Steve: How would you grade the Steelers offseason A, B, or C via signings and free agency? Have they improved the team (on paper) going into the draft, or do you feel they missed opportunities that would have made them a better team at this point?

Ray Fittipaldo: Well, they missed out on the one player they tried to throw some big money toward. That was Patriots LB Dont’a Hightower. And they only went after him because Lawrence Timmons signed with the Dolphins. So I’d give them a B or a C. The four free agents they did sign are depth players. Kevin Colbert said Sunday none of the signings have altered their draft plans. So in the end they did what they usually do in free agency, and I’m OK with that approach because it’s been successful for them.

Steve: When fans “complain” about the way Steelers handle free agency/trades etc. it’s often met with a “be happy we aren’t the Bills” type response, or that they have won 6 Super Bowls, get over it…But truth is in the past 37 (27 since free agency began) years they have won 2 Super Bowls (within a 4 year time period) and lost two others. Good, yes, but is it at least valid to question whether you can be the VERY best yoy using the 70’s way of doing business?

Ray Fittipaldo: I guess I would counter with other than the Patriots who has a better record, including Super Bowl wins, over those 37 years? Off the top of my head I know the 49ers and Redskins won five and three Super Bowls apiece in that span, but both franchises have struggled in recent years. I don’t think there is anyone out there who wants Daniel Snyder over the Rooneys. I think the same can be said of the York family. Listen, all franchises go through good times and bad times. The Steelers have found ways to avoid bad times. They’re either in contention or mediocre. And they’ve been in contention for Super Bowls the past three years. They’ve just fallen short of their ultimate goal.

Advertise with us

Steve: Thoughts on whether Steelers should or could make a move to sign Bengals linebacker Rey Maualuga? Could add depth or, compete for starting position, thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don’t want players the Bengals discard. They tried to sign Dont’a Hightower but could not get it done. Colbert said Sunday they are fine with Vince Williams as their starter. He’s a guy who can bridge the gap between Timmons and the next impact ILB they find. He’s a solid guy in run defense. I don’t think they’ll attempt to use him much in pass defense, which is yet another reason why they’ll try to find some cover guys in the secondary next month in the draft.

Steve: Thoughts on Raiders Vegas move? I’d schedule trips around Steeler/Raider games….or any intriguing Raider home games. Love the idea, do you think it will work long term?

Ray Fittipaldo: I’m quite sure fans will love it in the short-term. Lots of people will book getaways around road games. As for it working long-term, the Raiders haven’t been long for any of their destinations in the past 40 years so I guess it’s wait and see.

Denny from LA: Any word on Martavis?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Martavis is still awaiting word from the commissioner.

Jim: after hearing tomlin’s quote yesterday about ben and future qb’s, would you be shocked if say, tribisky, watson, or kizer fell to them and they fell in love, would take one at 30?

Ray Fittipaldo: I can’t see them taking a QB in the first round. People read way too much into what Tomlin or Colbert say regarding Ben. He’s under contract for three more years and remains among the top 5-7 QBs in the NFL in my estimation. You don’t draft his replacement in the first or even second round when you’re so close to winning another Super Bowl. They should draft an OLB and a CB in the first two rounds and try to get their defense back to being championship caliber. That could help them win a championship next year. Drafting a QB in the first or second round does not.

Guest: If the Steelers are fortunate enough to have McKinley, Harris, Witt and Lawson available at pick 30, which one would they take?

Ray Fittipaldo: Which one would they take? I don’t have a crystal ball. But I watched all four of those players you named. I’ll give you my order:

Advertise with us

1. Charles Harris

2. Carl Lawson

3. T.J. Watt

4. Tak McKinley

JerseySteel: Will the Steelers perhaps draft another Inside LB by the 3rd round now that Timmons is in Miami?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: It’s possible. They do have four picks in the first three rounds. But this is not a great year for ILBs after the guys who are first-round prospects. And I don’t think they take an ILB in the first round. I can see them taking someone between rounds 3-7 to challenge Matakevich, Steven Johnson and LJ Fort for backup roles. And maybe that guy develops into a starter someday.

JerseySteel: Do you think that DeMarcus Ayers can make the team this year? Would they pair him with Kniles Davis on kickoff returns?

