Mike Mitchell said he has always played the game with emotion. He said his favorite players growing up played that way, especially Ray Lewis. And he’s not about to change now, even if it means morphing mindlessly into a premature celebration after one of his bone-jarring hits caused a fumble against the Oakland Raiders.

Mitchell, a sixth-year free safety with the Steelers, wasn’t the only player guilty of celebrating a play that wasn’t over against the Raiders. Roosevelt Nix, a backup fullback, caused a fumble by Taiwan Jones with a big hit on a kick return and began celebrating while the ball was still live and uncovered on the field.

In each instance, the Steelers were fortunate to recover the fumble, even though the players who delivered the big hits — Mitchell and Nix — were busy celebrating their accomplishments.

“I’m not going to apologize for being emotional,” Mitchell said. “I feel like, as long as it’s channeled in the right way, it could be a thing that motivates you, gets you going, gets the team going. It gets the crowd energized. I can’t change. It’s just how I’ve always been taught.”

Advertise with us

Mitchell’s emotion has gotten the best of him the past two games, sometimes to the Steelers’ detriment.

Against the Cincinnati Bengals, following a third-down incompletion, he got in the face of receiver A.J. Green and was penalized 15 yards for taunting that kept the drive alive. Later, after he caused an incompletion with a big hit on receiver Marvin Jones, Mitchell ran halfway across the field, stopped in front of the Steelers bench and celebrated by pretending to shovel dirt, presumably like a grave-digger.

Mitchell was not penalized for that display, but it was so excessive that coach Mike Tomlin was asked about it two days later at his weekly news conference. For the record, Tomlin said he had no issue with Mitchell’s exuberance.

“I’ve never played the game flat,” Mitchell said. “I try to play it as emotionally as I can. As much time as I put into it, I’d be cheating myself if I didn’t play it emotionally.”

Then he added, “I don’t know what people want me to do — make a play that helps my team and do nothing? I don’t want to be lethargic out there. If I didn’t do anything, they’d say, ‘Oh man, he plays flat, he plays with no emotion.’ ”

Advertise with us

Not the first, not the last

There are those who would like to see Mitchell and other NFL players who overzealously celebrate what are sometimes ordinary plays curb their emotional displays. Especially when the play is not over.

For years, the NFL has tried to curb end-zone celebrations. Maybe they should try to reel in players who behave — according to some — selfishly and foolishly, sometimes to the detriment to the team.

“When you’re celebrating and trying to get into a celebration, when there’s ball on the ground and you’re not finishing, your focus is not on your job, it’s more about ‘me’ and how great you are,” said former Steelers running back Merril Hoge, an analyst for ESPN. “How many times do you see guys do those types of things, then the very next play someone goes 15 [yards] on them. I don’t see them take their thumb and point to their back then.”

Last year, Raiders linebacker Sio Moore sacked Kansas City quarterback Alex Smith on third down with a little more than 40 seconds left, then sprinted 20 yards downfield as though Oakland had just won the Super Bowl. While Moore was doing a choreographed handshake celebration with rookie linebacker Khalil Mack, Smith was getting ready to run one final play on fourth down.

Advertise with us

Defensive end Justin Tuck wisely called a timeout before Smith could snap the ball, saving the Raiders an embarrassing penalty. Tuck then chewed out Moore and Mack, right there on the field.

Remember what Steelers receiver Plaxico Burress did his rookie season in 2000?

After making a diving catch against Jacksonville, Burress got up and spiked the ball in celebration, forgetting that, unlike college, a player must be touched in the NFL before he is considered down. The Jaguars’ Danny Clark recovered the live ball and returned the fumble 44 yards.

In 2002, Cleveland linebacker Dwayne Rudd celebrated what he thought was a game-ending sack on Chiefs quarterback Trent Green by throwing his helmet in the air. But Rudd did not see Green flip the ball to tackle John Tait just before he was sacked. Tait ran 28 yards to the Browns 25 as time expired, but Rudd was penalized for his celebration and Morten Anderson kicked the winning field goal on the extra play.

