There have been plenty of mediocre teams to make the NFL playoffs in recent years. In 2011, Denver was 8-8 and made it. In 2010, Seattle was 7-9. And in 2008, San Diego qualified with an 8-8 record.
All three of those teams had something in common: they won their division.
It’s one thing to win a division with a bunch of bad teams in it. It’s quite another to make the playoffs as a wild card with an 8-8 record as the Steelers are trying to do this season.
Since the league went to a 16-game schedule in 1978, only six teams have qualified for the playoffs as a wild card with 8-8 records. Of those six teams only two won wild card games and none made it past the divisional round.
In 2004, St. Louis and Minnesota both made the NFC playoffs with 8-8 records and both won their wild card games. St. Louis beat Seattle and Minnesota beat Green Bay. The Rams and the Vikings, however, were eliminated the following week.
The only other 8-8 teams to qualify as wild cards are as follows:
2006 – New York Giants – lost to Philadelphia in wild card game
1999 – Dallas – lost to Minnesota in wild card game
1991 – New York Jets – lost to Houston in wild card game
1990 – New Orleans – lost to Chicago in wild card game




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.