though, can be questioned, given how much time and energy he seems to spend focused elsewhere. And thanks to his latest Twitter beef, his commitment to the Steelers can be called into question, too.
It wouldn’t be easy to replace Brown’s production, but there are lots of productive wide receivers out there, and Steelers still have one of the best quarterbacks in the league. It isn’t yet time for them to move on, but that time is approaching, slowly but surely.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com, Twitter: @PaulZeise





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.