Turns out it’s not just Steelers fans who have a problem with the NFL’s catch rule.

In speaking to Fox Sports’ Colin Cowherd Monday, commissioner Roger Goodell signaled that changes may be coming for the rule, which has come under intense scrutiny since Jesse James’ apparent game-winning touchdown Dec. 17 against New England was overturned by replay.

“I’m not just somewhat concerned. I am concerned,” Goodell said when asked whether he worries that the rule is too confusing for fans.

“You want there to be clarity from an officiating standpoint, a coaching and a player standpoint. They know what it is and what it isn’t. So they draft the rule, the competition committee looks at it, they bring it to the membership and they want that clarity. I think here, you might have clarity in a large element of it. Then what happens is it’s not the rule that people really want.

Advertise with us

“One of our Hall of Fame receivers said it well to me when we looked at this a couple years ago: fans want catches.”

Steelers fans certainly did on the James play. He appeared to secure the ball, then only lost control as he reached it past the goal line while he was falling to the ground. To anyone without an NFL rule book on his or her coffee table, it looked like a catch.

Unfortunately for the Steelers, that’s where the NFL’s wordy and occasionally contradictory policies on the matter got in the way. As senior vice president of officiating, Al Riveron, infamously noted, James did not “survive the ground,” and did not catch the ball by the letter of the law, whether that’s what our eyes saw or not.

Goodell seems to be acknowledging that this is a problem and is interested in pursuing a change.

“We had a really good discussion for over three hours in looking at a lot of tape, and we’ve got some ideas of how to bring some clarity to that,” Goodell said. “It’s particularly in the going to the ground that I think has created a lot of the confusion, because it’s a different rule when you’re going to the ground and when you’re on the sideline of in the end zone. I think that’s what we’re focusing on.”

Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.