Mike Tomlin has something in common this spring with Bill Belichick, the only NFL coach who is better than he is. Each has been attacked by critics, Tomlin for failing to win a playoff game last season with a 13-3 team and Belichick for having the nerve to not win the Super Bowl.
Former Southern California Heisman Trophy winner/NFL running back Reggie Bush took on Tomlin on the NFL Network’s “Good Morning Football” show last week by suggesting the Steelers are in trouble because Ben Roethlisberger and Antonio Brown aren’t taking part in the voluntary spring practices. Roethlisberger was there for the first one but has missed the past five because, according to NFL Network, he is on a family vacation. Brown made the first two but missed the past four because, again according to NFL Network, he doesn’t want to catch passes from the backup quarterbacks.
“At what point do you start to say that maybe the players aren’t responding to the coach or maybe there needs to be some form of a culture shift that I believe Tomlin can get done,” Bush said.
“If you want to be a great player, that’s fine, you can afford to miss some of those OTAs, some of those minicamps, some of the voluntary stuff. But if you want to be a great team, you’ve got to look at the Patriots, what they’ve done over the years. They’re always there. All of their players are always there.”
Bush has a point, although I hardly think that Roethlisberger and Brown missing the OTAs is a team-killer. Both will be ready to go at the mandatory mini-camp next week and at training camp in July. It’s not as if other teams don’t have players skipping OTAs. That includes the Patriots, who have been without Tom Brady and Rob Gronkowski this spring. You don’t really believe that will keep them from being a Super Bowl contender again next season, do you?
But Bush’s criticism of Tomlin is more credible than that from inane phony Terry Bradshaw, who has said Tomlin is nothing more than “a cheerleader.” Bush is right that the Steelers could use a culture change. I wrote that after their home playoff loss to Jacksonville in January and opined that Tomlin needs to get tougher. James Harrison disrespected him for much of last season and was allowed to get away with it. Le’Veon Bell and Mike Mitchell publicly looked past the Jaguars to a playoff rematch with the Patriots, which, Tomlin, unfortunately, had done seven weeks earlier in an interview with Tony Dungy. Bell missed most of a walk-through practice the day before the Jaguars game and showed up at Heinz Field on gameday later than Tomlin wanted. Talk about disrespect.
Read More
If Tomlin getting tougher leads to a culture change, I’m all for it.
The criticism of Belichick is much different. He has been accused of being too tough. More than one former player has said it was no fun playing for the Patriots. Current players have wondered why Belichick didn’t play star cornerback Malcolm Butler in Super Bowl LII against Philadelphia in February. Belichick has yet to offer an explanation. Even Eagles offensive lineman, Lane Johnson, showing no class after his team won, piled on, telling Bleeding Green Nation, “All these guys talking about ‘I’ll take the rings.’ OK. You can have your rings. You can also have 15 miserable years.” Perhaps most hurtful to the Patriots, there have been reports that Brady has tired of Belichick’s ways.
Belichick remains steadfast.
“We feel what’s important to us is to win,” he told Pro Football Talk.
That doesn’t mean Belichick doesn’t have problems, maybe problems greater than Tomlin’s. An ESPN story in early-January talked of a rift between Brady and Belichick. Brady, allegedly, is angry that Belichick wanted to keep backup quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo as his eventual replacement only to be overruled, at Brady’s urging, by owner Robert Kraft, who approved the October trade of Garoppolo to San Francisco. Brady also is angry that Belichick banned his personal trainer, Alex Guerrero, from team facilities. The most damning proof of all this was Brady’s “I plead the fifth” response when asked during a May interview if he feels appreciated by the Patriots and, presumably, Belichick. The Brady-Belichick relationship is worth watching next season.
My guess is Belichick won’t change much, if at all, and Brady and the Patriots will find a way to keep winning.
I’m also thinking Tomlin will get tougher and eliminate some of the distractions that led to the Steelers being known last season as “Team Turmoil."
Bush also criticized Tomlin for losing too many games that the Steelers are expected to win. The playoff loss to Jacksonville was the worst, but it hardly makes me believe the players have stopped responding to Tomlin. His record is 116-60, his .659 winning percentage second only to Belichick’s .679 among active coaches. He has taken teams to the playoffs eight times in 11 seasons, including to two Super Bowls, and never has had a losing season.
And many Steelers fans want him out?
That always amazes me.
Do those fans want Baltimore’s John Harbaugh? The Ravens have missed the playoffs in three consecutive seasons and four of the past five. Do they want Cincinnati’s Marvin Lewis? The Bengals are 0-7 in the postseason in his 15 seasons. Do they want Cleveland’s Hue Jackson? The Browns went 0-16 under him last season and 1-15 in 2016.
Fans should be careful what they wish.
Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.