Steelers-Patriots Part II.

It has been forecast since the NFL schedule came out in April. The notion was spurred along by the unlikeliest of characters in November when Mike Tomlin felt emboldened to predict the two best teams in the AFC would meet again in the playoffs.

It was only natural this week for fans to speculate about a Steelers-Patriots rematch, especially with the juicy James Harrison vs. the Steelers story line that would be in play. But how often do the two best teams from the regular season meet for the right to go to the Super Bowl?

The top two seeds from each conference only have to win one game in the playoffs to advance to the conference title game, but over the years it has been proven that the only thing that’s predictable about the NFL playoffs is that they are unpredictable.

Advertise with us

The chances of the Steelers and Patriots playing each other in the AFC championship game are 50-50. At least that’s what history tells us since the NFL went to its current playoff format in 1990, the first year six teams from each conference made the playoffs. Twenty seven of the 54 conference title games staged since 1990 have featured the top two seeds.

There was a time when it was almost a given the top two seeds would advance that far. From 1990-2000, the top two seeds in the NFC met in the conference title game nine times in a 10-year span. The only time it didn’t happen was 1995 when No. 3 seed Green Bay won in San Francisco to advance to the title game to play No. 1 seed Dallas.

But those days of predictability are long gone. There are a few reasons for the increased playoff parity, most notably the institution of the salary cap in 1994. And the AFC has seen the most upsets.

Only 10 times in those 27 years since 1990 have the top two teams met in the conference title game. The Steelers, perhaps better than any team in the NFL, know the playoffs are all about who’s hot in January and February rather than who’s seeded higher.

The Steelers became the first team in NFL history to win the Super Bowl as the No. 6 seed in 2005. They beat the No. 3 seed, the No. 1 seed and the No. 2 seed in the AFC en route to Super Bowl XL before knocking off the Seahawks, who were the No. 1 seed in the NFC.

Advertise with us

In 2008, when the Steelers won Super Bowl XLIII, they were the No. 2 seed. They beat the No. 6 seeded Ravens in the AFC championship game and the No. 4 seeded Cardinals in the Super Bowl.

In 2010, when they reached Super Bowl XLV as the No. 2 seed, they beat the No. 5 and No. 6 seeds (Ravens and Jets) in the AFC playoffs before losing to the No. 6-seeded Packers in the Super Bowl.

“They [darn] sure didn’t play like a 6 seed, and we can’t play this year like we’re going to have an easy road to Minnesota,” said offensive lineman Ramon Foster, who started against the Packers in Super Bowl XLV. “I don’t think we will.

“It’s amazing. You walk around this room and everyone is locked in. With all the distractions, with players not playing, being on the road so often early in the season, to handling all the prime time games, everyone has been locked in. If that’s not a testament to what type of team we are then I don’t know what is.”

Gerry Dulac and Ray Fittipaldo look ahead to Steelers-Browns

This will be the first time since 2010 the Steelers don’t have to play on wild-card weekend. Right tackle Marcus Gilbert was drafted by the Steelers in 2011 and has competed in the playoffs four times. He knows what it’s like to be a higher-seeded team and lose at home in the playoffs. It happened to the Steelers in 2014 when they were No. 3 seed and lost to the No. 6 seed Ravens at Heinz Field.

Advertise with us

The next season the Steelers were the No. 6 seed and almost made it to the AFC championship game. They beat the Bengals in a wild-card game and held a fourth quarter lead against top-seeded Denver before Peyton Manning staged a late comeback.

“It’s single elimination,” Gilbert said. “Everyone knows as long as you get a chance to play everyone has an opportunity. We can’t take any team lightly. I know a lot of people want to look ahead and appoint us to that Patriots game in the AFC championship game, but it’s all a trap. And I think our guys understand that, too. We’ve been there before. We know the ramifications of us going out there and laying an egg or taking a team lightly.”

The AFC has been particularly tumultuous in recent years. There have only been two 1-2 matchups in the past 12 seasons. There have been three 2-6 matchups in the title game in that same 12-year span.

Just about every permutation with seeding that could happen has in the past 27 years. In the AFC — after the 10 1-2 matchups — there have been four 1-3 matchups; four 2-4 matchups; three 2-6 matchups; two 1-4 matchups; two 2-5 matchups; one 1-5 matchup; and one 3-4 matchup.

Now more than ever it’s about getting hot at the right time. Those 2005 Steelers won their final four regular-season games and four postseason games to claim Super Bowl XL. Last year’s Steelers won their final seven regular-season games after a 4-5 start and didn’t lose until the AFC championship game.

Advertise with us

The Steelers have won 9 of 10 this season entering Sunday’s regular-season finale against the Browns.

“It’s about who understands circumstances more than anything,” Foster said. “And by that I mean it’s ‘Win or go home.’ I don’t think seeding means much more than you get to play at home. You have to play your butt off every single game.”

And just because Tomlin and just about everyone else from Delmont to Duxbury is predicting a Patriots-Steelers rematch don’t think for a minute the players are thinking that way. The ultimate path Steelers fans would be to go through Foxborough and beat the Patriots on their home field. That would be exorcising those demons from 2001, 2004 and 2016 in an improbable manner.

The players don’t necessarily think that way.

“I don’t think we have to go through them,” Foster said. “I’ll be happy as hell if they lose. And I’m sure they’ll be happy as hell if we lose. I could care less if Kansas City comes to us or if Jacksonville comes to us. What matters to me is winning.”

Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.