CLEVELAND — It’s starting to become obvious, isn’t it?
The Steelers don’t have a quarterback problem.
They don’t have a quarterback.
Kenny Pickett was outplayed again on Sunday by the other team’s young quarterback. It happened with San Francisco’s second-year pro Brock Purdy in a lopsided loss in the opener and with Houston rookie C.J. Stroud in another blowout loss. It happened with Tennessee’s Will Levis and Green Bay’s Jordan Love even though the Steelers won both of those games.
This time, it happened with Cleveland rookie Dorian Thompson-Robinson, who made just his second NFL start after throwing three interceptions and being sacked four times by Baltimore on Oct. 1 in his first start.
It’s true Thompson-Robinson wasn’t much better than Pickett. His passer rating was 54.9 compared to Pickett’s 62.5. The game was so bad that it set offensive football back about 50 years. But Thompson-Robinson was better than Pickett by just enough to lead the Browns to a 13-10 win. He led the winning field goal drive in the final 1:18 after Pickett failed to put up points on two fourth-quarter possessions.
Read More
So much for that Pickett fourth-quarter magic.
It’s not that Pickett didn’t have opportunities. The Steelers had a first down on the Cleveland 40 with 5 minutes left before an incompletion on a screen pass, a 5-yard loss by Najee Harris on a run and a short pass to Jaylen Warren well short of the first-down marker. The Steelers took possession again on their 30 with 1:42 remaining, but Pickett threw three consecutive incompletions for Diontae Johnson, turning the ball back to Thompson-Robinson at the Cleveland 35. That set up the Browns’ winning eight-play, 48-yard field goal drive that had the crowd chanting, “DTR! DTR!”
The Steelers somehow managed to lose on a day when they rushed for 172 yards against the NFL’s top-rated defense and didn’t turn the ball over. Warren was a sensation again, running for 129 yards, including a 74-yard touchdown on the second play of the third quarter that gave the Steelers life after a 10-0 halftime deficit. Why he was given just nine carries is inexplicable.
Sadly for the Steelers, that Warren score was their only touchdown.
It was great that Pickett didn’t turn the ball over. Thompson-Robinson threw one interception to safety Chandon Sullivan on a ball that was tipped. But Pickett passed for just 106 yards. Factor in the three sacks he took, and the Steelers finished with 77 passing yards.
Not exactly NFL offensive football in 2023, wouldn’t you agree?
Mike Tomlin had a couple of excuses for Pickett and his offense. The Browns defense was terrific, he said. The throbbing crowd at Cleveland Browns Stadium made things difficult for his offense, he said.
Blah, blah, blah.
“They have a really good defense,” Tomlin said. “They make a lot of offenses look like that. Coupled with the venue, we have to give them some credit. There were a lot of things that were challenging today. ...
“We weren’t able to get enough big plays on offense. That’s what you have to do when you play against a great defense in their venue. You’re not going to drive the ball, you know, 15-play drives and things like that. You need some chunk.”
I repeat:
Blah, blah, blah.
Pickett also had an excuse, although he did say he “didn’t play nearly well enough” ...
“They play a lot of man-to-man. They didn’t play man today. They threw a lot of zone looks at us. We were expecting them to come in and play man. We’ve got to adjust better.”
I get that Pickett didn’t have the best protection. He was sacked on the Steelers’ first play by Myles Garrett at the Steelers’ one-inch line. That should have been ruled a safety.
I also get that Pickett had at least three “miscommunications” — his word — with his receivers. This was the Steelers’ 10th game. Shouldn’t those issues be resolved by now?
Diontae Johnson was targeted eight times and had just two catches for 16 yards. He was visibly frustrated in the locker room after the game and refused to speak with the media.
George Pickens was targeted six times and had four catches for 38 yards. He did talk after the game, muttering over and over, “We’ve got to keep working.”
But the bottom line?
Pickett hasn’t progressed nearly enough in his second season as a starter. He was a No. 1 draft choice in April 2022. Thompson-Robinson was drafted in the fifth round in April. His UCLA team lost to Pitt in the Sun Bowl last season.
“I don’t know what it’s like to play that position, but I do know what it’s like to have ups and downs in this league,” Steelers center Mason Cole said. “This league is tough. You’re going to have really good weeks and really bad weeks. The bad weeks, you’ve got to try to pull yourself through.
“Kenny’s got a heck of a future. He’s a heck of a ball player, a heck of a quarterback, a heck of a teammate. He’ll get through it. We’ll get through it.”
Tomlin said the same thing about the Steelers.
“We’ll be back,” he growled.
I’m not so sure after watching this game.
Pickens did manage to come up with a positive, maybe the only positive of a rotten afternoon on the Cleveland lakefront.
“People woke up today. I’m blessed for that.”
Pretty sad, right?
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.