Ben Roethlisberger and Andrew Luck combined to score 85 points and threw for 922 yards and nine touchdowns in a 2014 game the Steelers won, 51-34. NFL fans and TV executives salivated at the thought of future matchups between two of the league’s top quarterbacks. When the two teams met again the following season it was the nationally televised NBC Sunday night game. Last year the league made Steelers-Colts the primetime game on Thanksgiving.
But the dream matchup didn’t materialize either year. In 2015, Luck missed the game with a lacerated kidney and last season he missed with a concussion. When the Steelers play the Colts Sunday they’ll play a Luckless Colts team again because of a shoulder injury that last week landed the $123 million quarterback on injured reserve for the remainder of the season.
Luck isn’t the only star quarterback who has endured a major injury in 2017. DeShaun Watson of Houston (knee), Carson Palmer of Arizona (arm), Sam Bradford of Minnesota (knee) and Ryan Tannehill (knee) of Miami are out for the season, too. Aaron Rodgers of Green Bay will miss at least two months and perhaps more with a fractured collarbone.
That’s almost one-fifth of the league dealing with major injuries to their franchise quarterbacks.
“This year it’s not really any worse with the injuries, but it’s the stars who are getting injured,” said Dr. David Chao, a former team doctor for the San Diego Chargers who now works in private practice. “It seems like it’s one of those years for the stars.”
In addition to the high-profile quarterbacks, three-time NFL defensive player of the year J.J. Watt, receiver O’Dell Beckham, Jr., running back David Johnson, safety Eric Berry, linebacker Dont’a Hightower are all out for the season, too.
Read More
When the NFL released its schedule the second half of the season looked perilous for the Steelers. They’d have to face Luck, Rodgers, Watson and Tom Brady of New England as they tried to repeat as AFC North champions. But Brady is the only one left standing as the Steelers get set to open the second half of the season in Indianapolis Sunday. Instead, they’ll face Jacoby Brissett, followed by Brett Hundley and Tom Savage when they play the Packers and Texans.
Talk about a stroke of good fortune. This string of good luck for the Steelers goes back a couple of years. In the past two postseasons they’ve played two playoff games against backup quarterbacks. They beat A.J. McCarron of Cincinnati and Matt Moore of Miami in AFC wild-card games the past two years when Andy Dalton and Tannehill were injured.

Why is it happening?
Under NFL rules, quarterbacks are not allowed to be hit in the head or neck area when they are in the pocket. Hitting them below the waist when they’re in the pocket is not legal, either.
The rules were put in place to protect the most expensive and the most irreplaceable players on NFL rosters.
However, once quarterbacks leave the pocket they are no longer protected. That’s how Rodgers was injured. He was hit by Vikings linebacker Anthony Barr after scrambling out of the pocket. That’s also how Derek Carr of Oakland missed a game earlier this season. He was attempting to run and injured his back.
Other quarterback injuries occur because traditional pocket quarterbacks aren’t being produced by the colleges that feed talent to the NFL. Many of the younger quarterbacks in the league come from spread offenses in college and were selected high in the draft at least in part because of their athleticism and running ability.
NFL coaches teach them how to become pocket quarterbacks, but in order for them to be productive, especially early in their careers, coaches have to take advantage of their athleticism.
While Watson’s injury happened in practice in a non-contact drills it occurred when the Texans were practicing a running play, not a passing play.
Chao pointed to four quarterbacks that have been able to stay healthy for long stretches over the years. Eli Manning of the New York Giants has started 219 consecutive games. Phillip Rivers of San Diego has started 193 consecutive games. They are third and fourth on the NFL’s all-time list for most consecutive games played.
Since injuring his knee and missing the final 15 games of the 2008 season, Tom Brady of New England hasn’t missed a game because of injury over the nine ensuing seasons. Drew Brees of New Orleans has missed two games since the beginning of the 2005 season.
“What do they all have in common?” Chao asked. “They all get rid of the ball and stay in the pocket. The guys who are on the outside, the guys who extend plays, they get hurt more.”
One of the reasons the Steelers fired offensive coordinator Bruce Arians in 2011 and hired Todd Haley as his replacement was to extend Ben Roethlisberger’s career. Ownership felt like Roethlisberger was getting sacked too much and taking too many big hits.
