Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my Steelers chat. Let's get started.

Chowdah Mullaney: just seems like this all comes back to Tomlin . Great organizational talent engine, and absolutely pathetic coaching.

Chowdah Mullaney: all trolling aside, how much blame do you lay at the feet of the coaching staff? Pitt is far and away the most talented team in the NFL, but they are routinely unprepared, baited into stupid plays(how bout a QB sneak) of which they actually got away w a few today (2 4th down 40+ completions) and can’t focus on what’s in front of them. People around the Pats organization said all weekend “don’t be surprised if that jag team comes out and knocks pitt out”.

Ray Fittipaldo: Nice handle, Chowdah. I lay lots of blame at the feet of the coaches, and I start at the top with Mike Tomlin. When he did that interview with Tony Dungy and looked ahead to the Patriots Part I and Part II. That gave his players the freedom to do the same. It was inexcusable for him to do that and a fireable offense in my opinion. I don't know if the Steelers will hold him accountable, but he made an egregious error when he answered that question by Dungy. Haley isn't likely to return and I'm not sure about Butler either. But for me it starts and stops with Tomlin. This season was a bad reality show.

Advertise with us

Moose: Why do we always get out game planned in the big games? Play calling was terrible on O, the Def was manhandled and had no answers, and once again, Tomlin with horrible in game decisions, specifically the on side kick when we had 2 TO and the 2 min warning.

Ray Fittipaldo: There is no doubt they were out coached in this game. There is absolutely no reason a team with Blake Bortles at QB should beat you, especially at home. The defense was out of position. There were communication errors. It was an awful performance. Once again, it starts with Tomlin. He's had more and more influence with this defense in recent years after Dick LeBeau's departure. Where were his adjustments Sunday?

Mike Tomlin on Steelers' loss: 'We didn't play well enough today'

Moose: Bell is great, but I am about fed up with his antics. Who brings up next year's contract situation 2 days before a playoff game? No focus on this team.

Ray Fittipaldo: All I know is the Patriots change running backs every year and continue to win. Bell is a great player, but his sideshow is tiresome. He's as guilt as Mitchell with the looking ahead and talking about it. He ought to look back to 2015 and check the success the Steelers had without him. He's not irreplaceable. Running backs are a dime a dozen. Look at the Saints. When did they get Alvin Kamara? Third round?

Moose: I believe our Offensive and Defensive lines lost that game yesterday. Don't you think we lost the battle in the trenches?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Definitely the defensive line. Not really sure where you are going with the offensive line. Roethlisberger dropped back to pass 58 times and they protected him well. They could never get into a rhythm running the ball because they were behind so early.

Moose: Do you foresee any coaching changes? We consistently have good regular seasons, but lose to terrible teams, and lose to the elite teams in elimination situations. If the goal is to win titles, something has to change.

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes and I'm not ruling out wholesale changes on both sides of the ball. When that game was over yesterday and I was in the locker room it felt like an ending to me. I know they have important players under contract on offense and they like some of their players on defense. I'm talking about the whole coaching operation. It felt like it ending and that changes were going to come. You just can't lose a game like that at home when your coaches spouts off about having the most talented team in the NFL. It can't happen.

Moose: I hate the Pats, but I can respect the fact that they are always 100% focused on the task at hand. You never ever hear them making comments on opponents 2-3 weeks away, contract situations, or stupid drama. I credit Belicheck for putting the kibosh on that nonsense. Don't you think Tomlin needs to model Bill in that sense?

Ray Fittipaldo: All I know is that this season was a circus and Tomlin was the ring leader when he did that interview with Dungy.

Advertise with us

Bryce: Any chance we see a change at offensive or defensive coordinator? Or both?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes definitely one, not ruling out both.

Moose: If we don't forsee paying Bell an enormous contract, wouldn't it be better to trade him now and get a lot in return for him? Maybe Ben's replacement? If we tag him again, we will most likely lose him and get nothing in return. Correct?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not how it works. If they don't tag him again he becomes an unrestricted free agent in March. So it's either tag him again and try to work out a long-term deal or let him become a free agent. Only two options.

PC: Does Haley and Butler lose their jobs? What is most glaring need for Steelers in offseason

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: The most glaring need is for this organization to stop being a clown show with their off-field antics.

