Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome to my Steelers chat. Let's get started.

cjp: how can we continue to watch our defensive coaching staff continue to get out-coached, poorly evaluate/develop talent, make no in game adjustments and just get all around embarrassed in big moments with no changes. We put up 42 on Jax and fire our offensive staff? We give up 45 to jax, listen to defenders for the second year in a row talk about missed assignments, no adjustments, not knowing where to be in week 18 and no change to defensive coaches???? It's a total disgrace for this organization and Tomlin to continue this charade

Ray Fittipaldo: Well, they didn't actually fire anyone. Todd Haley's contract was not renewed. Richard Mann retired. But to your point about the defense they have to change a few things. You are right about the communication errors and mental lapses. Good defenses don't have those problems. So the Steelers have to get smarter players to execute their assignments or they have to make their defense simpler. But you shouldn't lose to a team like Jacksonville because your defense allowed 45 points. It should not happen. The same Jaguars team only scored 10 in these same playoffs against the Bills and 20 against the Patriots.

Moose: The Steelers loss hurt, but I'm almost glad it happened. When you disrespect your opponent, don't focus on your job at hand, tweet about next year's contract holdouts, and miss practice without any accountability, THEN WE DESERVED TO LOSE! What say you Ray?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I tend to agree it's a bad idea to talk trash and tweet, but I can tell you the head coach and the players don't feel the same way. Tomlin came out and said as much at his season-ending presser.

Moose: With the new OC, I assume we will keep the same system, but the only thing that will differ is the relationship with Ben?

Ray Fittipaldo: I am sure Randy Fichtner will add his own personal touch to the offense, but yes the move was made so there would be some continuity. Why change offenses when your QB is 36 and still playing at a high level?

Moose: The Jags took a page out of the Steeler's book and played too conservatively with a lead! Why do the Steelers play prevent OFFENSE when we are up by only 2 scores and a lot of time left to play? It kills momentum and lets teams hang around.

Ray Fittipaldo: The Patriots played great situational football Sunday. They pinned the Jaguars deep, stopped the run and made Bortles beat them by throwing. That's what the Steelers should have done, but they could never get the running game under control. That's why they lost. The Patriots were kind of stunned early in that game just as the Steelers were. The difference is they made some good adjustments, played good situational football and completed the comeback. The Steelers could not do that. If the Steelers were able to tie that game against the Jaguars they would have won. As soon as the pats went ahead I knew they'd win because it was then on Bortles to win the game and not manage it.

Advertise with us

Moose: Why wasn't Porter and Lake terminated within 24 hours of our loss? Is Tomlin's seat officially warm?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think it's warm, but there should be sufficient reason for ownership to ask Tomlin to clean some things up with his operation. I don't think that's too much to ask.

DaquidoBazzini: Hi Ray, I’ve seen a couple guys that cover the Steelers in the past week say that they think Mike Mitchell will be back. What do you think and why?

Ray Fittipaldo: I guess it all depends on how they approach free agency and the draft. Mitchell is a $8.1 million cap hit for 2018, the final year of his five-year contract. The Steelers can save $6 million by cutting him. Those are the facts. But you can't just cut him and replace him with Robert Golden. You have to have a plan to replace him whether in free agency or the draft. Remember when Will Gay was tortured by Brady in the 2017 AFC title game and everyone thought he had to be replaced? Well, there he was in the loss to the Jaguars missing an assignment on the TJ Yeldon dump-off. I said it then about Gay and I'll say it about Mitchell this year. If he's on the team next season and playing they won't win a Super Bowl.

Dj Cain: Ray thanks for the Chats! All this y’all about Bell and his contract, do you think we have seen the last of him in a Steelers jersey?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I think they value great players. He's a great player, an All-Pro. But I think they can win without him if they want to go down that road if they feel like he's worn out his welcome. They did it in 2015. Running backs are replaceable.

TK: I still don't understand why they released James Harrison. He showed yesterday that he can still rush the passer, and I don't get why they didn't play him on the left side instead of Bud DuPree. I know they want DuPree to develop, but it would have been nice to have Harrison pressuring Bortles in the JAX game. Why do you think they released him?

Ray Fittipaldo: That's still a good question. If he indeed was sleeping in meetings and being a disruption at work then the Steelers had the right to do that. However, the timing to me is odd. Why do it so late in the season if he was doing these things all along. Why not suspend him for conduct detrimental to the team so he could not play for the Patriots? The other odd part about the timing is how the Patriots were involved. The Steelers play the Pats Dec. 17. The Steelers cut him Dec. 23. I wonder if the Steelers have surveillance video from Heinz Field of Harrison on the 17th. Did he speak with the Patriots on the 17th at any time? We saw something similar to LeGarrette Blount. Wink, wink, nod, nod, get yourself released and we'll use you.

