Ed Bouchette: Good afternoon, let's begin

Comment From Dude_From_Cali: Do you agree with Butler being the right man or hire from outside?

Ed Bouchette: I believe Keith Butler was the right hire.

Comment From Bernard: This is the NFL, injuries happen, why did Tomlin not sign a RB soon after Blount was released? Starting Tate against the Ravens proved that Tomlin had no faith in Archer or Harris? There is no way that a new RB can become familiar with the offense in just a few days.

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Who would you have had them sign when they released Blount? Tate was not available because Minnesota claimed him off waivers and kept him until Dec. 23. They actually did sign one running back -- Josh Harris off their practice squad. They introduced Harris with the rest of the offensive starters for the playoff game against Baltimore, then started Tate, but Harris wound up with more carries.

Comment From joe canada: Hi Ed who do you suppose will coach the LB's now Butler is DC?

Ed Bouchette: I would think they would elevate Jerry Olsavsky, who has been a defensive assistant with them since 2010.

Comment From Guest 6Rings: Do you think the four DB's that start the 2015 season opener are currently on the roster?

Ed Bouchette: I would think at least one is because finding two new starters would be incredibly difficult for them.

Advertise with us

Comment From Scott from Erie: The argument against bringing back Harrison appears to revolve around the Steelers wanting to see what Jones can do. Why can't Jarvis start and James back him up as a situational pass rusher?

Ed Bouchette: I'm with you on that, especially with their depth issues. James forte, though, is not just rushing the passer, it's playing the run. It seems as though the wind is blowing the other way, but if it were me, I'd talk to him about coming in around the middle of camp to save his legs but get him up to speed.

Comment From Taz: Hi Ed! Was there any dissatisfaction that led to the dismissal of Dick LeBeau? Or was it exclusively the interest in giving Butler the opportunity to lead?

Ed Bouchette: No, there was no dissatisfaction with what he did, I just believe they wanted to move on and LeBeau wasn't ready to retire. So they came to a parting of the ways that was somewhat messy for a coach of his stature and his longevity here and how much he meant to the players and the organization.

Comment From mark

Advertise with us

I'm sure Keith Butler is a well deserving coach for the DC position, but without their top draft picks from the past few years playing up to expectations and as well as a few others (C. Allen, S. Thomas) and maybe some FA signings - not sure the Dee will peform much better. Your thoughts - thank you!

Ed Bouchette: I agree, but I also think the defense improved as the season moved along. And don't write off those top draft picks so quickly.

Comment From Bruce: Do you think the Steelers will draft a tight end early in this years draft? doesn't seam to be a lot of talent in that group this year.

Ed Bouchette: It's way too early to even think about what position they might draft early. I think they will draft a tight end somewhere, though. They also drafted one last year, Rob Blanchflower, who spent the season on their practice squad and has a chance.

Comment From CardinalRichlieu: What priorities do you see for the Steelers in the off season? Not just personnel but situations that need attention?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: They absolutely must find a way to get a better pass rush and, of course, cover with better DBs. I think their offense is OK, but they can improve that too with a tight end and backup RB. Defense should be their top priority

Comment From Thad: Please tell me this tampa-2 talk is much ado about nothing?

Ed Bouchette: I don't know who is talking about it other than jibber-jabber. If you mean a 4-3, I don't think they can do that because of their personnel. Remember that Chuck Noll also ran a Tampa 2 before there was a Tampa 2

Comment From Guest: After they sign Ben to a new contract, are they going to have trouble fitting Brown and Bell under the cap when its time for their new contracts?

Ed Bouchette: That is a story for another year, not this one.

Advertise with us

Comment From joe canada: Will RB be a top 3 draft priority, or will they get one via FA as a backup to Bell?

Ed Bouchette: With Le'Veon Bell, RB may be a bottom 3 draft priority.

Comment From Marcus: Can you tell us about Butler's defensive school? I mean, is a 3-4 guy, 4-3, tampa 2, etc?

Ed Bouchette: For most of his career, he has been a 3-4 guy -- because he's coached that defense for the past 12 seasons with the Steelers.