DaquidoBazzini: Hi Ray, I felt like this Defense could implode for quite awhile this year, and it did yesterday. What’s the chance Keith Butler is fired?

Ray Fittipaldo: There is a chance for sure.

Jonah Spencer: Why does Todd Haley pitch the ball to the outside on 4th and 1 and do the Steelers part ways with him after this year?

Ray Fittipaldo: I might be mistaken, but I think Roethlisberger called an audible on that play and he's the one who made that call. Either way, Tomlin said afterward that he was OK with it. And I doubt Haley is back. Can't see him coming back.

Advertise with us

Tom88: Do you think there will/should be changes to the coaching staff?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes 100 percent. As I said before Sunday felt like an ending to me. Sometimes change is good. Things can get stale when coaches are around for a long time. All good things come to an end.

DaquidoBazzini: What’s the contractual status of Mike Mitchell & Bud Dupree? I think that might be two positions to make a change on this Steeler D.

Ray Fittipaldo: Mitchell has one year left. Not sure of the cap hit, but I've been a long-time critic of his. Many of my colleagues defend him for his on-field play. I don't see it. Of course, everyone is tired of his talk after what happened with the Jaguars...They have a decision to make on Dupree. They must decide by May if they want to pick up his fifth year option. Either way, he's under contract next season.

Jess from MT: Going back to the offseason the ILB depth at least appeared to be a concern for the team with them trying to sign Hightower to a big deal as Im thankful they didn't and I know this wouldn't have been a cure all but do you feel they should have made more of an effort to keep Timmons?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: All you needed to know was they went out and signed Sean Spence when Shazier was injured. They had zero confidence that Tyler Matakevich could fill that role. Tomlin pretty much came out and said that to Steelers.com. Don't remember his exact quote, but he made it sound like Matakevich was a sepcial teams player and not a starting linebacker.

Click here for more Post-Gazette coverage of the Steelers’ playoff run

Zach B: Hi Ray - it’s time for one of you in the local media to grow a pair and call for Tomlin’s Head! We haven’t won anything in 10 years with a Hall of Fame QB in his prime. Constantly play down to competition and clearly an undisciplined, unprepared football team all the time. We have a HOF QB, WR and possibly RB and get beat by Blake Bortles at home! And to all his defenders out there saying “look at his record” - that’s because he has a HOF QB. If the Browns had Big Ben they would have at least been in the playoffs this year. This guy needs to go and fans need to stop going to games so little Art gets the message! What are your thoughts, or do you even have the gonads to post this question??

Ray Fittipaldo: You should read every answer of mine today. It's all above.

Moose: Just an idea. Don't disrespect your current opponent by talking about winning next week's game vs the Pats. Maybe even quit talking smack on social media. Maybe stop talking a tough game and start playing a tough game. Thoughts?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Couldn't have said it any better.

abowerspittsburgh: Ray - The Steelers looked so unprepared yesterday, especially on defense. How does the coaching staff explain that in light of the fact that the team had a bye week and that they had played Jacksonville earlier in the season?

Ray Fittipaldo: There is no explanation. It was a terrible performance.

Zach B: Hi Ray - this team was woefully underprepared and undisciplined both in their communication and how they ran their mouths all year - does that sound like a team that has a solid head coach to you??

Ray Fittipaldo: No.

Advertise with us

abowerspittsburgh: No one wants to say this, but shouldn't the Jaguars be given credit for coming up a game plan that neutralized the Steelers' defensive line? It really exposed how badly the Steelers miss Ryan Shazier and his speed. This was compounded by poor play by the secondary in missing assignments.

Ray Fittipaldo: What does the Jaguars game plan have to do with the defensive line being out-physicaled at the line of scrimmage. The Jaguars offensive line dominated the Steelers defensive line. End of Story.

Zach B: Hi Ray - the Inside the NFL footage from Patriots game told the fans all we need to know about Tomlin as a coach. Unprepared, undisciplined, hot mess of an in game coach? Why no call for his head for underachieving for 10 straight years with a HOF QB??

Ray Fittipaldo: 10-year anniversary of the last Super Bowl is next season.