DaquidoBazzini: I have not seen a word from Art Rooney Jr since the loss. Is it possible that we could still see Defensive coaching staff changes?

Ray Fittipaldo: Art Rooney II will speak with the media before the end of the month or early next month. He does it every year. And while things could change with the defensive staff it's apparent that Tomlin's preference is to keep things the same.

Advertise with us

David C.: What are the chances that the Steelers use the non-exclusive Franchise tag on Bell? Also, would any team even consider giving up two first rounders for a RB in the NFL today? Thanks!

Ray Fittipaldo: That's an option, but if you do that you had better be prepared to pay him that guaranteed money because who in their right mind would give up first-round picks for a Bell when he's only guaranteed to play for that team for one year?

Moose: The Pat's best quality imo is their discipline and flexibility. No other team game plans better vs their opponents strengths and weaknesses. You never know what the Pats are going to look like from week to week. Doesn't it seem like Tomlin is stubborn and sticks to the "we are just gonna play our game" mentality?

Ray Fittipaldo: They do make good adjustments. That's what they always do. They're not going to beat themselves. The opponent has to do it. Teams have come close this season. The Steelers had them beat before the infamous Jesse James play. The Jaguars were up 10 in the fourth. But you have to finish the job against them. With Brady at QB, they'll always have life.

David C.: Will Mike Mitchell become a cap casaulty? How much wiggle room do the Steelers have in cap space (dependent on Bell's contract situation)?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: They'd have to rearrange some things, with Mitchell being an example where they could save $6 million.

David C.: Is Hargraves size a concern when trying to execute a 3-4 scheme? Do the Steelers need to get a true nose tackle to fix their run defense? (Would they ever consider switching to/incorporating more 4-3 schemes if Shazier doesn't return?

Ray Fittipaldo: That's a good question, but you have to look at how they've drafted in recent years. They've taken two 3-4 OLBs in the past three years in the first round. Yes, I know they could move inside if they go to a 3-4, but is that where they are at their best? I don't know. The Steelers have to get better at stopping the run. They're not going to make a change at either DE spot because they have too much money invested in those guys so Hargrave is the obvious place where they could make a change. If Vita Vea from Washington is there at No. 28 they'd at least have to consider taking him.

GeeNo: Hi Ray – While I believe Tomlin is a good coach (how can he not be with his records?), there are definitely steps he needs to take to go from good to great. I wish I knew all of answers (like how to stop playing down to competition, how to manage the last 2 minutes of a game better) but I’d hope Mike reflects on this. However, it seems like his answers to questions are either dismissive or defended by something like “we won’t live in our fears.” Do you get the sense the coaches try to improve themselves as well as the team?

Ray Fittipaldo: Of course. And just because he is dismissive with the media doesn't mean these issues are not addressed behind close doors with others in the organization.

Advertise with us

Andrew: Hi ray! I like the moves made with the staff on offense. Why nothing on defense? The defense was a disappointment and their ranking was not a true reflection of performance.

Ray Fittipaldo: A lot of people are asking that question. The defense was having issues before Ryan Shazier was injured. When Shazier went down they became even worse. Looking back, it obviously was a bad decision to think Sean Spence could walk in and start for a contender after being out of the NFL for two months. Why didn't the Steelers have better depth behind him? Look at the Patriots. They lost Dont'a Hightower early in the season and had players on the roster step in for him. They weren't great, but they got the job done and they're in the Super Bowl. I know you can't have quality depth at every position because of the salary cap, but there had to be a better option than Spence. Moving Watt or Dupree inside and playing Harrison certainly was an option though Harrison's antics might have prevented that from being seriously considered.

Carlo: Ray, what are your thoughts on the defensive adjustments made by Tomlin and Co after the Shazier injury? Seemed like they continued like he was still out there but we had no player that matched his speed and athleticism. I found it pretty obvious but thought changes would eventually be made at some point. It's hard to watch how the Pats adjust so well in game and we can't adjust over the course of half a season and into the playoffs (after a bye).

Ray Fittipaldo: Read above. Watt or Dupree moving inside might have been a better option. Play Harrison or Chickillo outside.

