Not often does a loss validate an organization's direction, especially when it falls in line with a mind-numbing, soul-crushing procession of 10 consecutive defeats to start seasons.

But this one warrants some acknowledgement of sensible choices made, starting with Brian Hoyer behind center.

Hoyer's orchestration of the no-huddle offense against a team and in a place that haunts Browns fans in their nightmares brought Team Possum all the way back from a 27-3 halftime deficit to dead even (27-27) with 11:20 remaining.

Hoyer's 9-yard rollout strike to Travis Benjamin was his best throw of the day, certainly since his 47-yarder to Jordan Cameron early.

Advertise with us

His fist bump and quick look at the Steelers sideline was born of the same competitiveness that led him to address his team at halftime.

"I wasn't the only one who talked," Hoyer said. "I don't want to make it sound like that. Joe [Thomas], Donte [Whitner], Karlos [Dansby], they made sure we kept fighting. I just said, 'We're all we have in this locker room. Are we going to lay down?' "

Hoyer and coach Mike Pettine sounded the same theme after the Steelers wriggled away on a 41-yard field goal as time expired for a 30-27 win.

"I'd rather pull negatives from a win than positives from a loss," Pettine said.

So a loss is a loss -- unless it supports the general manager's claim that the wide receiver position is not a full-blown construction zone without Josh Gordon; unless it reveals youth and power at running back behind starter Ben Tate; and, most importantly, unless it validates a new coach's decision to go with a career backup quarterback over a dynamic first-round draft pick.

Advertise with us

Asked if he considered using Johnny Manziel Sunday, Pettine curtly said, "No."

Moving on ...

Actually, moving on is one of the benefits of what happened Sunday. It moved the conversation past which quarterback should start against New Orleans and Drew Brees. My guess is that was happening at halftime in many northeast Ohio living rooms and bars.

Hoyer made mistakes. On a third-and-1 at the Steelers 5 late in the third quarter, he took the snap and was tackled for a 2-yard loss.

"We have two plays like that," Hoyer said. "I thought it was the other one. That's all on me and I have to get that down and get it right. That could have been a four-point swing."

Advertise with us

What he did, overall, is silence the call for Manziel. That's a plus for an offense that looked like a bunch of strangers standing around a bus stop for most of the preseason.

If anyone needed the second half more than Pettine -- his Browns looked embarrassingly unprepared -- it was probably Hoyer after an uninspiring camp.

He was 15 for 20 for 173 yards after halftime. Six Browns caught passes longer than 10 yards, three for at least 20 yards.

Next, the Browns must show more efficiency in their traditional offense. They can't run no-huddle primarily, let alone exclusively.

"Or our linemen will lose 30 pounds," Hoyer said.

Advertise with us

But you like their chances of running it more efficiently with him, rather than Manziel. That's a rookie quarterback thing, not a Manziel thing.

"He made some big plays for us, but there were a couple that he left out there," Pettine said of Hoyer.

The Steelers won in part because Ben Roethlisberger changed the pass play that led to the winning field goal with five seconds remaining on the play clock. The route to Markus Wheaton wasn't the original call.

In Hoyer's version of crunch time on the previous possession, he didn't get the entire play call after being sacked at his 14 with 1:53 remaining. The Browns didn't run another play -- an incompletion intended for Andrew Hawkins -- until 45 seconds later.

"The mic cuts out with 15 seconds left," Hoyer said. "I got the formation and protection, but couldn't hear the route. ... Kind of a messed-up situation."

Advertise with us

Hoyer didn't want to waste a timeout. He ended up wasting a play.

The Browns messed up enough to lose, but at least salvaged something.

Hoyer did enough good -- without the suspended Gordon and after losing Tate and Cameron to injury -- that the Browns have a starting quarterback instead of a quarterback controversy.

I say that while acknowledging the annual Browns slogan is still in effect in the absence of wins.

Everything is subject to change.

Bud Shaw is a columnist for the Cleveland Plain Dealer.