History is against the Washington Capitals, who play the Penguins Wednesday night in Game 7. The Penguins have won eight of nine postseason series against the Capitals, twice taking a Game 7 in Washington.
The Capitals haven’t made it past the second round of the playoffs during the Alex Ovechkin era. Barry Trotz hasn’t made it past the second round in nine postseason trips as a coach, two with Washington and seven with Nashville.
PG Live: Who will win Pens-Caps Game 7?
The home crowd at the Verizon Center will turn vicious if the Capitals get off to a slow start, worse even than the ugly way the PPG Paints Arena crowd turned on the Penguins in their 5-2 home loss Monday night in Game 6.
History is on the Penguins’ side. NHL teams that took a 3-1 series lead went on to win it 90.5 percent (268-28) of the time. It’s not as if the Penguins players haven’t been there and done that in big games.
Last season, on their way to the Stanley Cup, they lost Game 5 in overtime to Tampa Bay before winning Games 6 and 7. Going back to their Cup year in 2009, they won Game 7 at Washington after losing Game 6 at home. That Game 7 was the night Marc-Andre Fleury stopped Ovechkin on a breakaway early in a scoreless game, moments before Sidney Crosby scored to give the Penguins a 1-0 lead on their way to a 6-2 win.
They also lost Game 5 at Detroit in the Cup final with Fleury being pulled in a 5-0 defeat. They and Fleury bounced back to win Games 6 and 7, 2-1 each time.
History says it will be all Penguins Wednesday night.
So why do I have so many doubts?
I picked the Capitals in seven games before the series, mostly because Kris Letang wasn’t playing for the Penguins. I didn’t see enough in the first six games to change my mind.
The Penguins looked like a beaten hockey club Monday night. That didn’t just show on the scoreboard. It showed in the way they played. The speed advantage they brag about was missing. They couldn’t get the puck out of their own zone. On the rare occasions when they did, they couldn’t mount anything in the Capitals’ end.
Not having Letang has been more and more of a killer as the series has progressed. He is terrific with the breakout, often skating the puck out of danger. His offense has been missing. Justin Schultz has two goals against the Capitals and Ron Hainsey got one in the first-round series against Columbus. That’s it from the defensemen in 11 games. The physical edge Letang has also has been missing. He wouldn’t be afraid to bang around the Washington forwards the way the Capitals have done to the Penguins’ forwards.
Losing Trevor Daley — the team’s other puck-moving defenseman — hurt in Game 6. The other defensemen appear to be breaking down physically despite the best efforts of the coaching staff to limit their minutes. The six primary defensemen have played between Daley’s average ice time of 18:27 and Brian Dumoulin’s 20:46. But that doesn’t mean that a fierce forecheck from the opposition hasn’t taken its toll.
The Penguins faced one from Columbus and are facing another from Washington. Ian Cole, who had such a strong year, was a minus-5 in the past two games. Hainsey, in the first postseason of his long career, had a horrible play along the boards in Game 6, losing the puck to Andre Burakovsky, leading to the Capitals’ second goal. Those are just two examples.
“We’re spending way too much time in our end,” Matt Cullen said. “That falls on all of us. Our defensemen are under siege a lot and we, as forwards, are not helping them out. We’re not getting to our game. It’s all of us. You can’t point your finger at anybody. We all have to be better.”
The Capitals have done such a fabulous job pinning the Penguins in their own end zone that the Penguins’ high-powered offense has struggled to get going. The Penguins had just 18 shots on goaltender Braden Holtby in the loss in Game 6, 22 in the 4-2 loss in Game 5 and 18 in their 3-2 win in Game 4.
For the series, the Capitals have outshot them, 200-132. Washington probably should have won the series already and would have won it if the Penguins’ scorers hadn’t been so opportunistic in the early games and Marc-Andre Fleury hadn’t been so phenomenal.
Evgeni Malkin leads all NHL players with 18 playoff points but hasn’t been the difference-maker we have come to expect. Neither has Sidney Crosby or Phil Kessel. And don’t even ask about the Penguins’ usually reliable secondary scorers. Bryan Rust has no points in six games, Conor Sheary no goals in 10, Patric Hornqvist one goal in seven, Nick Bonino no goals in five and Chris Kunitz no goals in six.
It’s no wonder the Capitals will be a confident group in Game 7, all due respect to the Penguins, of course.
“We’ve got to be mature about this,” T.J. Oshie told the Washington media after Game 6. “They’re not going to just go away. They’re Stanley Cup champions for a reason.”
Mike Sullivan will tap into the “character” in the Penguins room. He channeled his inner Herb Brooks and his inner Badger Bob Johnson after practice Tuesday when he called Game 7 “a great opportunity …
“These are the games that you live to play in. Our team is excited about this opportunity. We believe in this group. We think we have a good hockey team. It’s the first team to win four games, not three. That’s how we look at it.”
It’s true, anything can happen in a Game 7. Puck luck could be on the Penguins’ side. The right bounce here. An official’s call there. A power-play goal here. A successful penalty-kill there. Fleury could outplay Holtby again. Malkin, Crosby and Kessel are capable of big games. Any of the secondary scorers could step up and make a difference.
But I don’t see it happening.
I’m thinking the Penguins lost the series in Game 3 after Malkin and Schultz scored in the final 1:53 to make it 2-2 and the team was just an overtime goal from taking a 3-0 lead. Or maybe they lost it in Game 5 when they couldn’t protect the 2-1 lead they took into the third period with a chance to eliminate the Capitals. The Penguins had been 76-1-1 the past two seasons when leading after two periods.
It should officially end for the Penguins Wednesday night.
That will be especially disappointing because the winner is going on to win the Cup.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.