Scott: Without a doubt, Ryan Shazier's absence proved a HUGE void the team was unable to fill. Linebacker was the biggest soft spot yesterday and proved how valuable he is/was. CAN he return and if not, where does the team go from here? Draft? Free agency?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Unfortunately, Ryan is paralyzed. Mike Mitchell came out and told us that Sunday morning on one of the pregame shows. The hope is he walks again. They have to go find his replacement in the draft.

Zach B: Hi Ray - most talented roster in the NFL hands down and yet another season lost due to incompetence. When will little Art learn from the Penguins and fire the HC after watching him underachieve with a loaded roster. Worked for them with back to back Stanley Cups!! Tomlin has made the Steelers an after thought in this town??

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes but the Penguins also hired Mike Johnston before they hired Mike Sullivan. If you make that move you better have an idea of who his replacement will be.

Ross : What happened to the entire defense? Players couldn’t play. Coaches couldn’t coach. The team has been porous all season for big plays, dispite being ranked 5th - which is hard to believe. Do you think the front office would consider a change at DC? It’s been the defense holding this team back over the last couple of years.

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes but you also have to acknowledge the growing influence Tomlin has had on that unit since Lebeau left. It's not all Butler's fault.

Advertise with us

Ron from NJ: Ray, I’m still shaking my head in disbelief. Two less than 4th and ones on not one QB sneak or fullback ray up the middle? And an on side with 2 timeouts and the two minute warning? Atrocious! I get the defense stunk all day, but either way in that situation, the defense needs to hold to 3 and out. And if you’re going to do that, why not do that in your opponents territory and not in field goal range? Somebody should be held accountable today - Tomlin, or Haley or both. This team was too good to lose to Blake Bortles and Company. And, no Vince Williams, this isn’t hate throwing, it’s fact, based on the total lack of preparedness and inept decision making that was on display yesterday.

Ray Fittipaldo: Ownership has to hold some people accountable. Things won't remain the same, that's for sure.

Huck: 550 yards of offense and still can't win! WTF is that all about? l Maybe,just maybe,they should start playing some defense! Yeah...I know that losing Ryan Shazier was huge for us,but our defense was pretty damn bad while he played too! , OH YEAH...their little TD celebrations are pretty fricking cute too! Guys,you are down by 21 points for God's sake. There is NO NEED to celebrate that at all!!

Ray Fittipaldo: Just letting you vent.

mtsteel: Hi Ray and thanks for your time this season. So what can we say? We seem to be in the same spot year after year, great regular season and then some bone headed moves in the playoffs to knock us out. The main thing is, I feel those moves have been from coaches. Bad offensive play calling when it matters, bad time management (onside kick?), defense never ready in big games?? Is this organization ever going to change that or do we just repeat and hope? Thank you sir

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Changes will be coming. It's just a matter of the extent.

Steve0212: Tomlin is just another Andy Reid - a good coach who fails in the post season. Time for a change...

Ray Fittipaldo: Well, Tomlin does have one Super Bowl. Andy Reid hasn't done that.

Beav: what is this defense missing, i would think its time to replace mitchell, and middle linebacker in draft? free agency?

Ray Fittipaldo: Top draft needs in order: ILB to replace Shazier, FS to replace Mitchell. The head-scratcher to me is the defensive line. They have so much money invested in that unit and they got pushed around Sunday. Inexcusable. That's not looking like money well-spent.

Advertise with us

Bubba Taco: Is the lack of QB sneak a Ben or Haley issue? Brees did a simple QB sneak on a 3rd and 1 yesterday. It is the most routine play in the book, and works 95% of the time.

Ray Fittipaldo: Ben has been on record the past two years saying he's all for it. Haley has said he doesn't like getting his QB ear-holed and Tomlin has been on record saying that RBs are on the roster for such situations. It's inexplicable to me that they don't run a sneak.

JIm: Is Haley gone? If so how would you rate his tenure? I would keep him I really don't think the offense has been the problem the pasty 3 or 4 years. The defense is just not good enougth.

Ray Fittipaldo: Haley had a good run, but you have to produce in the playoffs, and he never got to a Super Bowl with the Steelers. That's how he'll be judged.

Sam: What happened to Tuitt and Heyward? Is jacksonville offensive line that good?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Good question. Both make $10 million a year. Tuitt had the one tackle on the screen that was good, but that was the only time I noticed him. I didn't notice Heyward much either. They needed more from them.

