A lot of money can solve a lot of problems. Nobody knows that better than the NFL. This time, though, $100 million may not get it done.
That’s about how much the league and its owners have tentatively agreed to donate to its “social justice initiative.” Nothing about the league’s ongoing tightrope walk between player protests and public backlash has been simple, and this week’s news was no different.
The main issues with that particular figure, beyond the fact that it represents a drop in the bucket for the league (no matter what Papa John’s says), is twofold: The deal feels like a de facto payoff to stop anthem protests, and it was negotiated with a too-small portion of players that doesn’t — and can’t — represent the larger group.
Three Steelers on Friday expressed frustration with various parts of the process.
“I feel like now we’re trying to come up with Band-Aids for solutions, you know what I mean? In the sense of [the league saying], ‘Hey, we’ll donate X amount of dollars to this, but you guys aren’t allowed to do any type of public displays of protest.’ I feel like there’s pros and cons both ways,” linebacker Arthur Moats said.
Asked if that’s how the negotiation process was framed — as a quid pro quo, which the league has denied — Moats said, essentially, yes.
Read More
“That’s kind of how we took it. That’s definitely how it came off,” he said. “And because we weren’t in those meetings directly, we don’t know 100 percent, but that’s definitely the vibe that we got [among] the players. And it’s unfortunate because, like I said, we weren’t in that meeting. We really don’t know.”
Told of Moats’ stance — one echoed by other players, both on- and off-the-record at various media outlets — defensive end Cam Heyward agreed.
“Right. Right. Yeah, like we’re being bought out of our opinions,” he said. “I don’t operate by that.”
Neither Moats nor Heyward has protested during the anthem. Both are deeply involved with community outreach. Both also had an issue with the Players Coalition itself, a group of about 40 players led by Eagles safety Malcolm Jenkins and retired wide receiver Anquan Boldin that has fractured in recent days.
Jenkins had been raising his fist during the anthem since Week 2 of the 2016 season. That protest, he said, is over.
“The purpose was to draw awareness to the issues that plague people of color, and the disenfranchisement of our communities, police brutality, the gap in our education system, the way our criminal justice system devours black bodies,” Jenkins said on Friday (via NJ.com). “That’s what I wanted to draw awareness to. I’ve been actively working to improve in those areas nationally, and in my own community.
“Through those works, we were able to sit down and have dialogue with the league about how they can amplify those efforts, and move past the demonstrations. I feel those conversations have gone well. I feel like in good faith, the platform that they have offered to provide amplified that, but takes all of it to a new level. Not only does it draw awareness, but you can make actual change on both a national and local level.
“In good faith, that’s what I set out to accomplish in the first place. I’ll continue to do the work. I’m proud that we’ve been able to go from just a simple silent demonstration, even with all of the noise and backlash that that caused, we showed a lot of perseverance, a lot of sacrifice. Hopefully we’ll come out of that with something that’s very meaningful.”
Still, three members — 49ers safety Eric Reid, Dolphins safety Michael Thomas and Chargers lineman Russell Okung — left the group on Wednesday.
I agree with @E_Reid35’s assessment & also withdrew my involvement with the Players Coalition, effective earlier today. pic.twitter.com/A3zpQ4BN5N
— Russell Okung (@RussellOkung) November 30, 2017
Reid and Thomas said that while they’d continue working with the league, Jenkins and Boldin couldn’t speak on their behalf. Reid specifically told the Associated Press that he left because Jenkins excluded Colin Kaepernick from meetings, and asked players if they would stop protesting if the NFL made a charitable donation to causes they support.
Okung, meanwhile, called the NFL’s process “disingenuous” and “woefully inadequate.”
Heyward echoed both of those concerns: an issue with both the donation itself and its genesis.
“This is the thing, I don’t know where it’s coming from in the first place. I’ve heard rumors of where it came from. I just don’t have a definite answer,” Heyward said.
Around the time Heyward spoke, the NFL’s memo detailing the “social justice initiative” was circulating. In short, it’ll be initially funded with a $3 million grant and “supplement, not replace” existing league programs for cancer awareness, military appreciation, et al. Reid told Slate that he’d been told owners could choose to shift money from one cause to another; in other words, that they could avoid spending any more money.
Here are the memos sent to teams from NFL executives that provides an outline of the new community and social justice initiative. pic.twitter.com/CB3LyRcIll
— Ian Rapoport (@RapSheet) December 1, 2017
The issue of the Players Coalition, though — the size, specifically — remains.
“[For] it to only be one percent [of players] that’s voting, it’s just not enough for me,” Heyward said. “The Players Coalition was not a group formed by the whole NFL. For me to say I agree with it and I support is …”
He paused.
“I honestly don’t think it represents everybody. It needs to be a collective effort of everybody.”
Center Maurkice Pouncey called the infighting “pointless.”
“With me the whole time, it was ‘stand up [for the anthem]’ If people think it’s disrespectful, stand up,” Pouncey said. “But for me, if [the Players Coalition] is in a disagreement and they’re falling apart now, it kind of makes it senseless. Like, pointless. What’s it look like? We’re all in this together, don’t change up at the end.
“Don’t have a couple guys feeling this way and another guy feeling that way, because now it makes it look like there was no point in ever doing it. Like you’re against each other.”
Sean Gentille: sgentille@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.