Ed Bouchette: Good afternoon, let's begin

Steve: Ed, If James Harrison wins another ring as a Patriot in two weeks, is he more of a "sure" candidate for the Hall of Fame? 3 Rings ~ 4-5 All+Pro seasons D Player of the Year etc..

Ed Bouchette: No, he's still borderline and I don't think he'll make it. Not enough number of sacks

Steve in Baltimore: Ed, can the Steelers trade Mr. Bell before the draft and recoup something for him, i.e. draft picks, players or combo? Thanks

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: They cannot trade him unless he's signed and if you recall, he did not sign his franchise tag until Monday before the regular-season opener. I don't think they'll come to terms on a multiple-year deal either. So, I don't see a trade.

Bob R: Joe Haden will have a pretty substantial cap hit next season (I believe $9 mil). Do you see anyway that he becomes a cap casualty? He played well last year and it would seem imperative that he return.

Ed Bouchette: No. If anything, they should try to sign him to a long-term deal.

Bob R: I don't see how the Steelers can commit to Bud Dupree's 5th year option. He has shown flashes but not enough at this point to be one of the 10 highest paid at the position. Do the Steelers take a chance that Bud will break out in 2018 or decline the 5th year option?

Ed Bouchette: I don't see that either.

Advertise with us

Bob R: How active do you see the Steelers being in free agency this year? We all know their philosophy with free agency but this is a super bowl contender with major holes at ILB and S.

Ed Bouchette: They won't have a lot of cap room so it will be looking for bargains again and the draft. They desperately need a ILB

vut5686: Ed You tend to go lite on Steeler coaches and management, holding up their 13=3 as proof of how great they are. Other PPG writers venture into the waters of what could have been and where the blame lies. Who decides who will be good cop-bad cop at the PPG?

Ed Bouchette: This ain't a precinct, it's a newspaper. I don't check with others when I write except maybe the boss.

FajitaGringo: Can a signed Franchised Taged Player be traded?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: If he's signed, yes

TXSTEELER : Is it me or does everybody seem to forget how many of the great Bill Cowher’s teams failed in the Playoffs/AFC Championship game (often when favorited) and that people were ready to run him out of here? Lot of revisionist history going on with fans right now.

Ed Bouchette: Indeed. Doesn't mean Bill was a bad coach either. But Steelers had 5 AFC title games at home with him and they lost 4 of them.

Moose: Draft needs by priority in your opinion? Looks like another LB heavy one to me. Week class for TE's as well.

Ed Bouchette: ILB is priority No. 1. Can use safety, OLB and, if they let Bell walk, a RB

Advertise with us

JohnK: Hey Ed. Has there been in time, since the Noll era began, where the Rooneys have interceded in the hiring and firing of assistants? Or do they always stand with the coach's decision(s) in those matters?

Ed Bouchette: They helped push out LeBeau and Arians. In 1988, Dan Rooney made Noll fire some coaches and was going to do it again after 1991 season, but Noll retired instead. Tomlin was told to keep some coaches when he came aboard,

Steeler Joe: If Bell were allowed to walk, what round would the comp pick be? Is there such a thing as a second-round comp pick? Seems like if there is, he would qualify...

Ed Bouchette: Picks begin in the third round. If Bell leaves as a free agent, Steelers most likely would get a third rounder in 2019 for him.

JerseySteel: Hi Ed - it seems like the OL had a good year in pass protection, not as good in the run game. Thoughts?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Steelers run game was inconsistent in 2017 but I'm not ready to put the entire blame on the line. Bell has to take some of it and they never had confidence in him as a short-yardage power runner. I think they need to find one of them, or let Conner do it.

jpuhala: Ed, With the way the defense was toward the end of the season, after do you think it is time to overhaul the defensive coaching staff and release some players ?

Ed Bouchette: No.

SeanInIowa: Hi, Ed. After this season, pretty tired of the clown show. Any chance Steelers let Bell walk and get serious about team-first culture?

Ed Bouchette: I think they could let him walk, but I think it would have more to do with his demands and the price of the franchise tage at $14.57 M than other stuff

Advertise with us

SteelerJunky: I read somewhere that the Patriots set an NFL record this season with the fewest amount of penalties. Suspicious?

Ed Bouchette: Maybe they just are a disciplined team.

Steve: Ed - do you think the Steelers would consider letting Gilbert go and signing Hubbard to a long term deal? Also, Maybe placing the non exclusive tag on Bell and see if he finds his way out of town?

Ed Bouchette: I think they will stay with Gilbert. No one is going to sign Bell and forfeit two first-round picks.

Patxi from Bilbao : Who do you think is the next Steelers player to enter the HOF? Faneca, Ward, Polamalu...?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Faneca a finalist for the third time but hasn't made progress in the vote yet. Probably Troy

Tim from Big T Country: Hello Ed. I read in Paul Z story about if Steelers sign Bell to a franchise tag then he leaves via Free Agency then the Steelers get two first round picks. Does that mean he plays for the Steelers in 2018 then leaves by free agency in 2109 we get the picks. That doesn't sound right. Your thoughts . Thank You

Ed Bouchette: If the Steelers would sign Bell to another franchise tag and he plays for them in 2018 and then leaves as a free agent after that season, the Steelers would get a comp pick in 2020 draft. If he leaves this year, they would get comp pick in 2018 draft.