Chief: The empty set tells the other team this is a pass play come after our QB. Why not more play action. I hate the empty set

Ray Fittipaldo: Have to be able to be in position to call play-action passes. That can't happen when you get behind by 21 points in the first quarter.

Joe: Do you think Todd Hailey is out of pittsburgh? If so who would make a good replacement

Ray Fittipaldo: Randy Fichtner

Advertise with us

Steelcity21: Why does Tomlin seem to get a pass for Steelers failures? It always seems that something else is to blame

Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin isn't getting a pass for this loss. In other years they had injuries. He should get a lot of blame for the way this season ended, and he is.

Dude_From_Cali: An NFL championship caliber team who does not have a 4th and inches QB sneak in the playbook is no longer a team, I root for with unconditional support. Ray, thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: Again, it's inexplicable to me that they don't run it. It cost them in the AFC championship game last January too.

Jeff: I know everyone's whipping boy today is Todd Haley but why is Keith Butler not being mentioned? They could not stop the Jags all day. How can anyone justify Butler keeping his job when the past 2 postseason performances in the playoffs have been an utter disgrace? I just don't see the defense getting any better especially in the secondary since he has been the coordinator.

Ray Fittipaldo: I agree, but just acknowledge that Tomlin is more involved in that defense.

Dean: What pieces need to be added for this defense to be great again?

Ray Fittipaldo: ILB, FS, maybe another OLB if they don't like Dupree, maybe Cam Sutton if they don't like Burns... I don't really feel great about this defense to be honest with you.

Pete D from NYC: Can 13-3 be considered a failure? I say yes. Considering the expectations. I too come back to the head coach. He sets the tone with his mouth and his team follows. The lack of Football IQ during situational football is astounding. He leads wth emotion but basic strategy eludes him. Thank God for ballers on offense because they lose by 30if not. This coach is good at best. We don’t need more emotion from a head coach, we need more discipline and strategy.

Ray Fittipaldo: Just letting you vent, Pete.

Lonnie: The Steelers need a culture change. Time to get rid of Tomlin. The Rooneys are better than that

Ray Fittipaldo: Same, Lonnie.

Doug in Raleigh: Supposedly Tomlin does "exit interviews" with the players, does Art Rooney have one with him? This can't be a very happy owner today. It's one thing to over or knee jerk react, quite another to keep whistling past the tombstones.

Ray Fittipaldo: All members of the organization have meetings at year's end. Don't imagine this will be a pleasant one between Rooney II and Tomlin.

Matt: Is it coaching or talent or both

Ray Fittipaldo: Both, let's be honest. I think some of the players they've drafted on defense in recent years are struggling. So it's not just players, coaches. It's the front office, too. Whenever you lose it's not one group. Everyone shoulders some of the blame.

Matt: With all the high picks we have why isn’t our defense good ?

Ray Fittipaldo: Great question. Burns has not progressed. Dupree didn't play like a first-round pick this season. They have an interesting decision to make with his fifth year option.

Burley : Am I being too simple, or did Jville have the exact same strategy on offense yesterday as they did in the first game, and somehow we were less prepared for it?

Ray Fittipaldo: Pretty much. They gashed the Steelers for 231 on the ground in the first game and got 164 yesterday. If you can't stop the run you're not going to beat that team. That's how Borltes had all of those wide open receivers. They established the run and put him in positions to succeed.

Ron from Iowa: How bad does this defense need to be blown up? Tweak it or scrap it and start over? The offense was not perfect, but did enough to win. Watt, Heyward and Tuitt are all nice pieces, but they disappeared all day yesterday. Everyone else is replaceable. Do you agree?

Ray Fittipaldo: You have to keep Haden. He's your only good corner. Burns is too inconsistent. The safeties struggled this season with inconsistency too.

john: Also, all the players that opened their stupid mouths should also be gone....I don't care who they are.....all of them!

Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe they will be.

Doug in Raleigh: So is the defensive talent way overrated, or are they not put into the proper schemes? Yes, coaches don't make plays, but the Jags sure looked like the better prepared team.

Ray Fittipaldo: Little of both. Just because you're a first- or second-round pick doesn't mean you're good. Some of these guys have underperformed.

