Today’s poll question: What is the biggest task for the next Steelers defensive coordinator?
Fixing a pass defense that ranked 27th in the NFL ( 36% )
Fixing a pass rush that ranked 26th in the NFL ( 61% )
Waiting on front office to supply better players ( 3% )
Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my weekly Steelers chat. Post your questions and we'll get it going soon.
Comment From DNY
Read More
Does LeBeau's departure reduce the chances of James Harrison's return from slim to none?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm not sure what the chances were before LeBeau's departure to be honest with you. Harrison, who will turn 37 this spring, came out of retirement to play at a high level this season. He said his body felt better than he expected. He left the door open for a return. However, the only way I see him coming back is in a similar fashion to last season -- if there is a need late in training camp or early in the season. They brought him back this season because of the injury to Jarvis Jones. Otherwise, he never comes out of retirement.
Comment From Troy B
Is Butler a lock to be the next D coordinator? If so, will he run the same type of scheme as LeBeau?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know if Butler is a lock, but he has stayed in the past because the Steelers have told him he would be the next coordinator. The Steelers blocked him from interviewing with other teams when he was under contract. Butler is no longer under contract. I think that had something to do with the departure. If he is the next coordinator I would expect many things to remain the same. I also would expect him to put his own stamp on the defense. Every coach has their own ideas and this will be his first chance to put his own personal stamp on a defense if he is the guy.
Comment From Brett
Do you find the switching to 4-3 cover 2 rumors credible?
Ray Fittipaldo: Tomlin has a background in the Tampa 2 from when he was an assistant with the Bucs. I am sure he has some ideas on how to tweak this defense and it might include some influences from his days in Tampa. However, a full-fledged move to a 4-3 probably is not in the works now. They have personnel suited for the 3-4. Tomlin has been on record saying he likes the 3-4 when it comes to defending multi-faceted QBs. I can see the new coordinator implementing some different schemes to compliment the old 3-4, but I don't see a complete move to a 4-3 at this time.
Comment From Kris
Is this the yr Jerome Bettis gets in the HOF? A loaded class again he goes up against, but he has been knocking on door for a while
Ray Fittipaldo: I believe Bettis is Hall worthy. He came to define the big back of his era. He churned out the yardage and didn't fumble very often. He was a workhorse, too. But there are some writers out there who are not behind his candidacy. Some are in the corner of Terrell Davis, who played for a shorter period of time but produced better numbers over that time period. Bettis, meanwhile, produced strong numbers over a long career. I feel like Bettis should go in first, but I'm not going to predict that will happen because I know he is up against some other worthy players, too. The Hall takes only a limited number of players every year.
Comment From Dave
Any chance they make a move for someone like nick fairley or Justin Houston if they clear up some cap room with extensions and possibly let worlids go?
Ray Fittipaldo: If you thought Worilds was making a lot of $ this season wait til you see what Justin Houston will be asking for in free agency. He'll make that $9.87 transition tag seem small. The Steelers spend to the cap every year and there won't be a lot of $ to pay free agents even if Polmalu retires and Worilds signs with another team. They have their own players to pay, starting with Ben Roethlisberger. After that, they'll probably try to do Cam Hewayrd and Kelvin Beachum if they can.
Comment From ColdInChicago
Hi Ray, first off, I cant believe how many questions you are getting on whether the Steelers will go to a 4-3 now. Like you know the answer to this one day after their D coordinator resigns. Anyways, my question is do you think this was the right time to let coach Lebeau leave? It had to happen some time and change can be good. Coach Lebeau is an all time great, but for a younger guy like myself, sometimes the older fellows need to give way to the young. Dick is 77 years old and should think about retirement, not his next job. Thanks Ray you do a great job.
Ray Fittipaldo: Plus, with players like Troy Polamalu, Brett Keisel, James Harrison and Ike Taylor likely not returning, it might have seemed like the right time to bring in a new voice. There will be younger players in a new roles next season. It will give the new coordinator a chance to start fresh.
Comment From Guest
Will Defense coordinator change likely result in position coach changes on defense?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm not sure about that. Everyone on the defensive staff has close ties to LeBeau. John Mitchell has been with him for more than a decade, the same as Keith Butler. Carnell Lake played for him and then coached under him. The same goes for Jerry Olsavsky and Joey Porter. I think there will be continuity, but I could see some change on the staff, too.
