Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my Steelers chat. Let's get started.

Kevin S.: I am a Steelers season ticket holder in Atlanta. For the last several years I have noticed a significant number of seats unoccupied during play at home games, regardless of whether I am physically there or watching on TV. It appears to be considerably greater than the old days at Three Rivers. Two questions, if you please. Is this a function of the attractions at Heinz Field and does this negatively impact the players as it must be equally noticeable from the field and sidelines?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, ownership is aware. They certainly don't want empty seats in the stadium, but this has been happening for a year or two or three now. As for why, I honestly don't know. We all know a certain segment of the population was turned off by the kneeling and the national anthem stuff. That could be a part of it.

Chiefar: I always heard from "football experts" that GREAT coaches have their teams ready for the BIG games. I can think of two from the past, one from Penn State and one from the Steelers. Where do you think Mike Tomlin fits in, good, bad, great and why? Thanks

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin is 1-1 in Super Bowls so he's had the Steelers in the playoffs consistently over his tenure. However, in three of their past five playoff appearances the Steelers have been one-and-done, and I'd argue they suffered bad losses on two of those occasions. The 2011 wild-card loss to Tim Tebow should never have happened. The same goes for the Jacksonville game this year. To me, those are two inexcusable losses. I give him a little bit of a pass for the 2014 wild-card loss to the Ravens because of Bell's injury and their inability to find a back to play in that game. So overall, he's a good coach in big games as his Super Bowl appearances attest. But it's starting to get to the point of 'What have you done for me lately.'

John M.: I have read about how the Steelers can use the franchise tag on Bell and then trade him for two 1st round draft picks. Is this correct and if so why wouldn't the Steelers do this?

Ray Fittipaldo: No. They can place the franchise tag on him. That allows them to control his rights through the 2018 season whenever he signs it. If they place the non-exclusive tag on him another team can sign him, but they would owe the Steelers two first-round draft picks. That's not really a viable scenario because a team would never do that. Well, no team except the Browns. Maybe.

Moose : Do you think Bell was truthful when saying the Steelers knew he was going to miss that final practice? Why would he and Tomlin take so much heat for a whole week before coming out an saying it was excused? And I haven’t heard Tomlin confirm what Bell stated have you?

Ray Fittipaldo: I have no reason not to believe Bell. Cam Heyward also said Bell's absence was excused. He's a team captain. I have no reason not to believe Heyward, either. As for Tomlin not coming out and saying it earlier, he never really is active in that kind of stuff. I just don't think he cares enough to correct it.

Advertise with us

Moose : I think any player would be crazy to play in the Pro Bowl, how about you?

Ray Fittipaldo: Why? Rosie Nix makes about $500,000 a year. You don't think that extra $64,000 is important to him? That's life-changing money for someone like him.

Moose : Do you have any possibilities as replacements for Shay either via draft or FA? Smith from Georgia would be awesome, but he will be gone in rnd 1 unless we move up. It is sad to even say replacement, but they have to plan as if Shay never plays again right?

Ray Fittipaldo: You are right. There are a few other ILBs I've seen in the first round of some mock drafts. There's Evans from Alabama and a couple of others who might slide into the second round. But as Louis Riddick told me over the weekend this isn't really known as a great draft for linebackers.

Moose : What is this team missing the most, preventing them from getting over the hump to the next level? Personnel? Coaching? Focus? Discipline? Strategy?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: All of the above. That's what happens when you lose in the playoffs. Everyone should shoulder some of the blame. But for me, the biggest issue was personnel, especially at inside linebacker and safety. The Steelers weren't very good after Shazier was injured and the play of the two safeties last season was pretty bad overall.

Dave: Could you see the Steelers trading up to get an impact inside linebacker? They're really aren't in a position to wait for guys to develop to improve this defense next year.

Ray Fittipaldo: They've done that occasionally in the past. They traded up to get Polamalu. They just don't do it very often. So maybe if there is a player there they really like, but don't count on it.

Crazybaker: How high are the Steeler's on the play of Javon Hargrave? Chances of taking another nose tackle in the 1st 3 picks?

Ray Fittipaldo: Good question. The run defense hasn't been great with him the past two years. Some blame the linebackers, both inside and outside, but there is no doubt the Jaguars controlled the defensive line in the playoff game. I wouldn't mind an upgrade or even some competition for Hargrave. Big Dan McCullers likely won't be back so there is room for another guy to compete in the group.