Comment From Willy: So HOF coach out, lifelong assistant in...how do you feel about this change, ed?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: It was inevitable sooner or later and they made it later.

Comment From Francis: Hi Ed, love the chat! Question is about Tomlin/LeBeau relationship - Tomlin being a former d coordinator, do you think this move had anything to do with ego?

Ed Bouchette: If that were the case, the parting would have happened years ago

Comment From EC: Ed: Would you liken the Lebeau/Butler scenario similar to Erhardt/Gailey deal under Cowher??

Ed Bouchette: Yes, that is a good example, except that the late, great Ron Erhardt had told them he would retire after the 1995 season and when that year came, he wanted to come back but they already had Chan Gailey in place to take over.

Advertise with us

Comment From Guest: Does EVERY coach on the Steelers staff go to the Senior Bowl to scout? Like does Joey Porter go?

Ed Bouchette: Yes, they pretty much all go, as do their scouts.

Comment From Jeff: Ed how much better do you see the offense & defense having to be to come close to duplicating the same amount of success next year as we experienced this year?

Ed Bouchette: They will have to improve because their schedule just got a whole lot better for 2015.

Comment From EC: Know it's old news but didn't Gradkowski w/beard in Ravens game, remind you of T. Hanratty??

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: That thought never crossed my mind

Comment From Guest: Any idea what kind of changes/differences in philosophy we might see under Keith Butler?

Ed Bouchette: I don't, but you will see some differences. it will always depend on personnel but I could see more aggressiveness from Keith

Comment From Scott from Erie: Ed, please tell us why we should be excited about Butler’s promotion to defensive coordinator. He’s not exactly a fresh perspective for this defense.

Ed Bouchette: How do you know he won't be a fresh perspective? He will be his own man and will implement his own ideas. Just because you get someone from outside does not make things automatically better. The grass ain't always greener.

Advertise with us

Comment From VA Steeler Fan: Hello Ed, thanks for your time. There has been some marked improvement in Kelvin Beachum. Do you think he has earned the status as the starter going forward at tackle? Or just a stop gap guy?

Ed Bouchette: If you believe in the ratings at Pro Football Focus, Beachum was their top-rated offensive lineman. He's a little like James Harrison in that he was not highly regarded because he was too small, yet his work ethic and his ability to use technique have helped turn him into a decent left tackle. I think he'll only get better.

Comment From LeoFromLebo: Ed, do you foresee any compensatory draft picks headed Pittsburgh’s way? I can’t think of why they would get any this year.

Ed Bouchette: The Steelers do not expect much either. Maybe they'll get a late-rounder. Remember, while they lost players such as Sanders, Cotchery and Ziggy Hood, they signed Mike Mitchell, Brice McCain and Cam Thomas. Woodley and Lance Moore do not count because they were released and not true UFA.

Comment From Taz: Hi Ed. You've mentioned the Steelers are once again pretty tight against the cap. But given that they'll be working off of a fresh QB contract (as you noted in your slog), won't the 2015 season represent the most cap freedom the Steelers have had in about a decade?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: It depends on how you see it. Do you see it with Jason Worilds or without him? He will count big against their cap if he returns, but without him you better find another OLB. Brice McCain is up. They also would like to sign Kelvin Beachum to an extension. They might save a little room on a Cam Heyward extension.

Comment From JamesinNYC: Do you think the change was more to keep Butler, say goodbye to LeBeau or convenient time to do both?

Ed Bouchette: I believe a little of both

Comment From Guest: Hello, Mr. Bouchette!

Ed Bouchette: Hello, Talking Car (that is for the benefit of all those seniors out there who can remember a commercial Franco Harris did on TV in his rookie season)

Advertise with us

Comment From Tony: Why wouldn't they want Keisel back assuming he can recover from his injury? It looked to me like he can still play. Couldn't he at least be a depth guy?

Ed Bouchette: They have their starters in Cam Heyward and Stephon Tuitt. I just don't think he will be invited to return for one more year.

Comment From Scott from Erie: Already starting to see some low-profile re-signings...when do you expect we will see some cap-saving cuts?