Ray Fittipaldo: Depends what happens in the draft. His chances decrease if they select a WR in the first four or five rounds. As for kickoff returns, they didn’t use him in that role last season when they were desperate for a player to return kicks. He’s more of a punt returner.

JerseySteel: What type of ceiling do you see for Tyler Matakevich? Strictly special teamer or solid backup LB?

Ray Fittipaldo: Solid backup and special teams player for now. He could end up being like Jerry Olsavsky. I don’t think anyone thought he’d be a future starter when they drafted him. He overcame the odds and became a starter on some very good teams. I’m not saying Matakevich will do that, but I have heard people make that comparison.

Advertise with us

Jasper: Hi Ray, The Steelers have done well building their O-Line and retaining the services of Mike Munchak. Can they keep this unit and coach together until the end of Ben R’s career?

Ray Fittipaldo: Sure. All of the starting offensive linemen are under team control for at least the next two seasons. And Munchak very much seems to like it in Pittsburgh.

JerseySteel: I love Charles Harris as an edge rusher. Lately though, I have seen a lot of mock drafts with him going to the Ravens at 16. Any chance he slips down to 30?

Ray Fittipaldo: I’ve seen him more in the late first round than middle of the first round. I think there is a chance he is there at No. 30 and I think he’d be a good option for the Steelers. He can rush the passer which is exactly what they need. Does he need work on his run defense? Yes. But they can work with him in that regard. You can’t teach the raw ability he has as a rusher.

John B.: Which linebacker do you consider the most important out of the four positions? Not knowing your answer, do you trust who we have at that position for a full year?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Well, with Timmons gone I would say Ryan Shazier is the most important LB right now. He is the quarterback of the defense, makes all the calls and is coming off his first Pro Bowl season. Having said that, this defense has been great wwhen they’ve had great OLBs. They haven’t quite had that since James Harrison and LaMarr Woodley were in their primes. That’s why I think they’ll use a first or second round pick on an OLB. They need to get back to their edge rushers harassing QBs.

JON: Ray,If you had to BET who is going to be the Steelers first round pick?

Ray Fittipaldo: Hmmm, still 32 days to go and lots can happen between now and then. I’ll say this: I’d be happy with Charles Harris or Carl Lawson if they are available at No. 30. I know Lawson isn’t mentioned as often in the first round as Harris, but he is a really good player who is a bit undervalued right now because of his injury history. I’d be OK with Taco Charlton too.

Bill Bonacelli: Will the Steelers draft at ILB, OLB or BLT first? Wilkens out of Oregon looks impressive at cornerback. Need a quarter pass rusher as well.

Ray Fittipaldo: I say OLB or CB.

Advertise with us

JamesinNYC: What are your top 2 corners that you could expect would be available to the Steelers in the draft?

Ray Fittipaldo: That’s hard to say because there are so many CBs mocked in the first round. Many of them won’t be there at No. 30. Injuries could push the top CBs even higher after Sidney Jones and Moreau had their setbacks at their pro days. I think Marlon Humphrey would be good for them at No. 30. I keep hearing good things about Awuzie from Colorado. He had been more of a second-round guy until recently. Maybe they grab him at No. 30. Whichever CB they draft I want him to be able to play well in man and zone schemes.

Antonio12: Shamarko and DeAngelo both definitely not coming back? Surprised due to DeAngelo doing well and now Karlos Williams released. Shamarko has ST elite value.

Ray Fittipaldo: I have news for you. Their special teams weren’t so special with Shamarko on them for the past four years. And you don’t re-sign players because they’re good on special teams. You can find good special teams players in your rookie class. As for DeAngelo, he is going to turn 34 in April. He missed six or seven games with a knee injury last season. They need a younger and a more durable player. DeAngelo was good in his role the past two seasons and but players break down when they get older. Why roll the dice on him again when there are so many good RBs in the draft this year?

big chuck: Did you get a feel on how the Steelers liked the Pitt QB Peterman? If someone like Kizer fell to them at 30, any chance they take him since LB, WR, TE, and CB are deep this year?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: As mentioned previously, I don’t see them taking a QB at No. 30. As for Peterman, they obviously watched him at Pitt’s pro day. All they had to do was walk across the parking lot. I don’t know that they like him especially if he’s going to go in the second or third round as some project. The Steelers are probably looking at getting one a little later than that.

