David DeCastro’s capacious brain works better than most or it wouldn’t have enabled him to study management, science and engineering at Stanford, but it still takes the Steelers All-Pro guard 24 to 36 hours to fully comprehend the violence he sees on an NFL field on Any Given Sunday, Monday, or Thursday.
“It’s usually the night after games or the next morning when you’re just like, ‘Man, what happened?’ ” said the Steelers’ All Pro guard as the club prepared to start the second half of its season Sunday at Indianapolis. “It’s amazing how you just become accustomed to it somehow. You almost forget. There are some games you remember that are worse than others, but humans have an amazing ability to just move on, push it aside.
“I think a lot of us at this level don’t even feel the pain as much. We’re just kind of numb to it as this point.”
Maybe the audience has become just kind of numb to the suffering as well. Yeah, they knew the job was dangerous when they took it. Yeah, they have paychecks that can meet most definitions of obscenity. Yeah, injuries are part of the game, but is there a point out there in galaxy between football and its audience, a nexus much nearer than we think, where injuries are not just part of the game but just too much a part of the game?
The league’s week began in depressingly metronomic fashion with the big reveal — the full extent of the previous weekend’s carnage. Tampa Bay shut down marquee quarterback Jameis Winston due to a shoulder injury, then, Monday night, Green Bay Packers tackle Bryan Bulaga (perhaps you remember him mauling people the last time Pittsburgh visited the Super Bowl) tore the anterior cruciate ligament in his right knee, the 33rd torn ACL of an NFL season only half done.
“On grass, too, which is weird,” DeCastro sniffed. “Usually it’s on turf that happens.”
Read More
Knees again dominate the league’s destruction inventory. Of the approximately 300 players on injured lists throughout the NFL at the beginning of the week, 94 were there with damaged knees. Ankles are the next most vulnerable body part, followed by shoulders, feet, and hamstrings in that order. In the sprawling compilation maintained by CBS Sports, 63 players have injuries listed as undisclosed, so the actual anatomy standings may vary.
You can’t avoid contemplating a day when we’ll cross the line from where pain was part of the game to where pain is the game, or is that already in the rear view?
I didn’t put that question to Ben Roethlisberger; he just happened to be talking about it in the locker room the other day.
“I hate being asked about sacks and injuries,” the quarterback noted. “Hopefully we stay as injury-free as we can. Injuries are gonna happen, it’s just a matter of who, how significant, how serious, things like that. Typically the team that stays the healthiest usually can make a run in the playoffs.”
That can be verified with a new stat I just invented this week. You’ve heard of baseball’s OPS? Well, this is OFTS, an acronym for Out For The Season. At last check, 128 players were Out For The Season, even if Arizona Cardinals star running back David Johnson now says he hopes to return.
Teams with winning records to this point averaged 3.2 OFTS players so far, while teams with losing records averaged 4.69 OFTS. Seattle’s Super Bowl aspirations took a wallop Thursday night when standout defender Richard Sherman ruptured an Achilles tendon to become the Seahawks fourth player to go OFTS. That’s what Ben is saying, essentially, but what he’s not saying specifically is that “teams that can make a run,” tend to be the teams with the healthy quarterbacks, a requirement that has already eliminated 12 teams, nearly 40 percent of the league.
If the playoffs started today (we’ll all have missed Christmas, I know), 10 of the 12 teams would feature starting quarterbacks who were available for every game, and all would have had their primary passer available for at least six games.
The Steelers are 6-2 in no small part because Ben is one of them, and that they’ve faced a rookie quarterback, two back-ups, and this week at Indy, a backup’s backup. And no smaller part of their success stems from Baltimore’s AFC-leading OFTS number. The Ravens lost nine players for the season before the season even started. The official figure is eight, but that doesn’t count guard John Urschel, who retired July 28 because, as a doctoral candidate in applied mathematics, he figured his own capacious brain wasn’t worth the risk. Good for Pittsburgh, but bad for a league without megawatt stars Aaron Rodgers, Deshaun Watson, Carson Palmer, Andrew Luck, and prominent non-throwers like Sherman, Johnson, Odell Beckham, Julian Edelman, J.J. Watt, Greg Olsen, Tyler Eifert, Malik Hooker, Allen Robinson, Tamba Hali, Eric Berry, Dalvin Cook, Brandon Marshall, Darren Sproles, Joe Thomas and many more.
An expansive new addition to punditry has grown up around the ratings argument — NFL ratings are down an estimated 5 percent from last year and 15 percent from two years ago — without much of it fastening to injuries.
Who wants to devote three hours or more watching the junior varsity?
“You want to watch the stars, the best of the best,” said DeCastro. “No offense to the backups, obviously they’re still good. But there’s a reason those guys get paid what they do. They’re paid to entertain. That’s all we are, entertainers, let’s be honest with ourselves. If the entertainment is not there, why watch?
“You watch J.J. Watt go down, Aaron Rodgers; it’s a different game when you’re watching without Aaron Rodgers. It’s a matter of time before [as far as] quarterbacks [are concerned], it’s two-hand touch, in my opinion, or they’ll have some flags hanging by their side and you pull them off. When those guys get hurt, I mean how much money was lost in the ratings for that Monday Night game?”
But DeCastro’s got another big question too, big and probably pointless.
“What are ya gonna do though?”
Solutions aren’t hard to enumerate, but most of them have about as much chance of happening as a Browns-49ers Super Bowl.
Players aren’t going to get smaller and slower, and fields aren’t going to get larger, as much sense as that would make. We’re not going back to leather helmets and or helmets without facemasks. We only go forward, into biometric technologies employed by teams like the Steelers and Ravens that monitor every player’s every breath and movement to map out recovery time, capacity, etc. All of it’s wonderful, but just like in baseball, the more comprehensively players are trained and monitored, the longer the injury list seems to get.
The one aspect in which the NFL is at least ostensibly making strides is in legislating against unnecessary hits, but that’s pretty subjective.
“We have to do a better job; we have to have less cheap plays,” said Steelers tackle Marcus Gilbert, who returns Sunday having missed five of the last six games with a hamstring injury. “A lot of times it’s inattention, guys just running to the ball and somebody just gets rolled up on. But the cheap shots and the shoves — like the shove of [Cincinnati’s] A.J. Green by [Jacksonville’s Jalen Ramsey last Sunday], he could have gotten really hurt. I got pushed like in high school, hyper-extended my knee. Those are things we have to eliminate.”
There has to be a considerable mental weight on players in this setting, where any play, the next play, could put any of them in a situation like the one that faced Chicago Bears tight end Zach Miller Oct. 29. Landing awkwardly in the New Orleans end zone one minute, he was in a hospital the next, where vascular surgeons worked feverishly and successfully to save his leg.
“You can get a bad injury, like, ‘Oh man, I might be done,’” said Steelers tackle Chris Hubbard, who’s played most of this season in Gilbert’s spot. “I think about it like this, if it happens, it happens, you just have to be prepared to deal with it afterward. How quick can you get back? You have to look at the big picture, you know, things happen for a reason.”
I don’t know about that, but I’m pretty sure that when somebody lifts that Lombardi Trophy the night of Feb. 4, it will be as much about who didn’t play as about who did.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.