Clint Hurdle dropped J.A. Happ’s name Friday afternoon, a few hours before Chris Archer made the most anticipated debut by a Pirates pitcher since Gerrit Cole in 2013. It was a public service announcement of sorts, a reminder that first impressions aren’t always good impressions or lasting impressions. Happ, who came to the Pirates from Seattle in a 2015 trade deadline deal for minor league pitcher Adrian Sampson, gave up six earned runs and nine hits in 3⅓ innings in a loss to Minnesota in his first start with the Pirates. He finished the season by going 7-1 with a 1.05 ERA to help his new, playoff-bound club win 98 games.

“It’s not like [Archer is going] to get a big grade after this one and that’s the way it’s going to finish up,” Hurdle said.

Good thing.

Archer’s start against the St. Louis Cardinals deserved no better than a D. He gave up a home run to Matt Carpenter on his third pitch. He pitched behind in the count much of the game, walked four batters and hit another. He allowed the leadoff man on base in all five of his innings. He couldn’t make it out of the fifth — an error by Jordy Mercer surely didn’t help — despite being given a 6-2 lead after three innings, thanks to the top of the lineup — Adam Frazier, Starling Marte and Gregory Polanco — going 5 for 5 with five runs and three RBIs.

Advertise with us

A bummer, sure, although the Pirates saved the night by winning, 7-6, on Frazier’s RBI single in the eighth inning.

Hurdle made another interesting observation after acknowledging he, like the rest of Pittsburgh, was looking forward to Archer’s start.

“I’ll be happy once it’s over, as well. We can go on and he can settle in and get his feet on the ground.”

I can’t agree more with Hurdle.

I refuse to believe much better times aren’t ahead.

Advertise with us

Archer blew into town Wednesday after coming from Tampa Bay in the biggest trade of the Neal Huntington era. He immediately climbed into Pittsburgh’s heart by showing up in an Antonio Brown No. 84 jersey, saying he has too much respect for Andrew McCutchen to wear No. 22 on his back and announcing he would warm up to Wiz Khalifa”s “Black and Yellow.” That just added to the out-of-control hype, which grew a little more when he slapped hands with fans along the third base line as he walked to the outfield to warm up.

If Archer was a little too pumped, can you blame him?

“I have no idea what that man had to compartmentalize and work through,” Hurdle said. “Adrenaline. Emotion. All of it. At the end of the day, he went out and competed. That’s the thing he’s always done. He gave us everything he had. I’m not going to overcook it.”

“I tried to keep it as similar as possible,” Archer said. “The reality is I was a little amped-up there in the beginning.”

Archer had his moments. He struck out Yadier Molina and Paul DeJong with the bases loaded in the second inning, pumping his fist repeatedly and screaming to himself as he walked off the mound after the DeJong strikeout. He stranded Marcel Ozuna after a leadoff double in the third. He threw 15 swing-and-miss strikes.

Advertise with us

But Archer wanted to do so much more. For his new team and for the fans who were so welcoming to him and gave him a standing ovation when Hurdle took him out.

“The fans were incredible,” Archer said. “I’ve never pitched in an atmosphere like that. Been in the big leagues almost six years. It was unbelievable. Do I wish I could have done a little bit better? Yes. But all things considered how hectic things were …

“We got a big win, so I’m not disappointed.”

The crowd was announced at 26,773 and, as Archer said, into the game from the first pitch. But it was a bit disappointing after the Pirates were buyers at the trade deadline and added Texas closer Keone Kela as well as Archer. It’s clear the franchise still has much work to do to win back paying customers.

The guess here is Archer will put this first start behind him and do his part.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.