National anthem protests before NFL games have bitterly divided pro football fans over the past couple of years.

Some find the protests disrespectful of the American flag and military service. Others feel they’re a brave and profound way to peacefully call attention to racial inequality in our country.

Now, the NFL is reportedly weighing a proposed solution that seems more likely to offend both of those groups simultaneously.

If you’re part of the anti-protest crowd, get ready to see the anthem turned into a trivial game instead. Rather than direct eyes to the flag and thoughts to the troops, the proposal would have fans scanning the field for kneelers and weighing the strategy behind a home team’s decision to take the field or not.

Advertise with us

If you support the protests, not only would the proposal literally penalize the cause, it would further diminish it by framing the act of kneeling with its consequence instead of the intended message.

Add it up and you have a “solution” that’s tone-deaf all the way around and probably won’t resolve the controversy either.

Sure, we may see fewer players kneeling for fear of hurting their teams, but we may also see more teams choose to stay in the locker room until after the anthem is played. The Steelers caught hell for making that decision last year in Chicago, as many fans interpreted it as a team-wide protest. So a similar pattern league-wide would leave the NFL right back where it started.

In the end, the NFL’s problem isn’t protests, nor the president whose attacks on them last season caused them to proliferate around the league.

Rather, the league’s lack of principles is what brought it to this moment. It stands for little beyond making money for its owners. It has no moral compass guiding its decisions. And now that it’s faced with a situation where it can’t please everyone, its lack of direction may lead it to end up pleasing no one.

Advertise with us

Good luck with that.

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.