Ray Fittipaldo: Let's get started.

Mike: Do you think the Steelers coaching staff will look at the Eagles game? Tomlin should learn from the play calling of the Eagles. They played to win!

Ray Fittipaldo: When you are up on the Patriots you have to step on their throat. The Eagles stayed aggressive all game. Kudos to Pederson for the game he called. As for the Steelers learning from this? We'll see. They had a chance to go for it on fourth and 1 against the Patriots and not give the ball back to Brady in that game in December. They played it conservative and ended up losing. That's not always the wrong call and playing it aggressive isn't always the right call, but the lesson is you have to score gobs of points to beat Brady and the Pats. Pederson understood that and that's why he's a Super Bowl champion.

DaquidoBazzini: Greetings Ray....Do you think it’s too late for any defensive coaching changes to be made? How do you think they justify this?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I think they would have already announced those changes. If changes come now I think it's a sign that ownership mandated. But I don't get that sense right now. Art Rooney II is expected to meet with local reporters this week so we might get his insight into the defense and its struggles.

Zach B.: Hi Ray - After watching that Super Bowl last night and seeing just how bad the Patriots defense was it only infuriated me more to think of Mike Tomlin’s incompetence as a head coach! This was our year to win #7, no doubt! I fear we will pay too much for Bell and the wheels will fall off as the signs were there this year already and Tomlin will continue to be more involved in the defense which is never good! I fear Tomlin fired Haley as a scapegoat and gave Ben a buddy as OC who has zero experience in the NFL and who’s playcalling certainly didn’t “light it up” in the pro bowl will see a regression in the offense next year, I fear we have past our window for #7 with Tomlin screwing everything up, your thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: Did you just reference Randy Fichtner's play-calling in the Pro Bowl as a bad sign of things to come? God Bless you. You just made this one of the greatest questions in Steelers chat history!

Jesse: Ray, thinking the Steelers need to let LB walk. Use the money to shore up depth at ILB, S and RB. Then draft ILB, S, TE, RB. A lot of wear and tear on those tires. Thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: The more I think about it the more I am on your side. Look at the RBs in the Super Bowl last night -- Blount, Clement, Ajayi, White, Lewis, Burkhead. None of them were high draft picks or highly paid players. The Eagles won that game because of Nick Foles and Doug Pederson calling a great game. The Eagles running game was great, but they got a lot of big passing plays that helped them win that game. Same goes for the Patriots. They've been built around the passing game for years. The NFL is a passing league. Does it help if you have a strong running game? Of course. But you had better have a QB that can execute at a high level. So yes, I'd be tempted to let Bell hit free agency and use the money elsewhere.

Advertise with us

Zach B.: Hi Ray - Why is the fact that Steelers Legends such as Terry Bradshaw, Jerome Bettis and Hines Ward have all come out critiqued Tomlin as basically being a bad coach gone unreported in the local papers. Hell, even the fact that John stallworth who was a part of the minority ownership group that wrote a letter demanding Tomlin be fired was not really reported on other then Bouchette’s snarky, self absorbed normal response that these people should be told to mind their own business by Little Art. The vast majority of Steelers Fans who actually “Pay” to see them play want Tomlin gone, why is this not being reported locally.

Ray Fittipaldo: How do you know John Stallworth was the minority owner that went to Pro Football Talk? I haven't seen that reported anywhere. Also, if you read my chats I've been very critical of Tomlin. I think he deserves to be called out for a lot of things that took place this season. What do you want reported? We all have opinions and express them in different ways at post-gazette.com and in print.

Mongo: would you rather have Jim Schwartz as the HC of the Steelers than Mike Tomlin?

Ray Fittipaldo: No.