Comment From JamesinNYC
Do you believe that Coach LeBeau had a hard time with the change of free agency limiting the time from draft to true UFA?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think every team struggles with that, James. I wrote a story last spring in the lead-up to the draft on that subject and how hard it is for GMs to evaluate players who only play a year or two before they become UFAs. We saw it with Keenan Lewis. He did not start until his fourth season and then hit it big in free agency. We saw it with Cortez Allen. The Steelers tried to lock him up before his fourth season because they thought the same thing might happen. LeBeau certainly liked veterans over younger players because they knew the ins and outs of his defense. Maybe this is another sign that things are changing in the way they operate. They played Jarvis Jones a lot as a rookie. Same with Ryan Shazier and Stephon Tuitt this season. It took Cam Heyward 2 1/2 seasons to become a starter. It only took Tuitt 12 games. Art Rooney has been on record saying he'd like to see progress from younger players earlier in their careers. I would imagine the next coordinator will have to work with the front office on this subject.
Comment From steelmann58
Ray Will Coach Butler defense be a little Easier for Rookies to get on the field quicker than in the past?
Ray Fittipaldo: Jerry O has been on the staff longer than Porter, who just came on this season.
Comment From Guest
If Butler moves up to DC, does that leave Joey Porter to move to LB coach
Ray Fittipaldo: Sorry, question to previous answer.
Comment From Go Steelers!
Ray, If the idea was to get some fresh ideas on defense wouldn't hiring Butler be counter productive?
Ray Fittipaldo: You are assuming he is a carbon copy of Dick LeBeau. That is not fair.
Comment From dylan
Why do you think they neglected shamarko for another season? I mean, he stands out enough on ST to at least earn some sufficient reps one would think. He couldn't be much worse than how palomalu played late in the season. I think It's a little ridiculous to wait 3 years to even see what the kids got.
Ray Fittipaldo: This ties into the questions from James and Steelmann58. Thomas barely played at all on defense this season. LeBeau went with 10-year vet Will Allen instead. Maybe Thomas wasn't ready to play. Or maybe it just took that long for younger players to get a complete feel for the defense.
Comment From Guest
Does Moats have the ability to be a solid starter at OLB? In his opportunities he was good this season.
Ray Fittipaldo: Moats was good in spot duty this season, but I don't think they view him as a starter. He is a nice depth player and it would make sense for them to try to re-sign him in the same capacity.
Comment From TDS
Do you think this defense has the talent to be good again in the next 2 years?
Ray Fittipaldo: All depends on what comes in the draft, right? Is there an impact defender at No. 22 this year. Probably not. So I guess I'm interested to see how the next coordinator changes things up with what figures to be a similar roster.
Comment From James
Ray seems to me that a "real" DT like Hampton was is the main thing missing from making defense better. Shouldn't that be priority 1 with CB 2nd fill in draft?? Thanks
Ray Fittipaldo: I thought Steve McLendon played really well this season and that was with a bum shoulder. And you don't draft a nose guard high in the draft anymore because they only play 35-40 percent of the snaps in a game. Plus, McCullers has some potential. Plenty of other positions to address like OLB and TE.
Comment From Tommy Tuna
Are you aware of any area where Lebeau and Butler differ in philosophy? I’m curious as to whether they will run the identical defense or if Butler will add some wrinkles if he does indeed get the job.
Ray Fittipaldo: I am quite sure he has his own ideas. Every coach does.
Comment From Troy B
Any news on a possible Roethlisberger extension and if so, would he sign a cap friendly deal similar to Brady?
Ray Fittipaldo: No news on that yet, but I think $20 million a year is the starting point based on the other QB contracts signed by less accomplished QBs in recent years. As for signing a team-friendly deal, that's up to the individual, but I wouldn't expect a hometown discount. It would be nice for the Steelers, but I would not count on that happening.
Comment From Ryan
Do you see Justin Brown coming back?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't. I think they signed two WRs to futures contracts in the past week. Brown was not one of them.
Comment From Guest
Seemed like Tomlin was mostly "hands off" on the defense with LeBeau. Assuming Tomlin will have more input moving forward with his background as DB coach?
Ray Fittipaldo: Gerry Dulac reported he had more input this season.
Ray Fittipaldo: I am sure they will do their due diligence. If someone is a better hire than Butler then I would assume they would hire him. I just think Butler has been their guy in waiting for years and he deserves an opportunity to a run a defense on his own.
Comment From Tship
Hi Ray and thanks for your time. I think Coach LeBeau was handicapped by the lack of talent but also that things got stale. That being said how tempting is it fo rhtem to go outside the organization for a fresh view?
Ray Fittipaldo: Answer to above question.
Comment From JimmyJohnson
Hi, Ray. What are the chances the Steelers go outside to find talent like Farrior to fill in the holes at OLB?
Ray Fittipaldo: It's possible, but the advantage the Steelers had then was not many teams ran the 3-4 and Farrior was not in demand the way other LBs are in this era.
Comment From Guest
How long do you think the Ben extension will be? Do we need to draft a mid-round development QB soon?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't see any reason Ben cannot play until he is 37. That would be a five-year deal. And no, I don't think there is a need to draft a QB. You can do that in 2017 or 18.