Jasonh: For Coach Tomlin not to see the need for change on the defensive staff is concerning to me. Joey Porter has been a distraction previously and Bud Dupree has regressed. Our pass defense has blown assignments regularly and is toward the top in the league in long pass completions and Artie Burns has regressed. Also seems to me it’s time for a new DB Coach too. Seems like Tomlin is being obstinate.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't disagree with you on some of your points. It just might be that they believe in the defense and the players are failing in their execution. The players have said that over and over since the loss to the Jaguars. They believe in the defense. They just made too many mistakes and there were too many mental lapses.

Moose: Can we draft more quiet football guys and less barking social media guys? Can you imaging Aaron Smith, Troy P, or Heath talking crap before the game or recording locker room footage for their followers? I'm tired of players more worried about their brand than their team/job.

Ray Fittipaldo: Sounds like a good idea to me, Moose.

Jasonh: I think a message needs to be sent by the Steelers to the team (Tomlin included) that the only way they get back to the Super Bowl is to be a more disciplined team. Don’t resign Bell and release Mitchell. Use the freed up money to get James Farrior level talent in free agency at safety and rb. Draft inside lbs and rb in the top 3 picks. Steelers need to go back to being a Team to get back to the Super Bowl.

Ray Fittipaldo: I think there are people who agree with you, Jason.

Advertise with us

John M.: Are the Steelers going to do nothing to fix the paper curtain defense? To keep the same players and coaches and expect different results seems like a recipe for failure once again.

Ray Fittipaldo: Agreed. Just like I wrote above about Gay and Mitchell. If Gay was playing this season the Steelers were going be in trouble. The same probably goes Mitchell next season. As long as he is playing I think the Steelers won't be at their best.

Bedford Bill: Do the Steelers have the right defensive coordinator if the head coach is spending his time helping the dc devise defenses? Surely the Rooney family has to be questioning the defense and it's trajectory.

Ray Fittipaldo: I can't imagine they're happy with the defense, but it doesn't seem like there are going to be changes. The staff is flying to Orlando tomorrow for the Pro Bowl. I think the Steelers would have given them the courtesy to go find new jobs at the Senior Bowl if they were going to make changes. The Senior Bowl is this week, too.

SB or Bust: Hi, Ray, Is the FO considering taking the $15 million that would be available by not signing Bell and using that to bring in a FA ILB and/or Safety? They could address those 2 positions in the first 3 rounds of the draft as well plus draft a RB. Bottom line, they did not get to the SB with Bell - if they do the above instead they may have a better shot.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: You might be right, but just know that's going against how they've approached other star players. They like to keep their stars in their prime years.

Bedford Bill: Deebo looked like he still had a little left in the tank. How could they let him out of the building? Not that Tomlin or DC would have played him. Sure could have used him last week...

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes that bull rush still works, doesn't it?

ryanh: why do you think tomlin decided not to make any changes to his defensive staff

Ray Fittipaldo: I think he believes in his defense and his coaches. If they go heavy on defense in the draft again I think you'll see they think there are still issues with their personnel.

Advertise with us

John: Why would the Browns be interested in our exOC?

Ray Fittipaldo: For all his faults, Haley did have some productive offenses with the Steelers. I suppose they believe he's worth the risk. Considering where they've been, why not?

Bodine from 5 Towers: Ray, there are a couple decent ILBs who are FAs now: Navarro Bowman and Demario Davis. Why not sign 1-2 of them and draft an ILB who can be developed? I don't think there are other Ryan Shaziers out there.

Ray Fittipaldo: I think Bowman is 29. That's not an ideal age to sign someone. He'd be a stop-gap. But maybe the Steelers would consider him given where they are: at the end of a Super Bowl window with a QB who wants to play three more years. So maybe that's not out of the question. It would just go against who they've approached free agency in the past. They always tend to gravitate toward guys who are 25 or 26 and can play for five more years or so.

Big Lou: Noticed Tom Brady ran a quarterback sneak. Perhaps it could inspire the Steelers to do the same when the occasion arises?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes that is an effective play, isn't it?

Dan: In your opinion do the Patriots receive preferential treatment from the officials?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know about preferential treatment, but they certainly had some calls go their way yesterday. There was the early whistle on the Myles Jack fumble recovery. There was the pass interference penalty. They got the calls. They always seem to get the calls. But you have to give them credit for trying to go deep. The Jaguars didn't do that. Put the game in the hands of the officials once in a while, and you might get a call. The Jaguars were content to hand off and got too conservative in my opinion.

Jack D: Hi Ray, What do you think it’s gonna take for us to reach an agreement with Le’veon? Or do you think the Steelers believe they won’t resign him?