Philly Jim: This team is undisciplined and poorly coached. Lots of talent but underperforming. Given Mitchell's ranting outside the Jags locker room, which is outrageous, it is apparent to me Tomlin cant control these players. Thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: I guess Jaguars players said that about Mitchell after the game. I wasn't there to hear it, but that's what I heard. If that happened it's even more inexcusable than running your mouth to the media. You have to go and do it in person, too, to get them even more riled up? That's crazy if that happened.

Joe Hanuscin: I sent a question to Steelers.com that was not chosen (which is fine) about do we need to be concerned about a defense that gave up a lot of points to a 0-16 team in the last game of season (that defense was only missing Cam Heyward that day)? Clearly we did. That performance was absolutely pathetic from every aspect. Is that the worst defensive performance from a Steelers team in the playoffs?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes. The only other time they gave up 45 was in 1984 and that was to Dan Marino. They gave up 45 to Blake Bortles. Enough said.

Rick: Hey Ray,. Cowher would of never put up with all the bull going on with this team, Tomlin has big management of the game issues,and player issues that he feels is not a problem...What say you...

Ray Fittipaldo: Wasn't Cowher the coach in 1994 when Eric Green and Co. produced that rap video before the loss to the Chargers in the AFC championship game?

Tim from Big T Country: Good Morning Ray. It seems like the Steeler's been drafting linebackers in the first round for ever but that's exactly what they need to do again. I think the defense wouldn't have stopped them even with Shazier playing. I think Bud Dupree is a bust. Your thoughts.

Ray Fittipaldo: They have to draft another ILb but through no fault of their own. Shazier suffered a catastrophic injury. The Dupree thing, yeah it's not looking like a great pick. He has to produce more.

rman: The Steelers do not seem to match up very well against teams that play "smash mouth" football. What are your thoughts on this statement? Also, I thought Ben, for the most part, was spectacular....maybe his best game ever.

Ray Fittipaldo: No way was that Ben's best game ever. As he said after the game he was responsible for giving the Jaguars 14 points. You can't do that in a playoff game.

Dave: If you to had to make a change and let go of one coach on this staff, who would it be and why?

Ray Fittipaldo: I'd think long and hard about Tomlin because of the clown show that was the 2017 season. I know that's not what they'll do, but there was way too much drama surrounding this team. They need to tighten up.

MB: Ray, this season was a complete failure given what happened last year and the expectations for this year. No playoff wins and you lose to a Blake Bortles led offense giving up 38 offensive points. This loss is an indictment of the coaching staff from top to bottom and major coaching changes should happen otherwise I don't expect next season will be any better.

Ray Fittipaldo: Sometimes change is good. Look at all the teams that made changes last offseason and how they did.

Steelcity21: Colin Cowherd had talked about the Steelers on his show that he likes them but they aren't buttoned up enough in the way they handle and discuss business with the media. Is there a sense from you that this is true?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes.

ralph: No sacks? do you think #82 would have put some pressure on Bortles? O I forgot he didn't have it anymore. Do you think he would forget his assignments?

Ray Fittipaldo: You mean 92 and I agree any pass rush would have been welcomed yesterday.

jim: Was all of the miscommunication on the defense this year the DC or the players. I have never seen so many wide open receivers as I have this year by our secondary.

Ray Fittipaldo: Should not happen in Week 19. Inexcusable.

Steelcity21: Do you think the Steelers talk to much? Is this the HC fault?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes and yes. He's in charge. It's his team.

Ralph: With all the clamoring for coaching changes, do you really think changes will happen any time soon?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes

jim: Yes, lots of doom and gloom today, that happens after you get embarrassed on national television like that. What do you think was the biggest reason for this debacle?

Ray Fittipaldo: Lack of focus on the team they were playing. Lack of preparation. Lack of attention to detail...I can go on and on

Barry Halls: If the jags play like they did yesterday. They will beat the patriots. Do you agree. Would love to watch a Super Bowl that doesn’t involve Brady.

Ray Fittipaldo: No. The Patriots won't self-destruct early and let the Jaguars get a big lead. Not saying the Jaguars defense won't play well, but I don't see their offense playing that well again. The Patriots coaches won't let that happen.

Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for all the great questions today. Come back next week if I didn't answer your question. I have to get to the locker room for the final session with players this year.