Chuck: Do you agree w Peter King that Bell will not be in PItt in 2018 and land w the highest bidder? He likes Oak as a fit.

Ed Bouchette: I just don't see them keeping him under his long-term demands or the huge franchise tag. They don't have a lot of cap room and that would gobble up that and more.

Advertise with us

Robert: You mentioned before Sutton a possibility at S. That's a terrific idea. Is that something the too far out the box for the steelers?

Ed Bouchette: No, it shouldn't be. I'm not saying that will happen, just pointing it out as a possibility.

Patxi from Bilbao : Is everyone of the steelers that made the pro bowl playing this sunday?

Ed Bouchette: I haven't heard of anyone backing out yet. I think the fact the coaching staff is there and so many teammates they will all go.

Reg3835: Will McDonald be a cap casualty this offseason? He played well but was always hurt.

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: He wasn't always hurt. I think they should keep him. His salary is only $3.7 million. He also has another $900,000 in bonuses due.

Felix: Can we assume DHB, Gay & Sensabaugh will be cut to save on cap space?

Ed Bouchette: I can't see them carrying Gay again. Sensabaugh has $1.4 salary but did not reach expectations. Tomlin likes DHB, who has $1.2 M salary. All according to OverTheCap

Since 1972: They named a video game after a coach that was 1-7 in AFC championship games

Ed Bouchette: And he made the Pro FB Hall of Fame

Advertise with us

Jake from Raleigh: I'm just assuming that Shazier isn't playing next year. How does his salary work against the cap space if that's the case. Allow for a FA ILB to come in?

Ed Bouchette: Ryan signed his fifth-year option so he counts $8.7 million against their cap this year.

Felix: Will the Steelers tender Eli Rogers who is an RFA ?

Ed Bouchette: Mmmmm, maybe not because of the ACL injury. No one else will sign him with that anyway.

Evan : Outside of Bell situation, that side of the balll looks stable. Focus of FA & the draft HAS TO BE to get the defense fixed right?? Top 3 picks will be D?

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: Yes, they must focus on the defense but if Bell leaves, they need to draft a stud RB

atown jason: Randy Fichtner ran an uptempo offense ar Memphis that mixed in good running backs. Think we will see more no-huddle (with Ben letting the clock drain to see the defense) next year?

Ed Bouchette: I think it's possible we will see more no huddle. There will be a smooth transition because terminology, etc., will remain but Randy will add his touch.

Steelr4Life: Do you think the Steelers should move away from grooming ex-players as coaches? Just because they were great individual players, that doesn't mean they are destined for greatness as coaches

Ed Bouchette: It depends on what player-to-coaches you mean -- ex Steelers players or just ex NFL players? Because Mike Munchak, in my opinion, is one of the best line coaches in the league. Dick LeBeau was a pretty good defensive coordinator in his prime.

Advertise with us

Jim: What do your sources think about Haley being hired by the Browns? Any of them surprised?

Ed Bouchette: I haven't asked anyone about it. He was well received by the media in Cleveland, though, from what I saw.

Calf Bill: ED, Cluch leaves and Pitt has tears. If Bell leaves will there be tears or cheers. Thanks for all the past chats.

Ed Bouchette: I'm sure there will be a mix of both.

Andrew: Would Bill Cowher have lasted as long as he did if social media existed? 1998 7-9 1999 6-10 2000 9-7 2003 6-10

Advertise with us

Ed Bouchette: I don't think the Rooneys react to either social media or disgruntled limited partners on that matter.

Bring Back Troy : Will Art Rooney II directly tell Coach Tomlin to pay more attention to player discipline/focus next year?

Ed Bouchette: I don't think he will order him. I do think it will be a topic of discussion.

Bigmike: Ed, on the supposed James Harrison strip sack it wasn't actually Harrison that did the sack or strip it was Kyle Van Noy, think Steelers fans overreacted quite a bit because the announcers messed it up. Harrison did not get any credited for any sacks in that game.

Ed Bouchette: You are correct. He was credited with three tackles, no sacks. But he did have two pressures that helped lead to sacks.

Advertise with us

Andy MD: Should the Steelers just offer the same contract from last yr with no franchise tag prior to free agency? in essence letting Bell walk due to immediate needs in the defense?

Ed Bouchette: They can offer him anything they want. He can accept or reject anything. But I don't think he would take the offer they gave him last year.

Oscar: Planning a trip to Super Bowl LII or someplace warm?

Ed Bouchette: I'll be at the Super Bowl.

ScottS: Does the team factor the likely landing place(s) of a player like Bell when deciding whether or not to let him walk - to minimize his affect on the team?

Ed Bouchette: You mean like they did not do with James Harrison and Blount?

fla: what is the difference between a non exclusive tag and a franchise tag?

Ed Bouchette: They are both franchise tags. One requires another team to pony up 2 first-round picks if they sign him. The other in essence allows him not to sign elsewhere. To me, there's no difference.

Paul L: How does Munchak's role with the team grow? What position would challenge him more?

Ed Bouchette: Since they already named their coordinator, he will remain the line coach. I could see them adding a title, maybe "associate head coach" or something.

Ed Bouchette: Thank you for another great chat. I'm not sure about next Tuesday yet because of interviews at Super Bowl. I'll check with the boss and get back to you