Steelers insider Ray Fittipaldo grades each aspect of the Steelers’ 13-10 loss to the Browns:
Quarterback: Kenny Pickett is regressing in his second season, and it’s now to the point where the Steelers might have to consider addressing the position in the draft again or via an offseason trade. Pickett was 15 for 28 for 106 yards. He didn’t break the 100-yard mark until the final play of the game. His pocket awareness is almost as bad as his accuracy. There were several occasions on Sunday where he missed receivers by 10 yards. Sunday marked his 22nd career start, and he lost to a rookie making his second NFL start. There are seven games remaining, and the locker room could be asking the coaches to make a change.
Grade: F-
Running backs: Jaylen Warren was the Steelers’ best offensive player by a wide margin on Sunday, and he only touched the ball 12 times. He scored the Steelers’ only touchdown of the game on a 74-yard run and finished with 129 yards on nine carries. He also had three catches for 16 yards. On the game’s final series, he watched from the sidelines as Najee Harris took the final three snaps — all incomplete passes. Mike Tomlin gets the blame for that gaffe as he does many others in this game. Warren, for his part, did everything he could to keep the Steelers in this game.
Grade: A-
Receivers: It’s hard to put any real blame on the receivers when the quarterback and/or the offensive coordinator are incapable of getting them the ball. Sure, the numbers are terrible. George Pickens led the Steelers in receiving yards with 38. He also had the longest catch of the game — for a measly 14 yards. But there were no attempts by Pickett that threatened the Browns deep down the field. That’s not on the receivers. They can’t call the plays, and they can’t throw the ball to themselves, although that might be a better option at this point.
Read More
Grade: C
Offensive line: Dan Moore’s pathetic attempt at blocking Myles Garrett on the Steelers’ first offensive snap set the tone for the entire game. The 9-yard loss put the Steelers on the 1, and they could never win the field position battle again in the first half. Pickett was sacked twice more, and there was pressure on Pickett on other occasions. They continue to block well in the run game, though. The Steelers ran for 172 yards. Makes you wonder why they didn’t run on their final drive, doesn’t it?
Grade: C-
Defensive line: The Browns entered the game with the NFL’s No. 2 rushing attack, and the Steelers held them to 3.3 yards per carry. The line deserves much of the credit for limiting Jerome Ford and Kareem Hunt, but the lack of an interior pass rush continues to hurt the defense. Browns coach Kevin Stefanski had his rookie quarterback throw 43 times. He wasn’t afraid of the Steelers’ pass rush.
Grade: C
Linebackers: The Browns started two backups at tackle, but T.J. Watt and Alex Highsmith were quiet for most of the game. Watt had the Steelers’ only sack and had three quarterback hits, but Highsmith was called for roughing the passer the only time he had a hurry in the game. The Steelers needed more pressure playing against a rookie quarterback who dropped back to pass so many times. Inside linebacker Elandon Roberts led the Steelers with 15 tackles and helped keep the Browns’ running game in check.
Grade: C
Secondary: Chandon Sullivan had an interception to thwart a potential scoring drive in the second half, and the Steelers limited the Browns to 165 passing yards with two backup safeties starting due to injuries to Minkah Fitzpatrick and Keanu Neal. But there were clearly some communication issues with Trenton Thompson and Damontae Kazee that forced the Steelers to waste two timeouts, including one on the first drive of the game. And the coverage on the Browns’ winning drive was way too soft.
Grade: C
Special teams: Pressley Harvin had two dreadful punts in the second half, including a 20-yarder. Those poor punts didn’t lead directly to points, but the Steelers had poor field position for their offensive drives as a result. It’s the same old story with Harvin every season. Chris Boswell kicked another field goal and has only missed once in the first 10 games. Punt returner Calvin Austin showed some juice in the return game with 51 yards on three returns.
Grade: C
Coaching: Mike Tomlin deserves 99% of the blame for this loss. Kenny Pickett was playing terribly, and he decided to put the ball in his hands on the Steelers’ final offensive series. Pickett predictably threw three incomplete passes. But it wasn’t just the fact that the passes fell incomplete and almost no time ticked off the clock, leaving the Browns with plenty of time to put together a game-winning field goal drive. It was the absence of any kind of safe passing game that could have moved the chains. Instead, Pickett threw three low-percentage passes. If Tomlin plays it conservative there, the Steelers at least have a chance to win the game in overtime. This is only one example of how Tomlin was out-coached in this game. Not having Warren in the game on the final series is inexcusable. Calling two timeouts when his defense had too many players on the field is inexcusable. Say whatever you want about practice squad players being called up into more prominent roles. What the heck is practice for? They had five days to sort it out. You think those timeouts would have come in handy on the final drive?
Grade: F-
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.