Then there are the celebrations that really go wrong.

Advertise with us

Despite being blown out in a game last season by the New England Patriots, Chicago Bears defensive end Lamarr Houston celebrated a late-game sack by jumping in the air and landing awkwardly on his leg, tearing the anterior cruciate ligament in his knee.

Detroit Lions linebacker Stephon Tulloch did the same thing last season in a game against the Green Bay Packers, celebrating a big tackle by jumping in the air and doing the discount double-check landing. However, when he landed on both feet, Tulloch crumpled to the turf with a torn ACL.

In 2010, Miami Dolphins cornerback Vontae Davis injured his hamstring celebrating a fairly routine tackle after a 3-yard gain against the Minnesota Vikings.

“You got to play with emotion, you got to get excited,” Hoge said in a local radio interview last week. “But too many times, when you’re too focused on ‘‍let me point at my jersey,’ that irritates me more than anything. That doesn’t help the team. Do your job. Play within the course of the game. The all-about-me thing, I’d put an end to that so fast. If I were a coach, it’s the first thing I would address.”

All this even became too much for NBC announcer Bob Costas to bear.

Advertise with us

At halftime of the Steelers’ 2011 game at Kansas City, he went on a televised rant against the abundance of non-spontaneous celebrations, calling them, among other things, “calculated displays of obnoxious self-indulgence.”

Costas then posed this question:

“Where are the coaches in all this? Guys are routinely benched or called out for blown assignments. When is a coach going to make an overdue statement and sit a guy down on the grounds of pure selfishness and unprofessionalism detrimental to his team?”

Apparently, the answer is never.

When Tomlin was asked about Mitchell and Nix each turning their backs on a live ball after big hits, he simply said, “I would like them to be aware the ball is on the ground.”

Advertise with us

When asked if he says anything to the players to make them more aware of that, Tomlin said, “Yes — the ball is on the ground.”

“He doesn’t need to [tell us],” said defensive end Cam Heyward. “I think we should know that as players.

“I celebrate, but not to that extent. You got to understand, you got to wait until the whistle is blown. I’m all for celebrating and congratulating with your team, but we’ve got to be more self-aware and play to whistle.”

Outside linebacker James Harrison ranks eighth among active NFL players with 29 forced fumbles in his career. But for all his vicious, ball-jarring hits, Harrison is not the celebratory type. He has never turned his back to jump, kick, pose, dance or even high-five while the ball is still alive. Or, for that matter, after the whistle has blown.

Still, he didn’t seem to have a problem with what happened against the Raiders.

Advertise with us

“Some people like to celebrate, some people like to do what they do and keep it moving,” Harrison said. “I’m sure some people get out of hand with it, but that’s what they get fined for, I guess.”

A fine line

Joey Porter played with as much outward emotion as any Steelers player in recent memory. He was constantly trash-talking on the field and would celebrate sacks with his trademark kicking motion. After a game against the Baltimore Ravens at Heinz Field, he remained so enraged at Lewis that he went to the Ravens team bus and challenged Lewis to get off.

Even now as a linebackers coach, Porter is not about to tell Mitchell or any player not to play with emotion, even if it means the timing of one of their celebrations is ill-advised.

“You get caught in emotions sometimes and not knowing exactly what you did, and it happens,” said Porter, who forced 25 fumbles in his career. “If I make a play and I think he fumbled, my first thing is, I’m always trying to get the ball. Some guys might get a big hit and not know they did something. I can see how it easily happens, but it’s something you don’t want them to do. You want them to be more conscious of what they just did because turnovers are big in this game and you’ve got to get it.”

Advertise with us

Defensive coordinator Keith Butler said he talked to Mitchell about his premature celebration.

“There’s nothing wrong with having that type of emotion; what is wrong is you can’t miss a play because of that,” Butler said. “You can’t do that. We want him to get the fumble recoveries. It was a great hit. We want him to continue to do that. But you’ve got to be careful about celebrating too quick. He knows that.”

Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com and Twitter @gerrydulac.