Advertise with us

mtsteel: Hi Ray, Thanks for keeping up the chats! So Lewis Riddick, a well respected sports analyst, stated that he didn't feel like any of the guys in the secondary are that good. Watching the way they played this year, I tend to agree. Joe Haden aside, the rest were not good. A splash play here and there, but the overall play in the secondary was almost awful. Your thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: I was a little surprised he said Haden was past his prime. I was under the assumption Haden had a pretty good year. But I'll defer to Riddick on that evaluation. He played DB in the NFL for six years and worked for two NFL teams as a personnel exec. He wasn;t saying Haden was bad. He just opined that they need to get better there. In my opinion, Haden is their best DB. Big drop-off after him. Burns was average to below average. And the two safeties were pretty bad. Only bright spot was Mike Hilton and I'm still not sure how great he is in coverage. He made an impact in run support and in the blitz game, but I'm not sure he's a great cover corner. That was Riddick's point. They need to play man and lock offenses down on third downs. They weren't able to do that enough last season

Doug in Raleigh: This idea that Rooney II can have a godfatherly talk with Tomlin and get him to address some of the things at which Tomlin is glaringly weak, and expect it to happen, seems wishful to me. First, Tomlin might not see a problem, and second, you just can't change a personality by command. And if you then designate a time management/challenges/short yards coach, and a discipline coach, and take away his input to Butler, what exactly do you need Tomlin for?

Ray Fittipaldo: Doug, there is no way you can know what those conversations between Rooney and Tomlin are behind closed doors. Tomlin works for Rooney. I can't imagine Rooney liked what he saw this season with some of the distractions. Rooney will meet with the local media soon so we'll be able to ask him about it, but I don't think he has a problem telling Tomlin he has to change a few things.

Florida Steeler: Ray, I understand how the stock market works, buy a share it rises you cash out (if you want) How do the minority investors in the Steelers get a return on their money? Thanks

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: NFL teams print money so they're getting their money back and thensome.

JC: Ray, How do think the Bell situation will play out? Sign, franchise tag or let him walk? Thank you.

Ray Fittipaldo: Actually, it might be sign a contract or let him walk. They are negotiating with him now in hopes of getting something done before March 6. That's the first day of the new league year and free agency starts shortly thereafter. I think this year they'll do everything they can to get a deal done, but if they can't, they'll let him test free agency.

Emilio: If the Steelers do not sign Bell, and he signs with the Patriots. By how much the odds of beating them goes down to?

Ray Fittipaldo: Belichick is not a big believer in running backs. He thinks they're pretty disposable so I just can't see a scenario where they pay him $15 million a year, especially for a players whose worth will depreciate over the period of a long-term deal. The Patriots don't operate that way,

Advertise with us

ALB: Hi, Ray. Will there be any free agent linebackers, safeties or corners who could help the Steelers and have a price tag they might pay?

Ray Fittipaldo: Navorro Bowman is probably the top free agent inside linebacker. They were willing to pay big money to Dont'a Hightower last March so I assume they'd be willing to do that again if they like Bowman or another ILB in free agency, especially with Shazier's future very much in doubt.

DaquidoBazzini: Hi Ray - I know you've mentioned the fact that the Steeler DL got mauled by the JAX OL in the playoff game. The Steelers have spend a lot of money on that line. What do you think caused this?

Ray Fittipaldo: Great question. I think Tuitt was playing hurt all year. Hargrave had a back injury that prevented him from playing at full strength. Heyward was good all year but not all that good in that game. Stuff happens sometimes. The Jaguars controlled the game with their line. No one wants to hear excuses. The Steelers needed to be better along the D-line in that game and couldn't make it happen.

Jack: When is Art Rooney's year end press conference scheduled? Do you expect to hear anything of substance (i.e. additional coaching changes, etc.)?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Probably in the next week or two. And I don't think you'll see any coaching changes at this point.

Jack: Is there any consideration being given to promoting Mike Munchak to Associate Head Coach?

Ray Fittipaldo: Don't think they'd do that as long as John Mitchell is still in the same position. You can't really have two associate head coaches. And I don't think Munchak needs the title. Everyone in the NFL knows how important he is to the Steelers.

Rick: Hey Ray, Do you think I we should go to 4-3 and if we have the personnel to accomplish this,or simply get a real nose tackle like Casey Hampton..Just wondering what to do to help our run defense.

Ray Fittipaldo: You need more than a traditional nose tackle to stop the run. Bud Dupree wasn't very good against the run this year. And the inside backers struggled too. Plus, traditional nose tackles might get on the field 25 percent of the snaps in most games. Do you really want to invest a high-round pick for a player who doesn't play all that much?

Advertise with us

Jack: How are Joey Porter and Carnell Lake still employed? When you look at the lack of development and regression of some of our younger guys I'd have to give them a failing grade at this point.