Ray Fittipaldo: $14.5 million for one year. They offered him $42 million over three years last year. They might offer that again, but if Bell turned it down then why would he change his mind this year?

Advertise with us

Zack B: Why not look at the secondary and lb's coaches? Bud has not progressed and Burns/Davis are not where he should be. Does Bud even get sacks anymore?

Ray Fittipaldo: Dupree and Watt dropped into coverage a lot last season because of the way they were playing -- rushing with four an dropping seven into coverage when they could. That's the way they liked to play. They have to ask themselves this offseason if that's the best way to approach things. They invested first-round picks in those guys. The 3-4 defense is built around LBs. If you're not allowing them to rush are you really getting the most out of them? I'm sure that's a discussion they'll have this winter.

jim: I like our offense and other than maybe a RB, shouldn't we go all defense in the coming draft? That 4th rounder for McDonald seems a bit steep now that we've seen him play, agree?

Ray Fittipaldo: They only dropped a few draft slots in the trade for McDonald. They just have to decide if they're going to pay him $4 million or whatever he is going to make next season. They obviously like him so it seems like they will pick it up.

jim: We have been a poor defense for years, which is stopping us from getting number 7. With Tomlin being a defensive coach, what is going on? Poor drafting, poor coaching? Something seems amiss.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: To me, the run defense is the biggest issue. Look at the AFC championship game yesterday. The Pats were able to keep Fournette in check in the second half. The Steelers were never able to do that. Fix the run defense and I think the Steelers defense will get better. They have to figure out this offseason why their run defense hasn't been as good in recent years and fix it.

Mongo: don't steeler fans realize if Tomlin was fired 31 other teams would fire their Coach to hire him?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not 31 but a good many would hire him.

Rick: Hey Ray,like your chats and honesty....I said to Gerry last week it seems Tomlin has lost this team..He said Tomlin nor cowher has never lost a team but then a few days later he writes a piece on how players and some coaches have shown up late or missed meetings.That to me is he is losing the team..What say you?

Ray Fittipaldo: Ed wrote the story on Bell being tardy, etc. When people say "losing the team" I think of players ignoring the coach, tuning him out. That clearly is not the case with the Steelers and Tomlin. His players like him. I think what people on the outside are asking is whether Tomlin is too buddy-buddy with his players. Does he let them get away with too much? There is a fine line when you coach star players and the Steelers have a lot of them. Obviously, people in the building are tiring of the shenanigans because they're telling us about it, but I don't think it's to the point where Art Rooney II is listening to the chatter.

Advertise with us

jim: Do you think we could win with Connor, Ridley and say a 2nd or 3rd round RB from the draft? Seems like too much money and headache for Bell.

Ray Fittipaldo: I think Bell is a great player, but I do think the Steelers could win without him.

Mike: Do the Steelers view James Conner as a potential replacement to LeVeon if things don't work out or will we go to draft for help. Thanks

Ray Fittipaldo: Not sure. He gets hurt a lot. They'd definitely have to have a strong backup plan if they did view him as a No. 1 option.

GSL: Following up a previous response , do you beleiev that the Steelers have been recruiting payers that are smart enough to execute their assignments or that the inconsistent and erratic defensive play (as ultimately epitomized in that Jacksonville game) is due to poor coaching?

Ray Fittipaldo: Whether it's one or the other the Steelers have to figure it out. If the defense is too complicated then simplify it. If you don't want to simplify the defense then get players on the field who can execute without making mental errors.

gary@northernVirginia: Ray, do you see the Steelers defensive problems as more a lack of discipline/execution/coaching than from a lack of talent?

Ray Fittipaldo: Probably a mixture of everything you mentioned. But I'm like a lot of people out there. I wonder how a team like the Steelers can have mental lapses and communication errors in Week 18. That's crazy that the Jaguars got so many big plays from their offense because the Steelers failed to execute their defense. If you just play straight up you'd have a better chance to win even if you don't think certain players are good enough at certain positions.

jim: What do you think is the reason we have a hard time establishing the run with a supposedly all-pro line? Shouldn't we be the ones dominating the offensive line of scrimmage, not being dominated? Happened too often this year.

Ray Fittipaldo: Some of it might have to do with Bell's running style. That's why I'm curious how this team would run without him. Again, I acknowledge his greatness, but I just wonder about that style and whether the linemen are being blamed when it's maybe not all their fault.

Ray Fittipaldo: OK have to run to a meeting. We'll do it again next week.