Deebo: when the Steelers keep Coordinators from inside the team..i.e Butler and Fichtner isn't that being narrow minded by continuing to promote in a failed environment?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: In the case of Randy Fichtner, it makes a lot of sense. Ben is going to be 36 next month. He had zero interest in starting over with a new coordinator again. As for the defense, I agree that they can use some new ideas and some positions on that side of the ball can be better coached, but I'm not exactly sure Butler should shoulder all of the blame there. Does he deserve blame for the failures? Yes. Absolutely. But there's a lot that goes into it. First and foremost, they need to line up their personnel against the other team's personnel and try to win that way for once. I find Butler at fault the most for his inability to get his unit to line up properly and to communicate with each other. Either the defense is too complicated or the players aren't smart enough to execute what they're doing. Figure it out and make the appropriate changes.

JJ: I didn't watch the game. Was the winning td catch no different than Jesse James td catch the refs took away?

Ray Fittipaldo: Ertz took three steps and dived for the goal line. James caught it, turned, lunged, extended the ball, etc. It's all about judgment and determining when the player becomes a runner. It's a dumb rule. They're going to try to fix it, but I don't have any real confidence the competition committee or the NFL will figure it out.

TXSteeler: Doubt you’ll answer this but you said one of Pitts problems vs NE was 3rd down efficiency when compared to Phili. Funny since they were successful and the exact same on offense (10 of 16) and Pitt was much beter on defense (3-9). Want to try again?

Ray Fittipaldo: How about in the second half? They were poor on third downs when it counted most. They couldn't extend drives when they needed it the most.

Advertise with us

Stash from Blawnox: doesn't this post season prove how far the Steelers are behind the rest of the league coaching wise..Marrone..Belicheck..Pederson seem like they play chess and Tomlin plays checkers

Ray Fittipaldo: I wouldn't go that far, but they all proved to be better coaches in this year's playoffs. Doesn't mean it will be true next season. Also, the Falcons were close to winning in Philly in the division round. They had a fourth-and-goal late in that game and failed to convert. The difference between winning a Super Bowl and not even getting close in this league is small.

jim: MY QUESTION IS WHAT WAS THE DIFFERENCE IN THE CATCH JESSE JAMES MADE AGAINST NEW ENGLAND WHICH WAS RULED NO CATCH ,BUT LAST NIGHTS CATCH WAS A TOUCHDOWN?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't have the answer to that question. Some have pointed out Ertz took three steps while James did not. However, I'll point out taking steps doesn't necessarily have to constitute possession. The rulebook has been rewritten over the years to make the rule better, but they haven't accomplished that.

Mark: Regarding Shazier, we know the medical updates are limited for privacy reasons and acknowledging that his overall health is a concern far above the game -- for those of you around the team what's the general consensus on the likelihood that he'll ever play for the team again?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't really get the sense that anyone is expecting Shazier to return to football. I think they all want him to be able to walk and to have a normal life. That's the most important thing. Football is secondary to all of that.

Chris : How do you think the Steelers handle Mike Mitchell’s situation?

Ray Fittipaldo: Guess it depends on their confidence in replacing him in free agency or the draft. I know one thing. He isn't worth $5 million. He just hasn't played well enough to warrant that type of money. Another situation where the money is spent better elsewhere on the roster.

Kyle: I've seen in the chats about Navarro Bowman being the top ILB and the issues with him. Do you know about any of the top free agent safeties? Really wish the steelers would have picked up Weedle over Green when they had the chance!

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes I mentioned that in last week's chat. He's a Pro Bowl safety and Green is out of football. I'll have to check the list of free agent safeties. It's all about fit. The Steelers need to get the best safety prospect and use him accordingly. They have to be willing to move Sean Davis to free if there is a better strong safety prospect available in free agency or the draft. And they're capable of doing that. The safety positions in this defense re basically interchangeable.

Advertise with us

John in Florida: Based on his tweets, Bell seems anxious to sign a new deal. I suspect one big reason is that, if he hits free agency, Bell’s value probably drops back to the top of current RB value, $8-$10 million a year. If Steelers cannot sign him for that money, highly unlikely, I think it’s time to move on. That money could help upgrade at safety and TE, then go for ILB and RB in the draft. What are your thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: Bell's not signing anywhere for $8-10 million a year. Believe me, there is a team out there who will pay him $15 million a year, or close to it. Lots of teams have cap space to do it.

