Mike Tomlin is a good coach. I believe he’s the second-best coach in the NFL. But it has become clearer than ever that the gap between him and Bill Belichick is enormous. It is just as clear that Tomlin can be so much better. Art Rooney II should demand that he be better.

I thought about that Sunday as I watched James Harrison get a big sack to help the New England Patriots beat the Jacksonville Jaguars on their way to Super Bowl LII. Harrison was at the center of much that went wrong for Tomlin this season. Releasing Harrison when he did and allowing him to go to the Steelers’ biggest rival might have been Tomlin’s worst mistake. That easily could have been Ben Roethlisberger who Harrison sacked late in the AFC championship, not the Jaguars’ Blake Bortles.

According to Harrison, Tomlin promised him playing time, then didn’t play him after deciding early in the exhibition season to go with young No. 1 picks Bud Dupree and T.J. Watt. That was the right call by Tomlin even though Dupree looked more and more like Jarvis Jones as the season progressed. It was then, in the heat of the summer, that Tomlin should have released Harrison to give him a chance to hook on with another team. Harrison eventually sulked, to the point that, if you believe Dupree and Maurkice Pouncey, he would fall asleep during linebackers meetings and wouldn’t stay for games when he wasn’t on the active roster. Tomlin put up with Harrison’s gross disrespect to him, defensive coordinator Keith Butler and outside linebackers coach Joey Porter before finally releasing him with two regular-season games left. At that point, Tomlin should have kept Harrison and made him suffer by deactivating him for the remaining games.

As it turns out, Harrison wasn’t the only player to disrespect Tomlin.

Advertise with us

The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s Ed Bouchette reported in a damning story last week that Le’Veon Bell missed most of the Saturday walk-through practice before the Steelers playoff game against the Jaguars, then showed up the next day later than the two hours before the game that Tomlin expects from his players and staff. Inside linebackers coach Jerry Olsavsky also was late, according to 93.7 The Fan’s Andrew Fillipponi. That’s a horrible reflection on Tomlin. It makes him look so weak.

Bell did no favors to Tomlin the night before the Jacksonville game when he tweeted he was looking forward to Round 2 against the Patriots in the AFC championship. Neither did Mike Mitchell, who promised a win against the Patriots in a Sports Illustrated interview. Tomlin has to take some blame for those idiotic moves because he also talked about Round 2 against the Patriots during an interview with NBC’s Tony Dungy in late November. That was so foolish.

Still, it was a shame for Tomlin the Steelers’ 13-3 season ended with the 45-42 loss to the Jaguars. He did some terrific work during the year. He kept the team together after the national anthem fiasco in Chicago over an issue that was potentially explosive and divisive. He also kept the team together after Ryan Shazier’s horrific spinal cord injury Dec. 4 in Cincinnati. That night was every coach’s worst nightmare. That the Steelers remained focused and came back from a 17-0 deficit to win is a tribute to Tomlin. It might have been the best-coached game of the NFL season.

Tomlin has been successful because of his mostly positive relationship with his players. It’s not easy being a coach these days. Social media can be a brutal, evil place. Many of today’s athletes are me-first, not team-first. Remember how Martavis Bryant put it in October when he went on Instagram and asked to be traded? “I just want mines, period, point-blank.” Beyond that, many athletes are just plain stupid. Just hours after ridiculing the Steelers for looking past his team, Jaguars cornerback Jalen Ramsey told a gathering of Jacksonville fans, “We are going to the Super Bowl and we are going to win that [bleep].”

Look how that guarantee turned out.

Advertise with us

Every coach has those issues.

Well, every coach but the one in New England.

That’s why Belichick might just be the greatest coach of all time in any sport.

Tomlin has shown he can be tough at times. He suspended Santonio Holmes for a game in 2008 after Holmes was caught with marijuana in his SUV. Holmes went on to become a Super Bowl hero that season by catching the winning touchdown pass from Roethlisberger to beat the Arizona Cardinals. Tomlin suspended Bryant for a game this season after Bryant demeaned teammate JuJu Smith-Schuster in his trade demand. Bryant came around and was a productive player down the stretch. Tomlin also released LeGarrette Blount after Blount quit on the team late in a game in Nashville in 2014. That didn’t work out so well for the Steelers; Blount went on to win a Super Bowl with the Patriots that season, as Harrison almost surely will do Feb. 4.

It’s obvious Tomlin needs to get even tougher. He has to put an end to the nonsense. His players always play hard for him. Is it too much for him to expect that they show up on time? To demand it, actually? And maybe demand that they stay off social media during the season?

Advertise with us

I believe Tomlin, after 11 seasons, a 116-60 regular-season record and a win in Super Bowl XLIII, will change for the better.

I know he’s a smart man.

He’s a really good coach.

Ron Cook: rcook@post-gazette.com and Twitter@RonCookPG. Ron Cook can be heard on the “Cook and Poni” show weekdays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. on 93.7 The Fan.

Our in-depth Steelers coverage is second to none.

Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.