The on-field futility of the Cleveland Browns, who likely are headed for another season in which they’ve lost at least 11 games, can be linked to their poor performance with No. 1 draft picks.
Just in the past four years, the Browns have had seven No. 1 picks who have had little or no impact on their team. And that's having three picks in the top eight spots where teams have a better chance of landing an impact player.
It began in 2012 when the Browns took running back Trent Richardson with the third overall pick and quarterback Brandon Weeden at No. 22. The following year, they drafted pass-rushing outside linebacker Barkevious Mingo sixth overall. Richardson and Weeden are no longer with the team and Mingo, who has only four sacks in his past 35 games, is a backup.
It didn’t get much better in 2014. With a chance to take Sammy Watkins or any of the top receivers in the draft, the Browns traded the fourth overall pick and moved down four spots to draft cornerback Justin Gilbert. The decision to not draft a wide receiver, especially given the plight of suspended receiver Josh Gordon, seemed even more dubious when they drafted Johnny Manziel with the 22nd overall pick.
Manziel is the third quarterback the Browns have drafted on the first round in the past nine years. But they passed on Teddy Bridgewater (Minnesota) and Derek Carr (Oakland) to take Manziel.
The Browns are getting some mileage from their two No. 1 picks this year — both nose tackle Danny Shelton (12th overall) and center/guard Cam Erving (19th overall) are expected to start today against the Steelers — but their huge misses the previous three years have them on pace to lose 11 or more games for the seventh time in the past eight seasons.
Read More
The focal point of those failures is Manziel, who is expected to start against the Steelers because Josh McCown, who is 2-15 as a starter, has been out with a rib injury. Manziel has received more attention for his off-field issues than anything he has done on the field, but he is 1-1 as a starter this season (1-3 overall) and has made several plays when he is running around out of the pocket.
“The only difference is the play will never be over, because you know Johnny has the ability to get outside the pocket, scramble around and prolong the play for 8-10 seconds,” said tight end Gary Barnidge, who leads the Browns with 42 catches and six touchdowns, third most among NFL tight ends. “You never know. I think that’s the only difference.”
Manziel led the Browns on a 92-yard scoring drive at the end of the first half in last week's loss to the Cincinnati Bengals, culminating with a 12-yard touchdown pass to running back Duke Johnson in which Manziel did what he does best — scramble out of the pocket and throw on the run.
But the Bengals changed their defensive tactic in the second half, letting Manziel stay in the pocket and forcing him to read their coverages. Manziel was 4 of 15 for 40 yards with a passer rating of 39.6 in the second half.
“He’s comfortable doing that,” said inside linebacker Lawrence Timmons. “You start running sideways and he looks downfield and he throws the ball on a rope. He has a nice arm.”
“That’s his style,” said defensive end Cam Heyward. “You don’t want to see him on the end line trying to throw darts down the field. He did that at the end of first half against Cincinnati.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.