Pat Mahomes talked glowingly about the number of weapons the Chiefs have on offense after he torched the Steelers for six touchdowns in a 42-37 win at Heinz Field Sunday. He said that takes the pressure off of him and makes the Chiefs extremely hard to defend.

“They can't stop everybody,” Mahomes said.

Actually, I’d disagree with Mahomes, at least with respect to the Steelers’ defense.

They can't stop anybody. And it has been like that pretty much every game since Ryan Shazier went down last season. It actually hasn’t been consistently very good in a long, long time. The defense cost them the playoff game against Jacksonville last season. The defensive backfield has gotten worse, not better. The young linebackers don't seem to be progressing like first-round picks should.

Advertise with us

And yet it was the offensive coordinator that lost his job after last season.

Think about how silly that is. The Steelers’ offense and Ben Roethlisberger were never better than when Todd Haley was calling plays, yet he got fired and sentenced to a stay in Cleveland. Defensive coordinator Keith Butler, on the other hand, and linebackers coach Joey Porter are still on the staff, and that is ridiculous.

Tomlin, Roethlisberger discuss loss to Chiefs

Here is the thing, though: the spin last season as to why Butler deserved to keep his job was that Mike Tomlin took over the defense and was calling virtually all of the plays. Tomlin, a defensive coordinator in a different life, was the one responsible for the meltdown against Jacksonville, and therefore Butler should be blameless in this mess. The rationale for keeping Porter around is ... well, I have no idea. The linebackers under his direction have not gotten better despite the fact that he has been handed first-round pick after first-round pick.

If all of that about Tomlin taking over the defense is true, then I have two legitimate questions that someone in the Steelers’ front office needs to answer:

1) Why the heck is Butler still around? If he isn’t competent enough to call his own plays, why is he still the defensive coordinator? And if he is competent enough to call his own plays, given how bad the defense has been, why is he still the defensive coordinator?

Advertise with us

2) If Tomlin is indeed running the defense, is he on the hot seat? If he isn’t, he should be.

Tomlin has had a great run here. He has never had a losing season. He has won a Super Bowl and coached his way to another. He has won a ton of games. His record speaks for itself, but then again, lately, that's not necessarily a good thing. His apologists will point to his recent regular seasons, but this team is more talented than most and thus winning regular season games shouldn’t be the measure.

The fact is Tomlin has won only three playoff games since 2010 despite having a Hall of Fame quarterback playing the best football of his career for most of those years. And his three playoff wins are not exactly something to brag about, either: one against the Bengals gift wrapped by Marvin Lewis, Pac Man Jones and Vontaze Burfict; one against a bad Dolphins team with their backup quarterback; and one against Andy Reid, Alex Smith and the perennial playoff-underachiever Chiefs.

Tomlin has won a Super Bowl, so he has had some capital and a longer leash than most, but at what point does he have to do more? At what point will Tomlin have to take this group of Steelers to the next level before he is replaced? And anyone who says a Super Bowl trophy ensures a lifetime contract, ask Jon Gruden, Brian Billick and Tom Coughlin how that worked out for them.

The biggest problem with Tomlin in recent years is this — the Steelers have become a sloppy, undisciplined mess of a football team. Sunday's game was more of the same. More of the same dumb penalties and more of the same comedy of special-teams errors. We also had more of the same selfish, nonsense from Antonio Brown on the sidelines, and at some point that needs to be dealt with in a severe way. The defense couldn’t even get lined up right and looked confused. We saw players arguing coming off the field on multiple plays.

Advertise with us

The other argument for not putting Tomlin and Butler on the hot seat has been “well, they don't have good enough players.” That is a bad argument, too. Tomlin has a huge hand in the draft, and he presumably signs off on the players that get selected. If they aren’t good enough, to paraphrase Bill Parcells, the people doing the shopping need to change.

This team plays selfish, stupid football far too often and they can get away with it and win games because they have special talent on offense and most other teams don’t. They can’t get away with it in the playoffs, though, and that's why this season is destined to be another failure if Tomlin doesn’t get some things changed immediately.

It is only two games, and there is a lot of season left, but the more things supposedly change with the Steelers under Tomlin, the more they stay the same. I’m not saying he should be fired, but his seat should start to become extremely warm. He shouldn’t keep getting a pass because he once won a Super Bowl. He needs to do better in the playoffs this season, and frankly nothing we’ve seen this season suggests they are capable of playing enough good games and good teams in a row to get to the Super Bowl.

The Steelers are good at making headlines for all the wrong reasons. They are good at talking a lot of trash. They are good at making excuses. And they are good at blaming everyone else for their struggles. That all speaks to a coach who is losing his locker room, and maybe one whose message is stale.

Tomlin has time to fix this mess — but he is certainly running out of it.

Paul Zeise: pzeist@post-gazette.com, Twitter: @PaulZeise