Ray Fittipaldo: They certainly have been criticized for their inability to get the most out of their talent, but the only opinion that matters is of Tomlin and others who make those decisions. And apparently, he is OK with them.

Dave from Baltimore: So Ray who is telling the truth Bell or Sheffler; seems to be two completely different takes on negotiations between Bell and the Steelers front office.

Ray Fittipaldo: Bell is under the impressions they will get something done. That's all I can say for sure at this point.

Rick: Hey Ray,great chats. Please tell me why we are not making any changes to the defense,Is it because Tomlin had his hands to far in it that it wasn't the other coaches fault,or he really thinks everything is ok..The ranking of our defense doesn't tell the truth...

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I think Tomlin believes in the defense and the coaches he has assembled. We'll see if they can get it together next season.

DouglasMC: Do you think either Landry Jones or Josh Dobbs has what it takes to be a successful starter in the NFL?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not at this point, no

Rick: Ray, I really feel they need to keep the offense in tact by signing Bell and McDonald,and concentrate on defense with free agents and the draft.Thier secondary I think will come around as long as Haden stays healthy and the younger guys really get a lot of attention..So draft draft draft linebackers and defensive line..Your thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: And safety. Don't forget about safety. They have to get better there.

Advertise with us

Ron: Looks like this year's draft is pretty slim pickings on our greatest areas of need: ilb's and safeties. Further, if they give a contract to Bell, they'll have no cap room left to sign any quality free agents. Do you see ANY reason to be optimistic about the future?

Ray Fittipaldo: They'll be fine offensively whether Bell is here or not. The issue is with the defense and I'm not real high on it. They need to address some things. Can they fix it? Sure. But they really haven't fixed it to the degree they've needed to the past few years to get over the hump so I'm not overly optimistic they'll figure it out this year.

Ralph LA: How did the Steelers use Nix? If you are just watching the games on television it isn't easy to figure out. Was he blocking for Bell?

Ray Fittipaldo: A lot of the time yes. He's a fullback. That's his No. 1 job.

Ralph LA: Is the goal of NFL kickers to get the ball within the 10 yard line and force a return, or are they just trying to bang it as far as they can, into the endzone?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Different teams have different strategies. The good kickers can put some hang time on the kick and get it to the 1 exactly and force a return. The Patriots are good at this. I think the Jaguars are pretty good in that regard too.

Las Vegas Steeler Fan: Hey Ray, Thanks for the great insight. I was hoping you were wrong with your concerns about the Jaguars . Being from Las Vegas all we hear about is the Raiders. Do you think Gruden will change his opinion of Burfict when he takes a cheap shot at his Pro bowl quarterback ? He made it sound like JuJu was the dirtier player of the two.

Ray Fittipaldo: Let's see what his reaction is the first time Burfict goes after Carr's knees. Or Amari Cooper's head. Or... well, you get the picture.

Retire#21: It scares me that L-Bell could report week 12 with no training camp and not in game shape and that it would still count as his last year. Is that true? If so either sign him long term or let him walk and use a high pick and the money left over on a RB and a free agent LB respectively. Draft said to strong in runners and light on backers?

Ray Fittipaldo: That would never happen. First of all, I don't think he would have the guts to do that. And secondly, the Steelers can rescind that tag whenever they want. I don't think they'd let it drag on into the regular season.

Advertise with us

Coach D: Well now that it is apparent Tomlin will never be on the hot seat even though his playoff LOSSES are against immortals like David Garrard Blake Bortles Tim Tebow and he has never beaten Tom Brady (Coughlin did twice w Eli, Harbaugh has w Flacco) what would ever constitute a hot seat for him? Ladies and gentleman...we have the Marty Schottenheimer of the 2000s. It's not his bad record against sub 500 teams or lack of team discipline or early playoff exits so again what is it?

Ray Fittipaldo: Marty Schottenheimer never made it to a Super Bowl much less won one. I already laid out his poor playoff record since 2011. But the hot seat isn't going to be hot this offseason. Not after going 13-3.

Guest: Is there a deadline of sorts when the Steelers would have to release guys like Mitchell, Dupree and Gay, so they wish to do that?

Ray Fittipaldo: No, but they tend to do that in February or March so those guys have a chance to hit free agency and sign with other teams.

Uncle Elmer: Thanks for your time Ray. Appreciate your candor and insight throughout the football calendar year. The Steelers season is over regardless of the Q and A session- but was wondering if there is a specific position u feel needs addressed, that if it is not, will result in a major problem?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Inside linebacker and safety. They're not good enough at either position.