JC: Ray, If the TE from South Dakota is available in the 2nd rd would you take him providing McDonald does not sign? Thank you.

Ray Fittipaldo: McDonald doesn't have to sign. The Steelers just have to decide if they want to keep him. And I think they will as long as they feel like his injury history is troublesome. They used him a lot when he was healthy. But that doesn't preclude the Steelers from drafting a TE if they like him. offensive coordinators can be creative with pass-catching TEs.

Dave Cos: Which position would be easier for a rookie to make an immediate impact next year- ILB or safety? Any way that could influence what the Steelers might do on round 1?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Tough to say. I think rookies can start at either spot. The thing is, you can't count on a rookie to come in and replace Shazier as the QB of the defense when it comes to communication. That has to be someone else next season. Maybe it's a DB who will be on the field at all times.

Dave Cos: Why do so many defensive players come into the NFL as poor tacklers? Are college practice rules also prohibitive to teaching proper techniques or is it just poor coaching at the college level?

Ray Fittipaldo: Just a sign of the times. Tackling periods are dwindling at every level of football as the coaches try to figure out a way to teach safe techniques while limiting head injuries. It's difficult. There are no easy answers.

Dude from cali: So many broken coverage resulting in Splash plays yesterday. I guess mistakes aren't exclusive to Steelers then, thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: I was thinking the same thing last night. I just think Patriots are really good at scheming and get players wide open while Brady is underrated in his ability to buy time in the pocket. As for the Patriots defense, they have personnel issues almost everywhere on that unit. Give credit to the Eagles coaches for exploiting their deficiencies in both scheme and personnel. Pederson out-coached Belichick last night.

Advertise with us

Dude from cali: Early on in the game, Philly played Smash Mouth football pummeling Patriots. That's what Steelers are sorely missing in personnel and or identity, thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: I think the Steelers can play smash-mouth if they want. I just don't think it suits Bell's running style. He has that hesitating style that has worked for him and to an extent the Steelers. Just not sure if it's always the best thing for the offense. The Eagles didn't have any negative running plays. Bell is always good for one or two or three a game. Not all his fault. Sometimes the OL is at fault. But I honestly don't think the issue is personnel on the offensive line. I think it's in the style of the running back who is getting most of the carries. And the Eagles do it without a fullback. They ran mostly out of 11 personnel. They ran well out of shotgun. You don't need a FB to have an effective running game. You just need to block well up front, and the Eagles do that exceedingly well.

Oldschool: During last night’s SB game, two very good defenses gave up a big yardage, big plays, and big points. This offseason I know the Steelers will try to improve in all areas of the game, but are they better off putting a larger portion of available resources (money & draft pics) in the offense in hopes of just being able to outscore anyone? It pains me to ask that question as I love defensive football teams.

Ray Fittipaldo: I get where you are coming from, but had Jacksonville closed the deal in the AFC title game we might be talking about how the Jaguars defense won the Super Bowl because it shut down Nick Foles. You need both. You can't count on scoring 41 points to win a Super Bowl game. The Eagles know that. The Patriots know it, too. They're just so much better on offense than almost every other team. That's the way you have to play to beat them. You have to be aggressive and take chances. Otherwise, Brady will find a way to beat you in the end.

Bob Price: How perfect was the Ertz TD at the end, Ray. Was it a case of the universe getting what it got wrong with Jesse James, right?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Steelers fans would argue the universe will be right when the Steelers hoist another Lombardi trophy on a similar play.

D. Fence: Ray, there are a lot of quality free agent safeties available. LaMarcus Joyner, who only made 1.2 million this year comes to mind - granted he will make a lot more in free agency. Eric Reed 26 SF, Kenny Vaccaro 26 NO are a few others. Isn’t it time to part ways with Mitchell and his 5.3 million that they can give to upgrade the position?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, but you have to know which of those players, or one in the draft, will be the right fit for your defense.