Comment From steelmann58
Ray any chance that Colbert goes after a top Fa at either CB,OLB or S. Instead of waiting to sign Bargain guys like he missed on last season
Ray Fittipaldo: Once again, there won't be a lot of cash for Colbert to spend in free agency.
Comment From Guest
Why not bring Harrison back at 37 he is better than what they have..
Ray Fittipaldo: Because you invested a first-round draft pick in Jarvis Jones and it's time to find out about him.
Comment From Guest
What round do you think we draft a TE, if we do?
Ray Fittipaldo: If you want to find Heath Miller's replacement or a pass-catching tight end to complement him, you probably have to take one in the first three rounds. The best ones go in the first or second round.
Comment From Steve
Would love to see Steelers sign Bills D Coordinator, he can't be too happy with being passed over or the Head Coach position. Thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: Jim Schwarz runs a 4-3, I believe. That's what he ran in Detroit and Buffalo. I don't see that happening.
Comment From tommy
From what I'm hearing the defense isn't going to change much is Butler gets the job, but Mike Tomlin asking added back in March he wants this defense to be more multiple. Meaning some 4-3 packages and like your story today, elephant and leo players. I know I'll sound like a broken record here, but is there any chance they maybe convert shazier to saftey even for sub package like fun plays or something?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know about that. I acknowledge he is a different type of linebacker, one of the fastest in the NFL. And I acknowledge they are deep at ILB. However, asking Shazier to learn a new position might not be fair to him and might be asking a lot.
Comment From Guest
Why don't the steelers ever have a good #2 RB on the roster?
Ray Fittipaldo: They did this season. It just turned out he wasn't a good teammate so they had to release him. I am sure that will be on their to-do list this offseason because Le'Veon Bell will be suspended for two games next season.
Comment From Guest
how does Howard Jones look? has he been able to add some bulk to his frame?
Ray Fittipaldo: They liked him enough to sign him to a futures contract and there is an obvious need at his position. But he has to prove he can play in the NFL. All he did last season was prove he can make a practice squad. There is a big difference.
Comment From steelmann58
Ray the best way to rebuild the Defense OLB and secondary is both through Fa and the Draft Agree?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, I think so. You need some young blood in that room but you can't rely solely on rookies. You might have to sign someone to fill a place on the roster.
Comment From mrkellyquenton52
Is Todd Haley Oc getting fired
Ray Fittipaldo: Ed reported last week he got a contract extension thru 2017.
Comment From BIFF
I understand the rule regarding maintaining possession in regards to the Dez Bryant play. However after watching in slow motion it appeared that Bryant kept his hand between the ground and the ball and as his hand with the ball bounced up the ball became loose. He then snagged it to his chest. In other words he juggled it but still made the catch and the possession rule does not apply. Your thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: I hate the rule. Does anyone remember a play similar in the 2008 AFC championship game? Santoinio Holmes had a catch that was disallowed and the Steelers had to kick a field goal instead of scoring a touchdown. It's not the referee's fault. He's calling it by the letter of the law. The NFL has had plenty of opportunities to change the rule. The Calvin Johnson play happened in 2010. That's four offseasons that went by without a chance. Maybe it takes a playoff game for a new rule.
Comment From Jack Splat
Does not matter who the DC is - Steelers need to prerssure and sack the QB much more often than they have. They need that "edge rusher" even more than CBs.
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree, but some new blood at CB would not hurt.
Comment From Go Steelers!
Tomlin singled Mitchell out for praise, am I missing something? He took bad angles at the start of the season and missed tackles and was still doing it in the playoff game. That would seem to be an instinct thing and not likely to improve. Also I don't recall him making any impact plays, except big penalties.
Ray Fittipaldo: You coach different players different ways. Some guys need a kick in the butt, other need praised. Maybe Mitchell is a guy who needs positive reinforcement to be reached. But there is no mistaking he did not have a good first year, that's for sure.
Comment From Guest
Do you think the drafting strategy will change on defense? Will they draft secondary players early and try to duplicate Seattle's style with fast ball hawking DB's?
Ray Fittipaldo: They didn't do that last year after Seattle won the Super Bowl. They waited until the fifth round to draft Shaq Richardson and then released him from their practice squad early in the season.
Comment From New Castle Vinnie
Now that the majority of the 2008 defense are gone do you think that group will ever get credit as being one of the best defenses EVER? They seldom are mentioned among the greats and their numbers are as good or better than the 85 Bears, 2000 Ravens etc
Ray Fittipaldo: It was a tremendous defense and yes it should at least be in the conversation.
Comment From Todd
Do you foresee any changes to the O-line for next year? RT really struggles at times.