Ed Bouchette: Unless they opt to retire, I think you may have to wait a bit for some of the veteran releases. Ike Taylor and James Harrison are not under contract for 2015

Comment From Clem: Even though he was cleared, do you think Ben was seeing birdies? That was an awful decision and throw into the end zone for his second pick.

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: I have no idea, but I trust they would not have put him back in there if they thought he was the least bit concussed or woozy. It would serve no purpose to have a QB out there who was not thinking clearly.

Comment From RIP Chief: Any chance Steelers make a serious play to sign Justin Houston? I know KC will fight hard to keep him but shouldn't prevent them from trying. Either way, think they should part ways with Worilds.

Ed Bouchette: That is not their style and I don't think they will or can pay the kind of money he will command.

Comment From Guest: Ed, do you vote for All Pro? Did you ever?

Ed Bouchette: I used to vote for All-Pro, which is the AP team. I opted out a few years ago when they decided to hold a re-vote on the rookie defensive player of the year. It is my understanding that of the 50 voters on their list, not one works in Pittsburgh.

Advertise with us

Comment From Mr Mike: It's been reported (not by you) that if Arizona signs LeBeau, he wouldn't be the DC...even if Bowles leaves. Any thoughts on what his role would be?

Ed Bouchette: not really

Comment From dave: Were you surprised they signed Haley to a new contract?

Ed Bouchette: No, he has done a good job here.

Comment From Mel: Tight End is a must for the Steelers for the offense to evolve. I see them taking one pretty early in the draft. The Steeler Nation will lose their minds if that happens.

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: It looks as though there will be some good ones in free agency

Comment From dave: What are the chances they use the transition tag on Worilds again this year?

Ed Bouchette: I don't think they can or want to take that $10 million hit again.

Ed Bouchette: I believe they are set there with Steve McLendon and backup big Dan McCullers

Comment From Mel: DO you feel the Steelers need a NT or are they set there?

Ed Bouchette: answer before the question there.

Comment From mike: do you think the patriots were cheating v. baltimore or just proving why they have the best coach in the game?

Ed Bouchette: They did not cheat, they came up with a unique offensive formation that was legal. I remember when Sam Wyche was running the no-huddle offense in Cincinnati and everyone complained about it because it did not give defenses the time to react. It was perfectly legal, although it led to the current rule that the defense has to have time to react if the offense sends in substitutes, which wasn't the case back then.

Comment From Yo: Ed, I love reading PG articles on the Steelers but now begins a period of reduced content in the offseason. Any chance you and Gerry and Ray F. could do a lengthy series of articles starting now and leading to the draft on prospects, mock drafts, etc.? Thanks in advance!

Ed Bouchette: We will try to keep busy.

Comment From Scott from Erie: You said Woodley AND Lance Moore were released?

Ed Bouchette: Yes, Woodley by the Steelers and Moore by the Saints last year. So neither count in the equation when they figure out who gets those extra draft picks as compensation for losing free agents.

Comment From Tim: I'm confused - they're up against the cap once again?! Ike/Troy/Woodley/Worldis all gone - I know they signed Pouncey big but come on, when do they get out of this salary cap pinch??

Ed Bouchette: Woodley will count more than $8 million against their cap this year because they released him in June last year, to start.

Comment From Arthur: Ed, I read your slog but how can they still be up against the cap? all of those huge defensive contracts are gone

Ed Bouchette: Have you seen Lawrence Timmons' contract -- No. 2 after Ben on the list. Antonio Brown carries a big number too.

Comment From ADL: Wheaton the #2 next season or has Bryant surpassed him.

Ed Bouchette: I think that will be determined next season, but in an ideal world, Wheaton would play in the slot and Martavis Bryant on the outside.

Comment From Rustin Cohle: Any insight as to why Mr LeBeau wants to keep working? Just pure love of the game?

Ed Bouchette: That is part of it. Like Jerry Brown wants to keep working as Gov. of California at 76. If you enjoy what you're doing and want to keep doing it, you do, unless no one wants you. I'm sure someone will want LeBeau, it will be a matter, like he told me and Gerry, "where.''

Comment From Renegade: Do you see any chance the Steelers make a play for home town kid Revis?

Ed Bouchette: no

Ed Bouchette: Thank you for an extended chat today. See you next Tuesday