The Pirates won five of seven games against the Cubs and Brewers just before the All-Star break. Then they lost three in a row to the Cubs right after. There were people surprised by both developments and many who tried to interpret both results as some sort of trend.
But baseball is the ultimate “marathon not a sprint” sport. The season is 162 games, and 162 games don’t lie.
And for the most part, the career numbers of a player don’t lie, either. That’s why nobody should be surprised by anything that has happened with the Pirates this season. They are a roster full of average major league players (or worse) with a few star-caliber players sprinkled in. This team was destined to hover around .500 from the start.
That brings me to the subject of what the Pirates should do at the trade deadline. I can make a strong case they should buy. I can make a strong case they should sell. But they should not just stand pat.
Last week general manager Neal Huntington hinted that he is leaning heavily to the “standing pat” option. He even made some quip about how he has failed to help the Pirates at the last three trade deadlines and that he likes the ball club as it is. That is why he will be cautious to make any deals and may even sit this deadline out.
That would be a huge mistake because the Pirates are stuck in mediocrity. They are 44-48 entering Monday, and they have had a hard time really getting out of their own way long enough to make large inroads into that record under .500. At one point they were 24-20, meaning they’ve been 20-28 in their last 48 games.
Read More
Huntington could look at his lineup and see that it is capable of scoring a lot of runs and decide the Pirates are a few pitchers away from legitimately contending this year. I’m not sure I agree fully, but I don’t think it is the worst thought, either. That might give them a chance to compete in the second half, and it would send a strong message to the clubhouse and fans.
But the GM could also realize his team isn’t close to a World Series contender and start looking to ship away players who don’t fit into the Pirates’ long-term plans, such as Corey Dickerson and Melky Cabrera, and look to cash in big on Felipe Vazquez and Starling Marte.
With either option, the Pirates would be improving themselves. They would either be improving for this year and perhaps next, or they would be improving for next year and beyond.
But if Huntington does nothing at the trade deadline, the Pirates will remain the same .500-hovering team they have been all season. They will be inconsistent and will fall short of the playoffs and maybe even struggle to get to 82 wins. That would mean this season would be a wasted one.
On top of that, doing nothing at this trade deadline would nearly ensure the Pirates will be the same .500-hovering team next season. There just aren’t many places in which there is a realistic chance of significant improvement if there aren’t some different players brought in. And that’s especially true since the Pirates won’t upgrade in the offseason, because that’s not how they operate.
This season may already be lost, but it definitely will be if Huntington doesn’t go out and get some help — either for this year or the future.
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com and Twitter @PaulZeise






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.