Quarterback
OK, Ben Roethlisberger threw 16 interceptions in 12 games, second most in his career, and played poorly in a near-costly loss in Baltimore. But don't forget the surprising development of Landry Jones and what he did off the bench against Arizona, leading four consecutive scoring drives. Or the last-minute heroics of Mike Vick in San Diego. Keep in mind, too, the injuries and concussion Roethlisberger had to deal with and still managing to put up the numbers he did against three of the best defenses in the league. This team won 11 games using three different quarterbacks. How many teams can say that?
Grade: A-
Running backs
When he filled in for Le'Veon Bell to start the season, DeAngelo Williams led the AFC in rushing with 204 yards after two games. When Bell returned and started the next six games, he became the AFC's leading rusher with 556 yards. After Bell had a season-ending knee injury, Williams stepped back in and finished as the fourth-leading rusher with 907 yards. And when Williams went down in the season finale, Fitzgerald Toussaint and Jordan Todman were the big surprises in the playoff win in Cincinnati. But that fumble in Denver ...
Grade: B+
Read More
Receivers
What can you say about a player who follows one of the greatest seasons by a wide receiver in NFL history with an even greater one? Antonio Brown finished with 136 catches, second most all time, and 1,834 receiving yards, fourth most all time, and was basically unstoppable on third down. Martavis Bryant showed he has the talent and big-play capability to be a dominating player, so long as he remains focused on his craft. Markus Wheaton had a monster game in Seattle, but disappeared too much in other games. They combined for more receptions of 40+ yards (19) than any team in the league.
Grade: A-
Offensive line
The impact Mike Munchak has had on the offensive line is not to be understated. David DeCastro has become an All-Pro guard, Marcus Gilbert has developed into maybe the best right tackle in the league and, despite all the moving parts at running back, the run game averaged 4.4 yards a pop, third best in the AFC. And that after losing All-Pro C Maurkice Pouncey in the preseason and LT Kelvin Beachum in Week 6. Cody Wallace and Alejandro Villanueva were beyond what the coaches expected as replacements. Stability helped too: Four of the five linemen started all 18 games, including postseason.
Grade: B
Defensive line
Keith Butler installed a different philosophy, switching from a reading two-gap style to a penetrating one-gap scheme, mainly to take advantage of the athleticism of Cam Heyward and Stephon Tuitt. And it had a big impact. Heyward (7) and Tuitt (6.5) led the team in sacks, combined for 21 QB pressures and helped improved a run defense that ranked fifth in the league, allowing only 91.2 yards per game. And only two teams allowed fewer rushing touchdowns than the Steelers (6). But depth was lacking, and there was a big drop off when Tuitt missed two games because of injury.
Grade: B
Linebackers
It wasn't until the postseason that the young linebackers started to make an impact, especially Ryan Shazier. When healthy, he can be as disruptive as anyone, witness what happened in Cincinnati. Jarvis Jones got better as the season wore on, but he needs to play more. Problem is, the coaches got more than they expected from James Harrison, who took too many snaps. Jones and rookie Bud Dupree didn't generate enough pressure off the edge after combining for only a half-sack in the last 10 games. Lawrence Timmons was slowed by a toe injury to start the season, but looked like his old self as the season wore on.
Grade: C+
Secondary
What the Steelers envisioned for their secondary before the season and what it became were too different things. Three players being counted on -- Cortez Allen (benched), Shamarko Thomas (benched) and rookie Senquez Golson (injured) — never really saw the field. And they were never completely comfortable with Brandon Boykin after trading a fifth-round pick to get him. Despite giving up more passing yards (4,350) than all but two teams, the Steelers had 17 interceptions, including seven inside their 8. And five of those were in the end zone, two by Mike Mitchell.
Grade: D+
Special teams
Four kickers since training camp is usually not a good recipe for success. The trade for Josh Scobee not only cost them a sixth-round draft choice, but it might also have cost them a division title because of the first Ravens game. But Chris Boswell came to the rescue, converting 36 of 39 field goals after he was signed, including 7 of 7 in the postseason. Jordan Berry had the NFL's longest punt (79 yards vs. Arizona), but was inconsistent on too many occasions. And, other than Antonio Brown's 71-yard TD punt return vs. Indianapolis, the longest return of any kind was 38 yards, and that by a player who was eventually waived.
Grade: C+
Coaching
Nit-pick all you want about Mike Tomlin's clock management and obsession with two-point conversions. His ability to get the players to buy into his "the standard is the standard" mantra is one of the main reasons for the resolve and resiliency they displayed in the face of all the injuries and suspensions. Keith Butler improved the speed and athleticism on defense to increase pressure and create turnovers, and it worked. An AFC-high 30 takeways resulted in 99 points. And Todd Haley still had the most explosive offense in the league despite starting three different QBs, three different RBs and losing two All-Pros.
Grade: B
Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com and Twitter @gerrydulac.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.