Cburg Stiller: Think there would be any interest in Earl Thomas as a FA safety pickup?

Ray Fittipaldo: Of course, but he makes too much money

Alan: I think the Steelers should take the best defensive player available at pick 28 regardless of position. They need help at all levels of the defense. What say you?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes to a degree, but they do draft for their needs.

Advertise with us

Bob from Va: Not a Todd Haley hater. He did seem to be repetitive in plays from certain formations (looks like run is a run: looks like pass is a pass) and certainly did not seem to anticipate the last series against N.E enough to be prepared to run a play. New coordinator reputed to anticipate two or three plays in advance. Big improvement from the change or no? Maybe longer drives?

Ray Fittipaldo: Time will tell. The Steelers have to get better in the red zone. If they do that they'll score more and won't be in so many close games.

Ray Fittipaldo: I think Faneca deserves it. Not sure it happens this year, but he'll get in. I haven't given much thought to the other guys. Ray Lewis will get in. I suppose Randy Moss gets in too.

Rob: Who do you think gets In The hall of fame this weekend?

Ray Fittipaldo: Answer to previous question

SBe or Bust: I thought Davis was ok at Safety, no? Mitchell is a cap casualty.

Ray Fittipaldo: Davis way too inconsistent. For a strong safety, he doesn't tackle nearly well enough.

TSgt Fisher: Hi Ray, Do you think moving Davis to Mitchell's spot and drafting/FA replacement for Davis's old spot might improve the D and get more out of Davis? Thanks

Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe. Davis is capable of playing both spots.

SBe or Bust: Need to rebuild the D. Need to let Bell walk and take money for FA and draft to build it.

Ray Fittipaldo: It might work out that way.

Charles De'Marr: Any FA ILBs you like?

Ray Fittipaldo: Bowman, but he has a checkered history with injuries.

Go Steelers!: Ray, if Bell wants $15+ million a year is he really worth it? He didn't seem to impact games that much. Brown on the other hand did.

Ray Fittipaldo: $15 million is a lot for a RB, even one who does so much in the passing game as he does. But they were willing to go to $14 million a year last year so I know they value him. Just don't know to what extent.

Chuck: Are the Steelers and Bell in a good spot with negotiations or not?

Ray Fittipaldo: He seems to think so.

Jay: Last spring the issue on ILB depth came up with Lawerence Timmons leaving to for free agency. With football being a game of attrition it didn't it seem prudent to address the depth issue last spring. Sometimes it seems like the Steelers are more reactive then proactive, even though no one expected Ryan Shazier to have a possible career ending injury he still was injury prone. What do you think?

Ray Fittipaldo: Agreed though I realize the salary cap prevents teams from being deep at every position. But certainly they got caught with their pants down after Shazier was injured.

A Blincoln: Is it reasonable to believe Bell is leaving it all up to his agent to make the deal?

Ray Fittipaldo: If that was the case Bell would have signed last summer. This is all about Bell, who said he wants to set the standard for RBs like him.

J from Akron: Why are so many people ready to get rid of L. Bell after mentioning his contract once? He did not have any drug issues that we know of, he played the whole season and was a big factor in the playoff game.

Ray Fittipaldo: All true though he wasn't dominant in the playoff game. He had a good game, but I'd argue he was better in the passing game in the second half of the season than the running game.

GregF: Do you think the Steelers actually go out this year and spend some money on good free agents that can help this team or do they take the cheaper route. Can we get a big game safety that can hit and make key plays and is not out of position like Mitchell is.

Ray Fittipaldo: They tried last year with Dont'a Hightower. They'll go after guys if they like them but they won't throw money around for the sake of throwing around money.

Joe: Given how manhandled the D was down the stretch, would using 2 or the top 3 picks at ILB be prudent with Williams for depth? Mac and Fort are really just special team players. Maybe they can also use them in pressure as the OLB’s continue to develop

Ray Fittipaldo: That was the plan last spring, but Hightower turned them down. Williams is paid like a low-level starter, which is what he is. He's competent. He might be best as a strong reserve.

Marnie: Hi Ray - I’ve read the articles indicating Tomlin is very involved with the defensive play calling each game. I read that as Tomlin basically doing the job of defensive coordinators. That surprised me. I hadn’t heard that comment or read while Lebeau was the defensive coordinator. Was wondering if Butler maybe on the proverbial hot seat -to the extent that Steeler coaches are on hot seat? He is still employed by the Steelers but a head coach stepping making game day decisions usually means the coordinator isn’t employed much longer.

Ray Fittipaldo: No I just think it means Tomlin is intricately involved in the day to day operations of the defense. Butler calls the game to the best of my knowledge. I don't know if Tomlin meddles to that extent.