Joe in Greensburg: 1. Haley was brought in and told to reduce the number of hits on Ben and to get the ball out quicker and help him to miss less games. he did this. Ben was more productive, took less hits and played in more games. I disliked some of the play calling but why was Haley fired when he did what he was asked to do? They did score over 40 in the playoff loss.

Ray Fittipaldo: You are discounting how relationships with players and coaches factored into the decision. Sometimes, it's about more than stats.

Advertise with us

MaryI: Why on earth did coach refuse to play Harrison more?

Ray Fittipaldo: Harrison missed some tackles and a sack last night, but he did collapse the pocket a number of times. He could have done that for the Steelers. He just couldn't drop into coverage with much effectiveness. I'm not saying the Steelers were right, but that's how they used their OLBs this year. They weren't rushing every single play.

Tom88: Do you think the refs taking away Jesse James TD had anything to do with the refs allowing Philly's?

Ray Fittipaldo: Who knows? There's not a lot of transparency with the NFL office when it comes to these things. Seems like they make it up as they go along.

Unsullied Earholes: Yet again STs played a huge roll yet leading up to big games they rarely get talked about. NE's long snapper is ranked dead last before yesterday... just sayin'

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I really need to know where you find these long snapper rankings!

Ike Steelheart: How do you think Randy F. will call plays, like Arians or like Haley?

Ray Fittipaldo: Probably like Randy Fichtner. Not being smart, just the reality. He's his own man and he'll put his own stamp on the offense.

OKC Dave: Do you think the play calling will get better now? Running wide on one of the fastest defenses in the league was ridiculous on 4th and 1. Bells "patience" works well on undisciplined plodding teams, but fast, better tackling teams can eat him up.

Ray Fittipaldo: Play-calling can only do so much. Are the coaches really going to tell Le'Veon Bell how to run? They have to decide it his other skills are worth it. But there is no doubt in my mind his running skills are replaceable. Not so sure his skills as a receiver can be replaced. And they know that.

Advertise with us

Unsullied Earholes: Belicheat benching/relegating Butler to STs at game time and his replacement not informed till then too... The genius has a crack in his manifesto? Butler is a free agent, how can other teams find out the truth of the why(s)?

Ray Fittipaldo: I agree. The genius outsmarted himself with that decision. He thinks he can win with any player off the street. Rowe will never be better than Butler, but Belichick convinced himself he could win without him.

Dr. Jay: Do the Steelers need to place heavier emphasis on 'durability' rather then 'speed' when drafting their inside linebackers? The last two IML both have had major injuries Spence/Shazier .

Ray Fittipaldo: Injuries are part of the game, but I'm not sure you can forecast which players will be injury-prone in the NFL. I think they try to do that, but it's hard to predict.

James in NE: So I suppose some business decisions don’t work out in the end, is this the end of the road for 92

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Apparently, he told reporters in Boston that he'd like to continue playing. I think there are teams that might sign him.

NCDAN: Time to let Bell go, he's a cancer on this team. What say you?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't necessarily think he's a cancer, but it might be time to move on because of the dollar he commands.

Heather: I thought Harrison played well last night - looked more disruptive thank Dupree. I think we missed badly on that one. What are your thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: No one on the Patriots defense played well enough. Harrison collapses the pocket much better than Dupree, but Dupree is more athletic and they used him in coverage. The Steelers have a decision to make on Dupree. They can pick up or decline his fifth year option in May.

Advertise with us

Unsullied Earholes: If the Eagles just jam Gronk at the line and shadow him/tackle in bounds on one or two of the plays before the HM... Brady runs out of time and has no shot at the endzone... It worked out but why do coaches clench and go full prevent like that, all the time?

Ray Fittipaldo: Eagles played the percentages and won. The chances of that Hail Mary being caught are like 100-1.