Ron: Long time reader of your chats. If Carl Lawson, Charles Harris and TJ Watt are all still around at 30, which player do you think the Steelers would pick?

Ray Fittipaldo: That’s a good question. The Steelefrs have always valued OLBs who can defend the run in addition to rushing the passer. Right now, Lawson is the most accomplished run defender of those three. Harris is the best pass rusher and Watt is just a really good player with a high motor. My gut says they’d take Harris because of his pass rush ability, but Lawson has a lot of potential too.

Jeremiah: Come April’s draft, if McKinley, Harris, Reddick are all off the board by #30 and sitting there is Mike Williams, TJ Watt and Jabril Peppers, who would you take if you were in Colbert’s shoes? (Mike Williams?)

Ray Fittipaldo: Not enthralled with any of those three at No. 30, but I guess Watt in that scenario.

Advertise with us

Jerry: What do you think about DeMarcus Walker?

Ray Fittipaldo: I like him in the second round. He’d have to lose some weight to play OLB in the Steelers’ scheme. But that’s OK. Others have done it before him. He’s solid vs. the run and he was a productive pass rusher. My only concern is many of his best rushes came inside in FSU’s scheme. He wasn’t as effective when he played OLB. So when you take a guy that high you’d like to know exactly what you’re getting. But as is always the case with OLBs, you’re projecting. Kevin Colbert is very upfront about that.

STEELERSALLDAY23: Do you think if the steelers don’t make it to the super bowl tomlin needs to go or Butler?

Ray Fittipaldo: No. The defense has improved under Butler. It’s still not great, but it’s better.

JerseySteel: Are the Steelers concerned with ILB depth with Timmons gone, VW elevated from top backup to starter, and Shazier’s injury history?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: There is some reason for concern because of Shazier’s injury history. That’s why you could see an ILB in the middle rounds. Don’t be surprised if that happens.

Jeremiah: Any truth to the rumors that T Brady may be in trouble again for using “illegal” supplements according to the NFL’s banned substance list?

Ray Fittipaldo: Haven’t read about that.

Jasper: Good idea? Last round of the draft, Rico Dynamite at QB? Very overlooked and probably the most upside of any QB...

Ray Fittipaldo: I’d prefer Rico Suave.

Advertise with us

JerseySteel: Will the CB’s on the roster this year be named Burns, Golson, Sensabaugh, draft pick, draft pick?

Ray Fittipaldo: You forgot Cockrell. And while I like your idea of drafting two DBs, I’m not convinced there will be two CBs taken.

Mark: Any news/updates on Le’veon Bell’s groin surgery?

Ray Fittipaldo: No updates. He should be ready for the season.

JerseySteel: Has Ross Cockrell re-signed or still exploring his free agent options?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: He has a few more weeks to explore. And even if he does find a better deal the Steelers have the right to match it. If no suitors, he’ll be back.

Jasper: Rico Suave couldn’t throw a ball over a mountain....better dancer though....

Big D: Do you think the Steelers would draft Jabril Peppers if available? Imagine him and Shazier on the field together...Mike Mitchell will only play so long. Thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: But Mike Mitchell has two years left on a $25 million deal. Even if you decide to move on from Mitchell after this season don’t you want your first-round pick to be an impact player as a rookie? They’d have to get very creative to find a role for him with Mitchell and Sean Davis as the starting safeties.

BigDawg: Deja Vu All Over Again? ....1983 Steelers let Marino slip by because they thought an aging Bradshaw had a few years left. If one of those top rated QB’s fall to #30 - I think they should pull the trigger. Ben too injury prone and talking about retirement too much. What do you think?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Flawed premie, BigDawg. You’re comparing the 1983 QB draft class, widely regarded as the best ever, to this class that is said to be weak.

ShawnC: Best MLB since Lambert...Timmons or Farrior?

Ray Fittipaldo: I’ll take Farrior in his prime over Timmons in his prime, but Timmons was a very good player.

Ray Fittipaldo: Thanks for another great chat. We’ll do it again next Monday.