I have long been a card-carrying member of The Mike Tomlin Apologist Society. It’s true.

Whenever people want him fired, I laugh and respond with inconvenient facts such as his career winning percentage (.656), or, say, his 20-3-1 record in the previous 24 regular-season games as of Sunday morning.

But my membership has never meant putting Tomlin above criticism — and as we sit here now, a long ways from Sunday morning, in the wake of a disastrous performance against the Kansas City Chiefs, he is more deserving of criticism than at any time in his 12-year tenure.

This team stinks.

Advertise with us

It’s not just that the Steelers are 0-1-1 after their 42-37 loss to the Kansas City Chiefs. Or that they tied the ridiculous Cleveland Browns in Week 1. Or that they have committed 23 (accepted) penalties and countless mental errors in those two games (I think Bud Dupree just jumped offside again).

It’s more than that.

It’s the fact that the following statement is frighteningly accurate in describing their past two home games, including the playoff debacle against Jacksonville …

That was one of the worst defensive performances in franchise history.

The Steelers have allowed 87 points in those two games (OK, only 80 by the defense). They have been virtually helpless, and they are staining the rich legacy of their ancestors, who built this franchise’s good name on stifling offenses across the NFL.

Advertise with us

If defensive coordinator Keith Butler’s job wasn’t in jeopardy after the playoff meltdown, it should be now.

On the other hand, Tomlin himself has taken a larger role in the defense since Dick LeBeau was jettisoned, and look what’s happening: Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes, in his third NFL start, nearly threw a perfect game on his way to six touchdown passes. And it could have been worse.

Tomlin, Roethlisberger discuss loss to Chiefs

It probably should have been worse. Early in the fourth quarter, Mahomes dropped into his end zone, completely unafraid of a meek Steelers pass rush, and spotted Tyreek Hill separating from Cam Sutton on a go route.

“If I hit him in stride,” Mahomes said, “that’s a 99-yarder.”

Yes, it is. And from there, the only question would have been whether the Chiefs could tack on one more touchdown to reach 56 points, a total no team has ever reached against the Steelers.

Advertise with us

My God, what’s happening here?

I realize the NFL has become a never-ending points festival, and I don’t absolve the offense for putting the team in an early hole Sunday, just like against Jacksonville. Sometimes you have to outscore people, and as guard Ramon Foster said, “We didn’t do enough early.”

Nor do I absolve the special teams, which are borderline tragic at the moment. Coach Danny Smith routinely pulls players (Matthew Thomas, Stevan Ridley) off the field after miscues, kicker Chris Boswell continues to slump and punter Jordan Berry misfires more than Ernesto Frieri.

But most of the richly deserved boos were reserved for the defense, which stood out in the worst kinds of ways. I have no idea what Tomlin was thinking when he eschewed an onside kick with 1:59 left, trailing by five (I mean, other than the fact that Boswell can’t execute one).

This is a coach who once justifiably had his team attempt an onside kick while leading the Green Bay Packers, reasoning his defense could not stop Aaron Rodgers.

Advertise with us

So how could he justify putting this sorry outfit out there down five, even with three timeouts?

“I wanted to give ourselves a chance to stop them,” Tomlin said.

Nice thought, but the Chiefs lined up and punched the Steelers in the face, using consecutive runs up the middle to earn a first down.

Artie Burns has regressed. The heavily relied-upon outside linebackers got nothing done Sunday. Kareem Hunt trucked rookie safety Terrell Edmunds on his way to a 5-yard touchdown. New linebacker Jon Bostic, like everyone else, looked terrible against tight end Travis Kelce. The idea that new secondary coach Tom Bradley was going to improve the tackling back there seems delusional.

I’m not sure the return of cornerback Joe Haden fixes this mess, but it can’t hurt. Up next is red-hot Ryan Fitzpatrick (819 yards, eight touchdowns) and the 2-0 Tampa Bay Buccaneers.

Advertise with us

One week, the Steelers nearly lose when they’re whistled for 12 men on the field. The next, they fail to line up properly for a fourth-quarter free kick, costing themselves 17 yards. All this junk starts with the head coach.

“It’s just Game 2,” Foster said.

True. But is that the good news or the bad news?

Joe Starkey: jstarkey@post-gazette.com and Twitter @joestarkey1.