Idaho Steeler Fan: Besides drafting some new personnel, how do you think the Steelers can improve on defense?

Ray Fittipaldo: Get players who know how to execute their assignments or simplify the defense so the ones you have aren't running around not knowing where to go.

Idaho Steeler Fan: What’s your prediction for the score of the super bowl?

Ray Fittipaldo: Patriots 34, Eagles 20.

Dean: Is there a chance they keep Stevan Ridley for next year...........he seemed to show signs of a real good back up..........I know they usually keep only three backs.........so is there a possiblity they keep him?

Ray Fittipaldo: He was open to coming back. Not so sure the Steelers share those feelings, but we'll see.

Tom: Will they resign Chris Hubbard and plug him into either LG (Foster) or RT (Gilbert) ?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think. I think they'll let him go somewhere else and make a nice buck.

Go Steelers: With Blount and Harrison stating that Tomlin promised them time to play, but acted otherwise, do you think is there is a problem with his communication style or he talks good game and then does not walk the same?

Ray Fittipaldo: Based on those two examples, it would seem he has some problems dealing with certain players or certain types of players. But overall, the players enjoy playing for him.

NYC Steeler: PFF focus rates Sean Davis as one of the worst players at his position in the NFL. A lot of talk about Mitchell, but not him. How come?

Ray Fittipaldo: Read above. He was pretty poor last season. He can't tackle.

Vince: Ray, It appears to me that all of the Steelers major needs are on defense. I think that their draft priorities should be 1) ilb 2.0 impact safety to hopefully replace Mitchell the human sieve 3.) nose tackle. your thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: That's pretty spot on though they might go another position instead of nose with an early pick.

Jay D: If steelers had signed hightower in FA, would that made a difference in Shazier's absence. At least against jags and for sure against pats

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes although Hightower was injured and won't play in the Super Bowl. You can't predict injuries.

Bob of Bowie: Would you agree w/former personnel executive Louis Riddick that our secondary “isn’t any good”? They they seem to be average at best..,

Ray Fittipaldo: They're average because of Joe Haden.

BDenny29: With the Super Bowl window expiration date seemingly set at Ben's 3 years, do you see the team being more aggressive in free agency to get more immediate returns?

Ray Fittipaldo: You might be onto something. We'll have to wait and see.

Chuck: 1. Do you think the Steelers will give into Bell's demands to be paid for two positions? 2. Do you think they we would be better off spending that money to fix our defense? Thanks, Great chat!

Ray Fittipaldo: They might be better off doing that, but how do you know they'll make the right signings. Think back to March of 2016. They had a chance to sign Eric Weddle to help the defense. They signed Ladarius Green instead. Weddle was in the Pro Bowl again. Green is out of football. I'm not necessarily taking a shot at Tomlin (who really wanted Green) or the front office, but free agency is a bit of a crapshoot. You never really know what you're getting. That's why so many teams like to build through the draft. You get them young and mold them they way you want them molded.

JP: Hi Ray, do you think there would be a need to draft a WR in rds 3-7 since Eli Rogers tore his ACL?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yeah not a bad call. Even if Rogers was healthy it wouldn't have been a bad idea. It's not like he's the second coming of Danny Amendola or Julian Edelman.

SteelrFAN4Life: Is it time to groom the next All-Pro center? Pouncey has been healthy, but is getting older (8 yrs) in the league. Could also use a road-grader guard too?

Ray Fittipaldo: Foster is a few years older so I'd replace him first. It is strange to me though that you have an All Pro center and can't get a yard behind him. I know he's not the biggest center, but it seems to me that's where you need to run when you need a yard. DeCastro too. Yet they went outside... That whole game against the Jaguars was nightmarish with so many questionable decisions.

Mike: Do you think that there is any way that the Steelers could help improve the development of S. Davis and A. Burns. At the end of last year, everyone was pretty impressed with them. They both regressed badly this year.

Ray Fittipaldo: I was higher on them at this time last year than I am now. That's not good.

Paul: If Shazier can not come back , what would be the salary cap implications? will he then still count torwards the cap?

Ray Fittipaldo: He counts $8.5 million against the cap whether he plays or not. I don't think that's fair to the Steelers. The NFL should have some type of salary cap relief for catastrophic injuries.

Steeler in Charlotte: There seemed to be communication issues at many points later in the season on defense. Is that on Williams, or were the calls not coming in soon enough? Or what else is up?

Ray Fittipaldo: I'm sure it was on the players and the coaches. Whatever the case, it happened far too much.

Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for all the great questions this week. We'll do it again next week.