Alberto Riveron, the senior vice president of officiating for the NFL, didn’t make the any friends in Pittsburgh after he ruled the Jesse James “catch” against the Patriots an incomplete pass. His decision directly affected the seeding for the AFC playoffs, giving the Patriots the No. 1 seed and home-field advantage throughout the playoffs and the Steelers the No. 2 seed.

Then Tuesday, Riveron revealed to ESPN that two Eagles touchdowns in the Super Bowl that were reviewed by him were ruled “differently” than the regular season. The Eagles beat the Patriots, 41-33.

The standard for changing the rulebook has always been voting on new proposals during the offseason. The NFL competition committee this week did successfully change the catch rule, but that news was overshadowed by the fact that the league actually changed the rule in the playoffs and told no one about it, at least not the fans. It’s unclear if they informed the teams.

The Steelers stated publicly at the time that the James play was ruled right by the letter of the law, but there were some in the organization that believed Riveron was micromanaging the catch rule. Other plays that were similar to the James play were ruled catches, including one by Brandin Cooks of the Patriots that was ruled a touchdown in the final minute of a game against the Texans earlier in the season.

Advertise with us

The Patriots and Steelers finished with the same record, but the Patriots benefited twice from inconsistencies by Riveron in game-swinging plays in the final minute of games.

The Steelers have moved on. They’ll never know if they would have won a seventh Lombardi trophy had they had home-field advantage throughout the playoffs, but having to play Jacksonville rather than Tennessee in their first playoff game emphasized just how important the seeding ended up being.

In a strange twist of fate, Riveron’s postseason change of course ultimately denied the Patriots a sixth Super Bowl title and tilted the game in favor of a team from Pennsylvania.

Just the wrong side of the state if you ask Steelers fans.