I very rarely disagree with Jim Leyland, the smartest baseball man I’ve known.

This is one time.

“I don’t ever want to see [computers calling balls and strikes],” Leyland said a few weeks ago. “I think the umpires do an unbelievable job. They don’t get enough credit for being as good as they are. They’re going to miss a pitch here and there. Some go in your favor, some go against you. But I think they’re better than ever.”

I was right there with Leyland until last week. I wasn’t necessarily against the concept of a robot umpire calling balls and strikes, but I had doubts that it would work efficiently. Then I read the reviews of a computer that was used for the first time in the independent Atlantic League All-Star Game Wednesday night in York, Pa. High pitches were called strikes more often than not. There were a few glitches and minimal delays, but not nearly as many as you might expect. One of the pitchers told Dan Connolly of The Athletic that he didn’t realize a computer was calling the pitches instead of the human umpire who was crouched behind the catcher, as always. That was a pretty good endorsement for the first time out.

Advertise with us

That’s why I’m now convinced the Automated Ball-Strike System will be used in the big leagues, sooner rather than later.

You know, in the interest of getting the ball-strike calls right consistently.

Here’s how it worked at PeoplesBank Park, per Connolly’s report:

“A 3D-Doppler radar screen attached to the roof of the stadium directly behind home plate registered pitches and sent the information to a laptop computer integrated with TrackMan data. That strike-ball info was then transmitted from the computer in the press box to the home-plate umpire, who carried an iPhone with Bluetooth in his pocket and wore an Apple AirPod wireless headphone in his right ear. After each pitch, he’d hear the ball or strike directive and then make the call on the field with only a second or two lag in the execution.”

Home plate umpire Brian deBrauwere lost connection to the computer twice, once for a three-pitch sequence, then for half an inning. He had to make the calls the old-fashioned way. The game kept moving.

Advertise with us

Implementing technology takes time, right?

The Atlantic League soon will begin using the Automated Ball-Strike System in all of its remaining games this season.

“We’re relatively confident that it’s going to spread through organized baseball,” Atlantic League President Rick White told ESPN. “What we know is technology can help umpires be more accurate. We’re committed to that.”

Major League Baseball is a partner in the project and will be monitoring the results closely. A spokesman said it will be in touch with the umpires’ union every step of the way.

“One of our focuses is not to replace the umpire,” MLB’s senior vice president of economics and operations Morgan Sword told ESPN. “In fact, we’re trying to empower the umpire with technology. The home plate umpire has a lot more to do than call balls and strikes.”

Advertise with us

Leyland, indirectly, offered a reason why a robot umpire will be coming soon to PNC Park.

“I think replay’s great. The idea is to get it right so the right team wins the game. I don’t think fans care if it takes a few extra minutes as long as their team wins. Pirates fans just want to raise the Jolly Roger.”

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Joe” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.