Ray Fittipaldo: That RT (Marcus Gilbert) was signed to a five-year contract before the season. He is not going anywhere. I would not expect any changes. All five starters are under contract next season. They could draft for depth or an eventual replacement for Beachum or Foster if they are not signed to long-term deals. But I don't think they have designs on drafting someone to come in and start next season.
Comment From Mike in Wisconsin
Ray, what happened to Justin Brown that the Steelers chose to not sign him back to a futures contract? I know his year didn't end up going the way he or the Steelers hoped but the kid showed some skills in pre-season and showed good blocking skills and caught a few passes in his limited opportunities. Despite his fumble, wouldn't it have made sense to bring back a receiver who was in the system and continue to see if he could grow?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm not really sure, honestly. Sometimes, the reality of professional sports is cruel. He had his chance early in the season, did not make the most of it, fell out of favor and now he's looking for a job. It's a tough business.
Comment From Dave
Am I the only one that thinks we need to improve our NT situation....I said this last lt year and it seems to be an overlook position. I know they don't run base 3-4 all the time but McClendon isn't getting the job done and I think that's why it hasn't been the same defense since Hampton retired
Ray Fittipaldo: He's getting the job done just fine.
Comment From BIFF
Assuming all the candidates for D-coordinator are qualified when being interviewed my number one question would be: "What is your plan to incorporate new draftees into the defense as soon as possible?" Legitimate question?
Ray Fittipaldo: It's not my No. 1 question, but I'm sure it's something that is broached.
Ray Fittipaldo: William Gay, Mike Mitchell, Shamarko Thomas and... Cortez Allen. I'm fairly confident in the first three, not so much on Allen. He is due a $3 million roster bonus in March. They must make a decision on him.
Comment From Guest 6Rings
How many of the four starting DB's that open the 2015 season are currently on the roster? For extra credit, name them!
Ray Fittipaldo: Question to above answer
Comment From Todd
Do you think they regret taking shazier over mosely the Ravens ilb?
Ray Fittipaldo: Too early to say that. Mosley had a great rookie season, but Shazier was injured for much of his.
Comment From ColdInChicago
Ray, how many questions do you think you will field this off season on whether the Steelers will sign a high profile free agent? Can you give me an over/under number? Thanks
Ray Fittipaldo: 3 or 4 a chat times three months til the draft equals 64?
Comment From Marc
Ray, can the steelers cut C. Allen without a big cap hit or are they stuck with him?
Ray Fittipaldo: It's not a huge cap hit if they cut ties with him.
Comment From Jack Splat
For Archer to make sense for the Steelers, he needs to return punts and kick offs - well. Do the Steelers realistically see that happening in 2015?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know. Those are not usually positions you have to learn so to speak. Either you can do it or you can't.
Comment From Jack Splat
I assume Bell will be suspended for the first 2 games? Presume NFL announces that at start of the NFL year in March.
Ray Fittipaldo: Not sure of the timing but it's pretty clear he will miss two games.
Comment From JamesinNYC
It is a darn good thing that the offensive side of the ball is stable...other than TE medium term. Would you see 2/3 of the draft going to the D side of the ball? Would be a bit of break from the norm.
Ray Fittipaldo: I would see that happening, but as I noted earlier Foster and Beachum are entering the final years of their contracts. If they don;t retain Moore then maybe a WR is a late-round possibility. But I would not be surprised at all if they go for a defender in the first round again. That would be three years in a row.
Comment From Jim Carbondale PA
I thought Big Dan showed that he can move the pile in the Ravens Game and can be very stout against the run and disrupt the back field. What say you?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think there is some potential there, but honestly he didn't play enough snaps for me to make a complete evaluation. I'm sure it's the same way for the coaches.
Comment From Guest
Ray, The steelers run defense was shaky at best. Isn"t the NT a big part of that to free up LB's to make tackles.McClendon is subpar in that regard. Agree?
Ray Fittipaldo: The run defense wasn't the biggest problem this season. It actually improved. The problem was the pass defense.
Comment From Justin
Do you see the Steelers bringing in a veteran RB like they did with Blount last offseason or do you think they one?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think they draft one and try to develop him throughout the spring and summer.
Comment From Renegade
Ray 35-40% of snaps is not insignificant when you consider the importance of those snaps for a NT - stopping the run on 1st and 2nd down. The value Ngata gives Baltimore is significant.
Ray Fittipaldo: Or maybe the Steelers should have done what the Patriots did and throw 50 times on a terrible secondary.
Comment From SteelByDesign
Ray, give me the odds that the next DC isn't Keith Butler.
Ray Fittipaldo: I'll say 80-20.
Ray Fittipaldo: That's it for this week. We'll do it again next week at the same time. Thanks for all the great questions.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.