From 2004 until 2011, Roethlisberger missed eight games due to injuries. Since 2012, Roethlisberger has missed eight games due to injuries, but he’s taking far fewer hits.
Under Haley, the Steelers have cut their sack numbers way down by having Roethlisberger play a more controlled game. The Steelers front office also has built a top-notch offensive line to protect him.
Over the past 24 regular-season games the Steelers have allowed just 31 sacks. This season they have given up 10 sacks. Only the Saints (8) have given up fewer.
In 2009, one season after their last Super Bowl victory, the Steelers allowed 50 sacks in 16 games. They allowed 42 in 2011, the final season under Arians.
“I think I’ve got the best line in the business,” Roethlisberger said. “People want to talk about some of the other ones out there, but I’ll put my guys up against anybody, anytime. Whether it’s run blocking, pass blocking, obviously not giving up any sacks … That makes me feel better. It makes my wife and the rest of my family feel better, too.”
Other teams, including the Colts, aren’t as good at protecting their quarterbacks. The Colts have given up an NFL-high 36 sacks this season. They gave up 44 sacks last season and Luck was among the league’s most-hit quarterbacks.
Dr. Chao and others believe young offensive linemen are ill-prepared for NFL pass protection because they come from spread offenses in college. And there are those who believe that linemen suffer the most under the 2011 collective bargaining agreement because the practice rules limit contact and greatly reduced the number of padded practices.Offensive linemen need the practice time more than any other position because the techniques involved in their trade require constant repetition to be perfected.
Steelers center Maurkice Pouncey, a two-time All-Pro, has another theory, and it has everything to do with the coaching in the NFL. Simply put, Pouncey said since line coach Mike Munchak arrived in 2014 the Steelers’ line play has improved exponentially, and he readily acknowledges other NFL teams don’t have the same luxury.
Simply put, Pouncey believes coaching is a major reason for the dysfunctional pass protection in the league.
“I came from the same type of spread offense [at Florida],” said Pouncey, who had two previous line coaches with the Steelers before Munchak arrived. “I honestly can say if you have a great O-line coach, and he really knows the techniques, things can easily roll over for you. I never did under-the-center snaps in college. We were a spread out team with a whole bunch of playmakers. You have to have the right coach around you. If you just have a guy who [messes] around and really doesn’t coach technique then it’s obviously it’s going to look like that. I love all the coaches who have been here but since Munch has been here, it’s self-explanatory.”
Ed Bouchette and Gerry Dulac look ahead to Steelers vs. Colts
Unlucky Colts
Perhaps no team in the NFL understands how the absence of a star quarterback can affect a team’s fortunes better than the Colts.
Luck has missed 17 of the past 40 games due to injuries. By season’s end, that number will jump to 25 of 48, or more than half the games over three seasons.
During the first three seasons of Luck’s career the Colts made the playoffs every year and finished with 11 regular-season victories in each of those years. They reached the AFC championship game following the 2014 season.
But with Luck dealing with his various injuries since the start of the 2015 season, the Colts are 19-22 in their past 41 games entering Sunday’s date with the Steelers. They are 3-6 this season.
“We got off to such a great start and had a ton of success early,” said Colts coach Chuck Pagano, who was hired in 2012, the same year Luck was a rookie. “You can always sit back and think about what could be, but you can’t do that in this league. It’s part of the league. You’re seeing it more and more, unfortunately.
“That’s why you can’t take any of these games for granted. We don’t do that around here. Nothing is promised. Nothing is guaranteed. That’s why you have to take advantage of every opportunity and every day you have in this league because it can be taken away from you in a heartbeat.”
The Colts haven’t fared very well against the Steelers without Luck the past two years. The Steelers beat them, 45-10, when Matt Hasselbeck started for Luck in 2015. They beat the Colts, 28-7, last year when Scott Tolzein was the quarterback.
Brissett, who was acquired shortly before the season began, has been the starter since Week 2.
“It’s part of the National Football League,” Pagano said. “Injuries happen. Certainly, you never want to see it happen to your quarterback. It’s always a difficult task, but I credit our coaching staff in having to deal with it the past couple of years. [Luck] missed nine games in 2015 and we navigated through that. That probably helped us down the road. You never want to be without your guy, especially at that position, but the coaches and players have done a good job. It’s ‘Next man up’, and you have to deal with it.”
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.