Luckybob: I feel differently than most about the job the defensive staff did this year. I think you judge coaches by how much they get out of the players they have to work with. Do you think that they can let Haley go because he took one of the most talented groups in the league and led them to 8th in scoring while Butler took a younger and comparatively less talented group to 7th in points against?

Ray Fittipaldo: You might have a point, but that doesn't explain the wide open receivers in the playoff game against the Jags. It doesn't explain the communication errors the players admitted were a problem all season. It doesn't explain the mental errors.

Ike Steelheart: Ray, what is your oponion regarding the 2018 Steelers opponents? I really think is one of the hardest schedules of 2018? Don't you?

Ray Fittipaldo: Won't be easy, but injuries play a big part in how these things play out.

Ryno: Was it just me, or were the officials calling the game last night the way officials should have been calling all the games this season? Just seemed like there was a different quality of officiating last night from what we are used to seeing.

Ray Fittipaldo: On the field and in the replay booth. I agree. I just have a hard time defending the lack of consistency when it comes to replay reviews. The standard used during the regular season was different from the postseason. That's not right. Really, the Steelers should have been the No. 1 seed and the Patriots No.2. Maybe the Jaguars beat the Patriots in the division round and the Steelers beat the Titans. Then who knows what happens in the AFC title game against the Jags? You see where I'm coming from. They totally messed with the playoff seeding with that call on James.

Zach B.: Hi Ray - I think we should try and sign one of the top safeties in FA, either Eric Reid, Tre Bost or Vaccaro after cutting Mitchell then draft two stud ILB’s 1-3. In the draft. Shazier cannot be replaced but if you have two young stud ILB with early round pedigree we could be scary on D, what do you think?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not a bad idea. But you never know what you're getting in free agency.

Steeler in Charlotte: Do you think Bryant gets traded before the draft, or is he back on solid footing with the team?

Ray Fittipaldo: He was a better citizen and player in the second half of the season, and he's cheap. He'll be back.

Mike: M. Butler is a free agent, I really do not think he will be back with the Pats. Do you think he could be a replacement for Mitchell?

Ray Fittipaldo: Butler has been a CB, not a safety. Perhaps he'll play safety at some point, even with his next team, but you had better know he'll excel there if you sign him.

Zach B.: My point about Fichtner was the only evidence we have of him as a play caller in the nfl was in the pro bowl and it didn’t look so hot - do you disagree with that asses,ent?

Ray Fittipaldo: It was the Pro Bowl for crying out loud. It's not a football game and you certainly shouldn't draw any conclusions from watching anything that happened.

Quentin B: What are your thoughts about drafting or signing a free agent NG? Hargrove is under-sized and more of a perpetrator at DT. Can we help shore up our ILB play with true a NG who can play base and move to DT in some Big Nickel formations.

Ray Fittipaldo: Competition for Hargrave isn't a bad idea, but I don't invest a high pick in one.

Guest 6Rings: Do you think Ramon Foster is good enough/young enough that he'll be offered an extension this year?

Ray Fittipaldo: He's getting older. Entering the final year of his contract. I'd be surprised if they offer him another contract.

PitMike: Is LBell considered a leader in the Steelers locker room? And if he is, do the Steelers really want a leader who talks about sitting out and retiring and how he was ready to go while others weren't for the JAX game? Seems to me that the Steelers are better off using the money for a free agent or two on D while drafting a capable RB. Improve D, improve leadership by subtraction. Agree?

Ray Fittipaldo: For the most part, they all respect Bell's preparation and his ability to produce in games. I think a lot of guys in there can do without his off-field antics, but that's probably true of Antonio Brown, too. They just decide to live with it because he's a future Hall of Famer.

Greg: Any chance the NFL gets the catch rule actually figured out? I felt Riveron during the regular season too often tried to reinvent the wheel with his decisions. He seemed to forget what the original call was and whether there was indisputable evodence to overturn it.

Ray Fittipaldo: I would hope so, but they haven't figured it out in the past, and it's been a problem for years.

Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for all the questions this week. We'll do it again next week.